Menu With Price > Menu > Caffrey's Deli & Subs

Caffrey's Deli & Subs Menu and Prices

4.1 based on 134 votes

Deli Food

Choose My State

Caffrey's Deli & Subs Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14

Specialty Cold Subs7" white or wheat sub roll - Upgrade to 14" for only $6.55 more. All subs prepared as listed

#1 The Vegetable Sandwich*

$6.55

Muenster & Provolone with Lettuce, Tomato, Roasted Red Pepper, Cucumber, Red Onion, Italian Dressing & Mayo

#2 Middle Class Club

$7.95

Turkey, Ham, Bacon & Swiss with Lettuce, Tomato & Honey Mustard

#3 Lake Street Italian

$7.95

Ham, Capicola, Salami, Pepperoni & Provolone with Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion, & Italian Dressing

#4 Adult Club

$7.95

Chicken Salad & Bacon with Lettuce, Tomato and Mayo

#5 The PC

$7.95

Turkey, Capicola & Provolone with Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo, and Cherry Pepper Relish

#6 Keep up with the Jones'

$7.95

Roast Beef, Turkey, Swiss & Cheddar with Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo & Straight Horseradish

Specialty Hot Subs7" white or wheat sub roll - Upgrade to 14" for only $6.55 more. All subs prepared as listed

#7 Hot Shot Italian

$7.95

Grilled Ham, Capicola, Salami, Pepperoni & Provolone with Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion, & Italian Dressing

#8 Three Pepper Chicken*

$7.95

Grilled Chicken Breast with Lettuce, Tomato, Pepper Mix & Mayo

#9 New Yorker

$7.95

Now w/ More Meat! Grilled Pastrami, Turkey & Swiss with Deli Mustard

#10 BBQ Beef

$7.95

Now Recipe! BBQ Beef with Red Onions

#11 The Ranch Gobbler

$7.75

Grilled Smoked Turkey, Melted Cheddar with Lettuce, Tomato & Ranch Dressing

#12 The Blue Cow

$8.95

Grilled Roast Beef, Blue Cheese Crumbles & Bacon with Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion & Mayo

Cheese Steak SubsMake it a Combo: Chips, Macaroni Salad, Potato Salad or Coleslaw with a Soda - add $2.49

#13 Simple Philly

$6.95

Just Grilled Steak & Provolone Cheese

#14 Loaded Philly

$7.55

Grilled Steak, Grilled Onions, Green Peppers, Mushrooms & Provolone Cheese

#15 Italian Philly

$7.95

Our Loaded Philly (above) with Grilled Pepperoni & Tomato Sauce

#16 Simple Chicken Philly

$6.95

Just Grilled Chicken & Provolone Cheese

#17 Loaded Chicken Philly

$7.55

Grilled Chicken, Grilled Onions, Green Peppers, Mushrooms & Provolone Cheese

#18 Italian Chicken Philly

$7.95

Our Loaded Chicken Philly (above) with Grilled Pepperoni & Tomato Sauce

Traditional Hotties

#19 Reuben

$8.25

Grilled Corned Beef with Kraut, 1,000 Island & Swiss Cheese on Grilled Rye

#20 Rachel

$8.25

Reuben (see above) made with Turkey instead of Corned Beef on Grilled Rye

#21 Grilled Cheese Please

$6.45

Muenster, Provolone, Cheddar & Tomato on Grilled Sourdough

#22 Hot Ham & Swiss

$7.25

Grilled Ham & Swiss with Mayo & Deli Mustard on Grilled Sourdough

#23 Hot Pastrami

$7.25

Grilled Pastrami, Swiss & Deli Mustard on Grilled Rye

#24 Havin' a Ball

$7.50

Sliced Italian Meatballs, Tomato Sauce, & Provolone Cheese on a 7" Sub Roll

Deli Sandwiches & SubsAdd Extras to your sandwich. Comes with Lettuce, Tomato & Mayo - Turkey, Ham & Swiss, BLT, Smoked Turkey, Tuna Salad, Egg Salad, Roast Beef, Chicken Salad. Comes with Lettuce, Tomato & Mustard - Salami & Provolone, Pastrami, Corned Beef

Deli Sandwiches & Subs

$4.95 - $12.99

On What Bread: White or Wheat, 7" Sub Roll, Sliced Sourdough or Rye, Plain or Spinach Tortillas

PB & J

$3.50

Sandwich Special

$6.50

Half "Lite" Deli Sandwich & Half Salad or Cup pf Soup

Salads & WrapsGet any salad AS A WRAP (dressing included) tucked into a plain or spinach tortilla. Dressings: Ranch, Blue Cheese, 1000 Island, Honey Mustard, Caesar, Italian, Raspberry

Garden Green

$3.25 - $4.75

Lettuce, Tomato, Cucumbers, Red Onion & Green Peppers

Club

$4.25 - $6.95

Garden Green with Ham, Turkey & Swiss

Grilled Chicken

$4.25 - $6.95

Garden Green with Grilled Chicken Breast

Salad Salad

$4.25 - $6.75

Garden Green w/ Chicken, Egg or Tuna salad

Spinach

$4.25 - $6.95

Spinach, Tomato, Cucumber, Red Onion, & Blue Cheese Crumbles

Caesar

$3.95 - $5.85

Romaine, Parmesan, & Croutons

Extras

Meat

$1.75

Chicken Breast

$1.50

Vegan Chicken

$1.75

Steak

$2.50

Bacon

$1.25

Jalapenos

Banana Peppers

Roasted Red Peppers

$0.50

Cherry Pepper Relish

$0.50

Hummus

$0.75

Real Horseradish

$0.50

Cheese

$1.00

Side of Dressing

$0.75

Cucumbers

$0.75

Scoop O' Chicken Salad

$2.50

Scoop O' Egg Salad

$2.50

Pepper Mix

$0.50

Red Onion

Mayo

Tomato

Lettuce

Oil/Vinegar

Mustard

Pickles

Whole Dill Pickle

$0.95

Half Dill Pickle

$0.55

Jalapeno Pickle Spears

$0.30

Soup

Vegan & Vegetarian Options Daily

$3.95 - $4.55

Side Items

Macaroni Salad

$1.39

Potato Salad

$1.39

Coleslaw

$1.39

Fresh Fruit

$2.99

Chips

Price may varies

Original, Garden Salsa, or Harvest Cheddar Sun Chips; Nacho Cheese or Cool Ranch Doritos; Sour Cream & Onion, Regular or Baked Lays; Salt & Vinegar, BBQ, or Jalapeno Mrs. Vickie's Kettle Chips

Desserts

New York Style Cheesecake

$6.50

Topped w/Blueberry, Cherry, Apple Cinnamon or Chocolate Brownie

Sebastian Joe's Ice Cream (1 pint)

$5.95

Brownie

$1.19

Rice Crispie Treats

$0.50

Fresh Baked Cookies

$0.65

Three Cookies

$1.70

Chocolate Chip, Rocky Road, Nut, Oatmeal, or Snicker Doodle

Big Chocolate Chip Cookie

$1.99

Carrot Cake

$3.95

Drinks

Cans of Soda

$1.65

Coke Products, Mountain Dew, Dr. Pepper

Aquafina

$1.25

Vitamin Water & Powerade

$2.09

Minute Maid Juices

$1.85

Honest Tea

$2.49

Starbucks Frappucino

$2.29

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.