Menu With Price > Menu > Buttercup Bake Shop > NY > New York > 973 2nd Ave, New York, NY

Buttercup Bake Shop Prices in New York, NY 10022

4.7 based on 165 votes
Buttercup Bake Shop Logo
973 2nd Ave, New York, NY
(917) 651-0693
Buttercup Bake Shop Menu

Hours of Operation

Hours may fluctuate. For detailed hours of operation, please contact the store directly.

Restaurant Menu

Classic Cupcakes

Buttercup Golden

Fluffy vanilla cake with choice of vanilla or chocolate buttercream

$3.00 - $36.00

Classic Chocolate

Rich chocolate cake with choice of vanilla or chocolate buttercream

$3.00 - $36.00

Lemon

Light and lemony cake with zesty lemon buttercream

$3.00 - $36.00

Red Velvet

Buttery cake with a hint of cocoa topped with cream cheese frosting

$3.00 - $36.00

Mini Cupcakes

No description available

$3.00 - $18.00

Devil Dog

Rich chocolate cake with whipped meringue frosting & chocolate drizzle

$3.00 - $36.00

German Chocolate

A light chocolate cake with coconut, caramel and pecan frosting

$3.00 - $36.00

Hummingbird

Banana pineapple cake with cream cheese frosting & chopped pecans

$3.00 - $36.00

Lady Baltimore

Almond cake with whipped meringue frosting, coconut flakes & a maraschino cherry

$3.00 - $36.00

Specialty Cupcake of the Month

No description available

$3.25

Classic Layer Cakes

Classic Layer Cakes Slice

No description available

$4.95

Classic Layer Cakes 2 Layer 7"

No description available

$32.00

Classic Layer Cakes 2 Layer 9"

No description available

$44.00

Classic Layer Cakes 3 Layer 9"

No description available

$53.00

Signature Two Layer Cakes

Sour Cream Spice Cake

No description available

$5.50 - $45.00

Hummingbird Cake

No description available

$5.50 - $45.00

Apple Walnut Cake

No description available

$5.50 - $45.00

Signature Three Layer Cakes

Lemon

No description available

$6.00 - $55.00

Coconut

No description available

$6.00 - $55.00

Mochaccino

No description available

$6.00 - $55.00

Carrot Cake

No description available

$6.00 - $55.00

Lady Baltimore

No description available

$6.00 - $55.00

Red Velvet

No description available

$6.00 - $55.00

German Chocolate

No description available

$6.00 - $55.00

Peanut Butter & Jelly

No description available

$6.00 - $55.00

Puddings & Trifles

Buttercup’s Famous Banana Pudding

Creamy vanilla pudding nestled between layers of freshly sliced bananas and nilla wafers

$5.00 - $32.00

Classic Chocolate Trifle

Rich chocolate pudding layered with chocolate cake crumbs and a fresh whipped cream

$5.00 - $32.00

Raspberry Lemon Trifle

Fresh raspberries and gingersnap crumbles wrapped in a blanket of tangy lemon pudding

$5.00 - $32.00

Seasonal Pies

Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

No description available

$8.00 - $24.00

Gingersnap Lime Pie

No description available

$8.00 - $24.00

Apple Crumb Pie

No description available

$8.00 - $24.00

Chocolate Pudding Pie

No description available

$8.00 - $24.00

Lemon Meringue Pie

No description available

$8.00 - $24.00

Pecan Pie

No description available

$8.00 - $24.00

Pumpkin Pie

No description available

$8.00 - $24.00

Peach Pandowdy Pie

No description available

$8.00 - $24.00

Brownies with Bars & Cookies

Brownies or Walnut Brownies

No description available

$3.00

Raspberry Fruit Bars

No description available

$3.00

Apple Pie Bars

No description available

$3.00

Peanut Butter Mud Bars

No description available

$3.00

Pecan Pie Bars

No description available

$3.00

Chocolate Chip Cookie Bars

No description available

$3.00

Magic Cookie Bars

No description available

$3.00

Rice Krispie Treats

No description available

$3.00

Oatmeal Chocolate Chip

Sugar and chocolate chip cookies

$1.50

Coffee & Bundt Cakes

Amaretto Bundt Cake

No description available

$4.50 - $32.00

Angel Food Cake (Strawberry Glaze Option)

No description available

$4.50 - $32.00

Blueberry Coffee Cake

No description available

$4.50 - $32.00

Chocolate Sour Cream Cake

No description available

$4.50 - $32.00

Lemon Vanilla Bundt Cake

No description available

$4.50 - $32.00

Mini Cheesecakes

Caramel Pecan

No description available

$6.00

Chocolate Almond

No description available

$6.00

Chocolate Swirl

No description available

$6.00

Peanut Butter

No description available

$6.00

Red Velvet

No description available

$6.00

Raspberry Marzipan

No description available

$6.00

Pumpkin Spice

No description available

$6.00

Assorted Breakfast Items

Blueberry Muffins

No description available

$2.50

Oatmeal Muffins

No description available

$2.50

Raspberry Cream Cheese Buns

No description available

$2.50

Sour Cream Pecan Buns

No description available

$2.50

Raspberry Orange Bread

No description available

$2.50

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading