Cafe 31st Menu and Prices

4.4 based on 72 votes
Cafe 31st Logo
Coffee
Italian

Choose My State

NY

Cafe 31st Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Appetizers

Maryland Crab Cake

Price may varies

Jumbo lump crab cake, served with tartar sauce

Jumbo Party Buffalo Wings

Price may varies

Served with blue cheese, buffalo hot sauce, carrots and celery

Chicken Fingers

Price may varies

Lightly fried and served with honey mustard and french fries

Baked Clams Oreganata

Price may varies

Whole clams seasoned and baked with spicy bread crumbs, oregano, garlic and fresh lemon sauce

Calamari Fritti

Price may varies

Fresh and tender squid deep fried till golden brown served with marinara sauce

Jalapeno Poppers

Price may varies

Stuffed with cheddar cheese, served with marinara sauce

Stuffed Mushrooms Piemontese

Price may varies

Onion, sage, cream, hot pepper, bread crumbs and sauce made of chicken broth and vegetables

Fried Fresh Mozzarella

Price may varies

Fresh mozzarella dipped in egg & bread crumbs, golden fried and served with marinara sauce

Fresh Mozzarella with Tomato and Red Onion

Price may varies

Served with fresh basil and pesto with vinaigrette dressing

Shrimp Cocktail Supreme

Price may varies

Jumbo shrimp served with the house cocktail sauce

Jumbo Coconut Shrimp

Price may varies

Lightly dipped in batter and rolled in fresh coconut, served with a sweet and sour orange sauce


SaladsChoice of dressings: balsamic vinaigrette, blue cheese, french, ranch, russian, house italian, low fat raspberry vinaigrette or low fat ranch

Chopped Chef Salad

Price may varies

Lettuce, tomato, onions, pepper, fresh turkey, ham and swiss cheese topped with a vinaigrette dressing

Greek Salad Supreme

Price may varies

Fresh mixed greens, feta cheese, green and red peppers, kalamata olives, onions, stuffed grape leaves with vinaigrette

Buffalo Chicken Salad

Price may varies

Mixed greens tossed with buffalo chicken breast, tomato, celery, blue cheese with a spicy buffalo sauce

Cracked Black Pepper Steak

Price may varies

Sliced over baby greens with onions, portobello, mushrooms, crumbled blue cheese and balsamic vinaigrette

Avocado Chicken Salad

Price may varies

Chicken breast, bacon, blue cheese, avocado, tomato and chopped egg over mixed greens

Blackened Fresh Salmon or Swordfish

Price may varies

Served over mixed green salad with a vinaigrette or caesar dressing

Classic Caesar Salad

Price may varies

The traditional recipe with romaine lettuce, croutons, parmesan cheese and our special caesar dressing. Add grilled chicken $15.95. Add grilled jumbo shrimp $17.95

Fresh Calamari Salad

Price may varies

Fresh squid, marinated with extra virgin olive oil, balsamic vinegar, fine herbs and spices, served over crisp mixed greens

Seafood Salad

Price may varies

Marinated jumbo shrimp, squid, scallops, fresh jumbo lump crab meat over mixed greens with light lemon & olive oil dressing


SoupsMade fresh daily

Old Fashioned Chicken Noodle

Price may varies

Minestrone

Price may varies

French Onion Soup

Price may varies

New England Clam Chowder

Price may varies

Lobster, Shrimp & Salmon Bisque

Price may varies


Pasta

Seafood Basil Square Ravioli

Price may varies

Stuffed with shrimp, baby scallops, cheese, minced lobster meat and fresh basil

Large Goat Cheese Agnolotti (Stuffed Pasta)

Price may varies

Goat cheese with caramelized shallots, chive and fresh tomato with a pink sauce and portobello mushrooms

Cajun Jambalaya Pasta

Price may varies

Our most popular pasta dish with jumbo shrimp and grilled chicken sauteed with onions, tomato and pepper in a light spicy cajun sauce. Available over rice, spaghetti or linguine

Louisiana Chicken Pasta

Price may varies

Parmesan crusted chicken, tossed with mushrooms, pepper & onions in a spicy new orleans style sauce served over pasta

Linguine Alla Vongole

Price may varies

Pasta al dente with fresh little neck clams in red or white sauce

Penne Alla Stoli Orange Vodka

Price may varies

A light cream & tomato sauce with orange flavored stoli vodka. Add broccoli and chicken $17.95

Baked Ziti Bolognese

Price may varies

Rich meat sauce, slowly simmered with mushrooms, garlic and red wine, topped with mozzarella cheese

Fettuccine Alfredo

Price may varies

Butter, cream and parmesan cheese


BurgersServed with fresh lettuce, tomato, pickle, fries or baked potato

10 Ounce Steak Burger 31

Price may varies

Our classic burger, ground fresh daily and flame grilled to order

12 Ounce Buffalo Bacon Burger

Price may varies

Our 12 ounce burger, ground fresh daily & smothered in spicy buffalo sauce, topped with crispy bacon & flame grilled to order

Turkey Burger

Price may varies

A gigantic old fashioned chop house turkey burger, low fat and delicious

Garden Burger

Price may varies

A blend of vegetables, rice, baked beans, garlic, onions and herbs

Additionl Toppings

Price may varies

Bleu, cheddar, american, swiss or mozzarella cheese, sauteed mushrooms, sauteed onions and bacon


Sandwiches

The Club Sandwiches

Price may varies

Fresh roasted turkey breast, bacon, lettuce, tomato, onions and mayo served with french fries or baked potato

Grilled Chicken and Avocado Club

Price may varies

Grilled chicken breast with avocado, bacon, tomato, melted swiss cheese and herb mayo served with french fries or baked potato

Blackened Chicken Sandwich

Price may varies

Chicken breast seasoned with our own cajun spice mix served with lettuce, tomato, pickle, french fries or baked potato

Crab Cake Sandwich

Price may varies

Fresh jumbo lump crab cake with lettuce, tomato & tartar sauce on a bun served with french fries or baked potato

Open Steak Sandwich

Price may varies

USDA shell steak served with cole slaw, lettuce, tomato & french fries

Veal Cutlet Parmigiana Sandwich

Price may varies

Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Sandwich

Price may varies

Melted mozzarella cheese and marinara sauce

Carlos Beltran Sandwich

Price may varies

Roast beef, grilled onions, sauteed mushrooms, peppers and american cheese

Grilled Portobello Mushroom on a Bun

Price may varies

A giant portabello mushroom grilled with herbs and served on a bun with lettuce, tomato, grilled red onion, melted cheese and spicy mayonnaise

Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Price may varies

Served with pickle, french fries or baked potato and cole slaw

Grilled Chicken or Tuna Wrap

Price may varies

Served with pickle, french fries or baked potato and cole slaw


Greek FavoritesAll of the above items served with mixed green salad

Spinach Pie

Price may varies

Golden crisp layers of phyllo dough, filled with fresh spinach and feta cheese

Moussaka

Price may varies

Baked layers of eggplant, chopped beef and cheese, topped with bechamel sauce

Chicken Souvlaki

Price may varies

Boneless breast of chicken marinated with green peppers and onions, served with rice and mushrooms


Brick Oven Pizza

Margherita Pizza

Price may varies

Topped with mozzarella, pesto, fresh basil and fresh tomato

The Quattro Staggione

Price may varies

Tomato sauce, mozzarella, mushrooms, onions, prosciutto and black olives

Pizza 31

Price may varies

Tomato sauce, oregano, black olives, peppers, onions and feta cheese

Plain Pizza

Price may varies

Mozzarella and tomato sauce

Additional Toppings

Price may varies

Pepperoni, chicken, sausage, mushrooms, onions, pepper, mozzarella cheese, anchovies and buffalo chicken


OmelettesAll omelettes consist of three farm fresh eggs, served with french fries, bread & butter. Additional fillings availabe at $1.00 each bacon,mushrooms, extra cheese, etc. Egg white $1.00 extra

Omelette 31

Price may varies

Omelette filled with fresh mozzarella cheese, topped with sauteed asparagus, portobello mushrooms, artichokes and fresh tomato sauce

Italian Omelette

Price may varies

Fresh tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese

Ham & Cheese Omelette

Price may varies

Greek Omelette

Price may varies

Feta, tomatoes, onions & green peppers


Steaks

Grilled Skirt Steak

Price may varies

Tender skirt steak, sauteed with portobello mushrooms, onions and fresh rosemary, served with baked or mashed potato

USDA Choice Filet Mignon

Price may varies

12 ounce cut, our most tender steak

USDA Choice NY Shell Steak

Price may varies

16 ounce boneless cut

USDA Choice Porterhouse Cut Steak

Price may varies

22 ounces and up

Baby Lamb Chops

Price may varies

Grilled to perfection tossed with fresh rosemary, fresh garlic, olive oil and white wine


Veal

Veal Parmigiana

Price may varies

Nature veal cutlet dipped in egg and bread crumbs, pan-fried and topped with a blend of cheeses and fresh tomato sauce

Veal Picatta

Price may varies

Nature veal medallions sauteed with lemon, caper and white wine sauce

Veal alla Marsala

Price may varies

Nature veal cutlet, sauteed with mushrooms and a marsala wine sauce

Seven Hills of Rome

Price may varies

Nature veal sauteed with white wine, cognac, roasted peppers and topped with prosciutto mozzarella cheese and finished with a demi-glaze sauce


Seafood

Shrimp alla Scampi

Price may varies

Extra jumbo shrimp, sauteed in a flavorful garlic, lemon and white wine sauce

Shrimp Parmigiana

Price may varies

Shrimp dipped in egg, bread crumbs, pan fried and topped with a blend of cheeses and a fresh tomato sauce

Calamari Fritti

Price may varies

Fresh and tender seasoned squid, dipped in a light batter, deep fried till golden brown and served with a mild or hot marinara sauce

Baked Stuffed Filet of Sole

Price may varies

Stuffed with a delicious blend of jumbo lump crab meat, baby shrimp, bread crumbs, peppers and onions topped with a lemon butter sauce

Atlantic Salmon Filet

Price may varies

Pistachio crusted salmon filet served over a bed of spinach with an amaretti di saronno sauce

Swordfish Filet

Price may varies

Charcoal grilled to perfection with lemon, tomato, fresh basil and extra virgin olive oil or mediterranean sauce


ChickenAll of the above items served with salad and choice of rice, pasta, potato, or fresh vegetables of the day. There will be an extra charge for splitting orders on all entrees

Chicken alla Marsala

Price may varies

Boneless breast of chicken, sauteed with mushrooms, butter and a marsala wine sauce

Chicken alla Parmigiana

Price may varies

Boneless breast of chicken, dipped in egg, bread crumbs, pan fried and topped with imported parmesan, fresh tomato and mozzarella cheese

Chicken alla Carciofi

Price may varies

Fresh chicken breast, sauteed with artichokes and mushrooms in a wine sauce

Chicken & Shrimp Lemonato Scampi

Price may varies

Sauteed in a fresh lemon, white wine and scampi sauce

Chicken Balsamic

Price may varies

Chicken sauteed with onions, mushrooms and fresh tomatoes in a sweet balsamic sauce

Chicken Scapariello

Price may varies

Chicken breast sauteed with garlic, rosemary, lemon and white wine


Frozen Fruit Smoothies

Strawberry Fruit Smoothie

Price may varies

Strawberries, orange, pineapple juice, coconut and banana

Tropical Smoothie

Price may varies

Mango, pineapple and strawberries

Frozen Iced Mango Smoothie

Price may varies

Mango, strawberries, coconut and tropical juices and swirled with raspberry puree

Peach Smoothie

Price may varies

Peaches and fruit juice swirled with banana and raspberry puree


Desserts

New York Cheese Cake

Price may varies

Chocolate Mousse Cake

Price may varies

Apple Pie

Price may varies

A La Mode

Price may varies

Blueberry Pie

Price may varies

Tartufo

Price may varies

Ice Cream

Price may varies

Vanilla, chocolate, strawberry

Assorted Sorbet Flavors

Price may varies


Water

Voss Flat 375 ml

Price may varies

Voss Flat 800 ml

Price may varies

Voss Sparkling 500 ml

Price may varies

Voss Sparkling One Liter

Price may varies

Small Pellegrino

Price may varies

Large Pellegrino

Price may varies

Mineral Water

Price may varies


Draft Beers

Stella Artois

Price may varies

Heineken

Price may varies

Guinness

Price may varies

Grolsch

Price may varies

Molson

Price may varies

Sam Adams

Price may varies

Budwiser

Price may varies

Coors Light

Price may varies

Miller Light

Price may varies

Bass Ale

Price may varies


Beverages

Fountain Soda

Price may varies

Snapple Ice Teas

Price may varies

Coffee or Tea

Price may varies

Iced Tea or Iced Coffee

Price may varies

Herbal Tea

Price may varies

Espresso

Price may varies

Cappuccino

Price may varies


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading