Cafe 58 Menu and Prices

4.5 based on 97 votes
Cafe 58 Logo
Coffee
Italian
Pizza
Sandwiches

Choose My State

NY

Cafe 58 Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Beverages

Coffee

$1.00 - $1.49

Tea

$1.00 - $1.49

Decaffeinated Sanka

$1.00 - $1.49

Espresso

$1.49 - $2.75

Latte

$2.49 - $3.75

Cappuccino

$2.49 - $3.75

Americano

$1.49 - $2.75

Abuelita Choco

$1.25 - $1.75

Nestle Chocolate

$1.25 - $1.75

Canned Soda

$1.00

20 oz. Soda

$1.49

2 Liter Soda

$2.25

Jarritos Soda

$2.25

JUMEX Nectar

$2.00

Sunny D

$0.75

Capri Sun

$0.75

Apple and Eve

$0.75

Welches

$0.75

Honest Tea

$2.00

Aloevines

$2.00

Coconut H20

$2.00

Nesquick

$2.00

Red Bull

$2.00

Black Mamba

$2.00

Monster

$2.00

RockStar

$2.00

Arizona Energy

$2.00


Fresh Fruits and Juice

Apple

$1.00

Banana

$1.00

Fruit Salad

$2.49

Orange Juice

$2.95 - $3.75

Strawberries

$2.95

Honey Dew

$2.49

Cantaloupe

$2.49

Grape Fruit

$1.50

Apple Juice

$2.49

Carrot Juice

$2.49

Celery Juice

$2.49

Smoothie

$2.49

Made with yogurt, orange juice, milk and honey.


Student Specials

Student Special Breakfast

$2.99

Includes breakfast sandwich and drink.

Student Special Lunch

$4.99

Includes sandwich, fries and a drink.


Breakfast

2 Eggs Any Style

$4.95

With potatoes and toast.

Steak and Eggs

$6.95

Served with home potatoes and toast or fries.

Huevos Rancheros

$5.95

Two sunny side up eggs on corn tortillas topped with red or green salsa, avocado and queso fresco.

Huevos a la Mexicana

$3.95

With chorizo, onions, jalapenos and tomatoes. Served with rice, beans, tortillas and coffee.


Omelettes

Omelette

$6.49

With your choice of any two ingredients. Served with coffee and potatoes or fruit.


Breakfast Sandwiches

Grilled Cheese on Toast

$2.00

Served on toast.

Eggs on a Roll

$2.00

Bacon, Egg, and Cheese

$2.95 - $3.95

Served on a hero or a roll.

Ham, Egg, and Cheese

$2.95 - $3.95

Served on a hero or a roll.

Sausage, Egg, and Cheese

$2.95 - $3.95

Served on a hero or a roll.

Western Sandwich

$2.95 - $3.95

Served on a hero or a roll with ham, eggs, onions and peppers.

Hamwich

$2.95 - $3.95

Toasted croissant with ham and Swiss cheese.


Pancakes

Pancakes with Syrup and Butter

$3.95

Three pancakes, served with coffee or tea.

Pancakes with Bananas

$5.49

Three pancakes, served with coffee or tea.

Pancakes with Strawberries

$5.49

Three pancakes, served with coffee or tea.

Pancakes with Chocolate Chips

$4.95

Three pancakes, served with coffee or tea.

Pancakes with Chocolate Syrup

$4.95

Three pancakes, served with coffee or tea.

Pancakes with Eggs

$5.25

Three pancakes with eggs, any style, served with coffee or tea.

Pancakes with Eggs and Bacon

$6.25

Three pancakes with eggs, any style, served with coffee or tea.

Pancakes with Eggs and Ham

$6.25

Three pancakes with eggs, any style, served with coffee or tea.

Pancakes with Eggs and Sausage

$6.25

Three pancakes with eggs, any style, served with coffee or tea.


Pastries

Toast

$1.00

Bagel with Butter

$1.00

Bagel w/ Cream Cheese

$1.49

Bagel w/ Lox & Cream Cheese

$4.95

Croissant

$1.50

Fresh Mexican Bread

$1.25

Muffin

$1.25


Appetizers

French Fries

$1.49 - $2.49

Buffalo Chicken Wings

$5.49

7 pieces.

Chicken Fingers

$5.49

6 pieces.

Mozzarella Sticks

$5.25

6 pieces.

Fried Calamari

$5.95

Fresh Broccoli

$5.95

With garlic roasted peppers.

Fresh Mozzarella

$5.95

With tomatoes.

Fried Shrimp

$3.75

15 pieces.

Empanada

$2.00

Salchi Papas

$3.49

Tostones

$2.00

Maduros

$2.00

Fruit and Cheeses

$4.95

House Salad

$3.95

Greens.


Nachos, Quesadillas & Tostadas

Crispy Tortillas Nachos

$4.99

With beans, sour cream, jalapenos, guacamole and cheese.

Tostada

$1.75

Crispy tortilla with beans, sour cream, lettuce, cheese and red or green salsa.

Tacos

$2.25

With onions, cilantro, guacamole and red or green salsa.

Chicharron Quesadilla

$5.49

With your choice of flour or corn tortillas.

Steak Quesadilla

$5.49

With your choice of flour or corn tortillas.

Chicken Quesadilla

$5.49

With your choice of flour or corn tortillas.

Pollo and Chiptole Sause Quesadilla

$5.49

With your choice of flour or corn tortillas.

3 Queso Quesadilla

$5.49

With your choice of flour or corn tortillas.

Shrimp Quesadilla

$5.49

With your choice of flour or corn tortillas.

Chorizo Quesadilla

$5.49

With your choice of flour or corn tortillas.

Vegetable Quesadilla

$5.49

With your choice of flour or corn tortillas.

Mushroom Quesadilla

$5.49

With your choice of flour or corn tortillas.


Crispy Salads

Caesar Salad

$5.95

Parmesan cheese and croutons.

Chicken Salad

$6.95

Fresh oranges, greens, dressing and tomato.

Vegetable Salad

$5.95

Chopped vegetables and Italian herbs.

COB Salad

$7.50

Chicken, bacon, tomatoes, cucumbers and cheddar cheese.

Mozzarella Salad

$6.49

Peppers, sun-dried tomatoes, olive oil and black pepper.

Tuna Salad

$5.95

Tomatoes, peppers and red onions.


Burgers

Pizza Burger

$3.95

Marinara sauce and melted cheese. 8 oz.

Cheeseburger

$3.49

8 oz.

Mex Burger

$4.49

Jalapeno jack cheese, avocado and onions. 8 oz.

Mushroom and Swiss Burger

$3.95

8 oz.

Turkey Burger

$3.49

8 oz.

Veggie Burger

$3.25

8 oz.

Chicken Burger

$2.95

8 oz.

Deluxe Pizza Burger

$5.95

Marinara sauce and melted cheese with lettuce, tomato, onions, pickles and fries or onion rings. 8 oz.

Deluxe Cheeseburger

$6.49

With lettuce, tomato, onions, pickles and fries or onion rings. 8 oz.

Deluxe Mex Burger

$6.95

Jalapeno jack cheese, avocado and onions with lettuce, tomato, onions, pickles and fries or onion rings. 8 oz.

Deluxe Mushroom and Swiss Burger

$5.95

With lettuce, tomato, onions, pickles and fries or onion rings.

Deluxe Turkey Burger

$5.75

With lettuce, tomato, onions, pickles and fries or onion rings. 8 oz.

Deluxe Veggie Burger

$5.75

With lettuce, tomato, onions, pickles and fries or onion rings. 8 oz.

Deluxe Chicken Burger

$5.49

With lettuce, tomato, onions, pickles and fries or onion rings. 8 oz.


Sandwiches

Sliced Breast of Chicken Sandwich

$5.49

With roasted peppers, tomatoes and low-fat mayonnaise. Served with mixed greens.

Fresh Mozzarella Sandwich

$5.95

With tomatoes and pesto spread on wheat baguette. Served with mixed greens.

Grilled Pesto Sandwich

$5.95

With tomatoes and melted mozzarella on wheat baguette. Served with mixed greens.

Monterey Melt

$5.49

With smoked turkey, roasted peppers and melted jalapeno jack cheese. Served with mixed greens.

Ham & Melted Cheese

$5.95

Served with mixed greens.

Steak Sandwich

$7.50

Flat top meat with grilled onions, served with french fries.


Tortas & Cemitas

Chicken Torta

$5.49

On a soft white Portuguese roll with beans, mayonnaise, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, avocado and jalapenos.

Chicken Cemita

$5.95

With beans, mayonnaise, papalo, onions, cheese, avocado and chipotle on sesame seed bread.

Steak Torta

$5.49

On a soft white Portuguese roll with beans, mayonnaise, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, avocado and jalapenos.

Steak Cemita

$5.95

With beans, mayonnaise, papalo, onions, cheese, avocado and chipotle on sesame seed bread.

Pork Milanese Torta

$5.49

On a soft white Portuguese roll with beans, mayonnaise, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, avocado and jalapenos.

Pork Milanese Cemita

$5.95

With beans, mayonnaise, papalo, onions, cheese, avocado and chipotle on sesame seed bread.

Cecina Torta

$5.95

On a soft white Portuguese roll with beans, mayonnaise, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, avocado and jalapenos.

Cecina Cemita

$5.95

With beans, mayonnaise, papalo, onions, cheese, avocado and chipotle on sesame seed bread.

Lengua Torta

$5.95

On a soft white Portuguese roll with beans, mayonnaise, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, avocado and jalapenos.

Lengua Cemita

$5.95

With beans, mayonnaise, papalo, onions, cheese, avocado and chipotle on sesame seed bread.

Carne Enchilada Torta

$5.49

On a soft white Portuguese roll with beans, mayonnaise, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, avocado and jalapenos.

Carne Enchilada Cemita

$5.95

With beans, mayonnaise, papalo, onions, cheese, avocado and chipotle on sesame seed bread.

Chicken Milanese Torta

$5.49

On a soft white Portuguese roll with beans, mayonnaise, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, avocado and jalapenos.

Chicken Milanese Cemita

$5.95

With beans, mayonnaise, papalo, onions, cheese, avocado and chipotle on sesame seed bread.

Steak Milanese Torta

$5.49

On a soft white Portuguese roll with beans, mayonnaise, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, avocado and jalapenos.

Steak Milanese Cemita

$5.95

With beans, mayonnaise, papalo, onions, cheese, avocado and chipotle on sesame seed bread.

Torta Cubana

$5.95

Ham, carnitas, Swiss cheese, honey mustard and pickles.


Burritos and Chilaquiles

Steak Burrito

$6.95

Steak, rice, refried beans, sour cream, guacamole and cheese. Served with fries or salad.

Chicken Burrito

$6.95

Chicken, rice, refried beans, sour cream, guacamole and cheese. Served with fries or salad.

Shrimp Burrito

$6.95

Shrimp, rice, refried beans, sour cream, guacamole and cheese. Served with fries or salad.

3 Queso Burrito

$6.95

Jalapeno Jack cheese, Hebra and cheddar cheese, rice, refried beans, sour cream, guacamole and cheese. Served with fries or salad.

Vegetable Burrito

$6.95

Vegetables, rice, refried beans, sour cream, guacamole and cheese. Served with fries or salad.

Chilaquiles

$7.49

with queso fresco, cream, onions and Epazote.


Wraps

The Gobble Wrap

$6.49

Smoked turkey, onions, tomato, Swiss cheese and Caesar dressing. Served with fries and a pickle.

La Fajita Wrap

$6.49

Steak or chicken with peppers, onions, avocado and jalapeno jack cheese. Served with fries and a pickle.

Fresh Garden Wrap

$6.49

Pesto, mixed vegetables and mozzarella cheese. Served with fries and a pickle.

Chicken Czar Wrap

$6.49

Romaine, red onions and tomatoes. Served with fries and a pickle.

Wild Tiger Wrap

$6.49

Shrimp, guacamole, lime, peppers and red onions. Served with fries and a pickle.


Triple Deckers

Smoked Ham Triple Decker

$6.49

With American cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise. Served with your choice of side and a pickle.

BLT Triple Decker

$6.49

With American cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise. Served with your choice of side and a pickle.

Steak Triple Decker

$6.49

With American cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise. Served with your choice of side and a pickle.

Chicken Milanese Triple Decker

$6.49

With American cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise. Served with your choice of side and a pickle.

Breast of Chicken Triple Decker

$6.49

With American cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise. Served with your choice of side and a pickle.

Fried Tilapia Triple Decker

$6.49

With American cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise. Served with your choice of side and a pickle.

Sliced Turkey Triple Decker

$6.49

With American cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise. Served with your choice of side and a pickle.

Turkey Czar Sandwich

$6.49

Greens and tomato on white bread. Served with fries.

Virginia Ham Sandwich

$6.49

Mustard, greens and Swiss on rye with fries.

Goat Cheese Sandwich

$6.49

Greens and sun-dried tomatoes on wheat bread.

Fresh Mozzarella Sandwich

$6.49

With pesto, greens and sun-dried tomatoes on wheat bread.


Hot Sandwiches

Tuna Melt

$6.49

Tomatoes and your choice of cheese on your choice of bread. Served with fries or salad.

Monterrey Melt

$6.49

Smoked turkey, peppers, onions and jalapeno jack cheese on your choice of bread. Served with fries or salad.

Chicken Breast

$6.49

Lettuce, tomatoes, peppers and mayonnaise on your choice of bread. Served with fries or salad.

Grilled Veggies Hot Sandwich

$6.49

Carrots, zucchini, broccoli, onions and asparagus on your choice of bread. Served with fries or salad.

Grilled BBQ Chicken Hot Sandwich

$6.49

Tomatoes, jalapeno jack cheese, fries and a pickle.

Philly Cheesesteak

$6.49

Swiss cheese, onions and peppers on your choice of bread. Served with fries or salad.

Chicken Parmigiana Hot Sandwich

$6.49

Marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese on your choice of bread. Served with fries or salad.


Sides

Side of Bacon

$2.49

Side of Ham

$2.49

Side of Sausage

$2.49

Side of Mashed Potato

$2.49

Side of Traditional Rice

$2.49

Side of Seasoned Beans

$2.49

Side of Mixed Garden Vegetables

$2.49

Side of Avocado

$2.49

Side of Spicy Mexican Guacamole

$2.49

Side of Tortilla Chips

$2.49

Side of Red Salsa

$2.49

Side of Green Salsa

$2.49

Side of Chipotle Salsa

$2.49

Side of Corn Tortillas

$1.89


Dessert

Rice Pudding

$1.49

Flan

$2.00

Caramel custard.

Flourless Chocolate Cake

$2.95

Cheesecake

$2.95

Tiramisu

$2.95

Apple Pie

$2.95

Vanilla Ice Cream

$1.49 - $2.75

Chocolate Ice Cream

$1.49 - $2.75

Strawberry Ice Cream

$1.49 - $2.75

Banana Split

$3.95

Triple ice cream, fudge and whipped cream.

Pound Cake

$3.95

Ice cream, fudge, whipped cream and cocoa.

Brownie

$3.95

Ice cream, fudge, whipped cream and cocoa.

Hot Fudge Sundae

$3.95

Chocolate syrup, whipped cream, nuts and a cherry.

Milkshake

$3.95


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading