Cap'n Morgan's Menu and Prices

4.4 based on 135 votes
Cap'n Morgan's Logo

Choose My State

NY

Cap'n Morgan's Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


GreensDressings: french, italian, ranch, peppercorn parmesan, honey mustard, 1000 island, raspberry vinaigrette, bleu cheese

Seafood Cobb Salad

$8.98

Shrimp, scallops, bacon and crab meat over fresh greens with tomato, artichokes, onion and a side of raspberry vinaigrette dressing

Chef Salad

$8.98

Fresh greens topped with ham, turkey, cheese, egg and croutons

Chef Salad - Lighter Portion

$5.98

Buffalo Chicken Salad

$7.98

Fried chicken pieces tossed in choice of buffalo sauce with julienne vegetables, crumbly bleu cheese, salsa and six feet of snow

Taco Salad

$7.98

Seasoned beef over lettuce with cheddar cheese, tomato, black olives, jalapenos, salsa and sour cream, served in a taco shell

Chicken Spiedie Salad

$7.98

Marinated chicken, onions, peppers and mushrooms over fresh greens

Caesar Topper Salad

$8.98

Romaine lettuce topped with grilled chicken or shrimp, parmesan cheese and croutons

Caesar Topper Salad - Lighter Portion

$5.98

House Salad

$3.58

Fresh greens with tomato, cheese and croutons, served with choice of dressing


Fresh Homemade Soup

She Crab

$3.98 - $4.98

Shrimp Jambalaya

$3.98 - $4.98

Soup of the Day

$3.98 - $4.98


Seafood EntreesServed with choice of soup or salad

Crab Stuffed Shrimp

$18.98 - $12.98

Jumbo shrimp stuffed with our lobster crab meat and topped with a garlic cream sauce, served with choice of side

Lobster Crab Cakes

$17.98 - $11.98

Succulent crab cakes made with lump maryland bluecrab and chunks of maine lobster. Served with a chesapeake Imperial mayo and choice of side

Smokey Mountain Boiled Scallops

$16.98

Bacon wrapped scallops lightly dusted with cajun seasoning, covered with BBQ sauce, served with bacon cheddar smashed potatoes and bourbon beans

Cranberry Salmon

$18.98

Pan-seared sockeye salmon filet topped with a cranberry infused butter cream sauce, served over rice pilaf

Tilapia Filet

$15.98

Pamesan herb crusted tilapia filet topped with artichoke, fresh tomatoes and capers and light lemon and garlic butter sauce, served with choice of side

Fish Fry

$11.98

Yuengling beer battered haddock with choice of side


Pasta LoversServed with choice of soup or salad

Seafood Lovers Pasta

$16.98

Crab meat, shrimp, scallop, mangos, peppers, onions and mushrooms sauteed tossed flo sauce with pesto and served over penne pasta

Lobster Ravioli

$15.98 - $9.98

Lobster and cheese stuffed ravioli with a sherry and herb butter sauce

Fettucini Alfredo

$15.98 - $9.98

Creamy, rich alfredo sauce served over fettucini served with chicken or shrimp


WingsMild, medium, hot, BBQ, sweet-n-sour, grilled jerk, garlic, honey jalapeno BBQ, lemon pepper, smoked jalapeno BBQ, naked, raspberry habanero, off jerk

Wings

$4.98 - $8.98


Cast Off

Cap'n Shrimp

$6.98

Lobster Crab Cake

$8.98

Gator Bites

$9.98

Bacon Wrapped Scallops

$7.98

Italian Buffalo Calamari

$8.98

Hot Crab & Artichoke Dip

$8.98

Nacho Supreme

$8.98

Boneless Wings

$8.98

Pierogi T'sers

$5.98

Mozzarella Stix

$6.98


All Hands on DeckServed with homemade potato chips. Substitute a side for $1.78

Caribbean Dip

$7.98

Grilled chicken, roasted peppers, pepperjack cheese and a spicy chili and cilantro pesto on texas toast with some kind of dipping sauce

Turkey Club

$7.98

With lettuce, cheese, bacon, tomato and mayo

Bayou Burger

$7.98

Carmelized onions and mushrooms with pepperjack cheese on a blackened seasoned burger

Philly Cheese Wrap

$8.98

Raost beef with cheese, peppers, onions, lettuce and philly sauce in a tortilla wrap

Chicken Speedie Wrap

$7.98

Marinated chicken, cheese, peppers, onions and lettuce all wrapped up

Cheeseburger in Paradise

$7.98

Heinz 57 and french fried potatoes

Seafood Cobb Wrap

$8.98

Shrimp, scallops, bacon, crab meat, artichoke, onion, tomato and lettuce

Buffalo Chicken Wrap

$7.98

Fried chicken tossed in wing sauce with lettuce, tomato and bleu cheese dressing

Surf Burger

$7.98

Blacken seasoned burger topped with crab meat and cheddar cheese

Jamaican Jerk Burger

$8.98

Jerk seasoned burger topped with a cajun salsa and pepperjack cheese

Veggie Burger

$7.98

Garden burger topped with lettuce, tomato and onion on a kaiser roll


Beef LoversServed with soup or salad and choice of side

Cap'n Morgan's Sizzlin Steak

$18.98

12 oz. center cut USDA angus sirloin marinated and char-grilled, served on a sizzling cast iron skillet with frizzled onions and garlic au jus

BBQ Ribs

$21.98 - $12.98

St. lois pork ribs smothered in our homemade BBQ sauce

New York Strip Steak

$19.98

14 oz. center cut USDA choice strip loin grilled to perfection


Raw Bar & Steamers

Steamed Littlenecks

Price may varies

Steamed Mussles

Price may varies

Steamed or Raw Oysters

Price may varies

Steamed Peel & Eat Shrimp

Price may varies


Dinner BuffetBuffets are served with salad, bread, coffee, tea or soda. Person

Choose 2 Entrees, 1 Starch and 1 Vegetable

$16.98

Entree: ham with pineapples and cherries, roast beef with rosemary au jus, spicy pork with cranberry, baked chicken, penne pasta with vegetables in a wine sauce. Starch: garlic mashed, caribbean rice

Choose 3 Entrees, 2 Starch and 2 Vegetable

$18.98

Entree: ham with pineapples and cherries, roast beef with rosemary au jus, spicy pork with cranberry, baked chicken, penne pasta with vegetables in a wine sauce. Starch: garlic mashed, caribbean rice

Choose 3 Entrees, 3 Starch and 3 Vegetable

$20.98

Entree: ham with pineapples and cherries, roast beef with rosemary au jus, spicy pork with cranberry, baked chicken, penne pasta with vegetables in a wine sauce. Starch: garlic mashed, caribbean rice


Sides

French Fries

$2.78

Rice Pilaf

$1.98

Curly Fries

$2.98

Vegetable Medley

$1.98

Bacon Cheddar Smashed Potatoes

$2.58

Boardwalk Fries

$2.98

Apple Sauce

$1.58


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading