Menu With Price > Menu > Buttercup Bake Shop

Buttercup Bake Shop Menu and Prices

4.7 based on 165 votes
Buttercup Bake Shop Logo

Choose My State

NY

Buttercup Bake Shop Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14

Classic Cupcakes

Buttercup Golden

$3.00 - $36.00

Fluffy vanilla cake with choice of vanilla or chocolate buttercream

Classic Chocolate

$3.00 - $36.00

Rich chocolate cake with choice of vanilla or chocolate buttercream

Lemon

$3.00 - $36.00

Light and lemony cake with zesty lemon buttercream

Red Velvet

$3.00 - $36.00

Buttery cake with a hint of cocoa topped with cream cheese frosting

Mini Cupcakes

$3.00 - $18.00

Devil Dog

$3.00 - $36.00

Rich chocolate cake with whipped meringue frosting & chocolate drizzle

German Chocolate

$3.00 - $36.00

A light chocolate cake with coconut, caramel and pecan frosting

Hummingbird

$3.00 - $36.00

Banana pineapple cake with cream cheese frosting & chopped pecans

Lady Baltimore

$3.00 - $36.00

Almond cake with whipped meringue frosting, coconut flakes & a maraschino cherry

Specialty Cupcake of the Month

$3.25

Classic Layer CakesButtercup golden, classic chocolate. Suggested serving sizes 2 layer 7” 5 – 6, 2 layer 9” 10 - 15, 3 layer 7” 6 – 8, 3 layer 9” 15 – 18, ½ sheet cake 25 - 35

Classic Layer Cakes Slice

$4.95

Classic Layer Cakes 2 Layer 7"

$32.00

Classic Layer Cakes 2 Layer 9"

$44.00

Classic Layer Cakes 3 Layer 9"

$53.00

Signature Two Layer Cakes

Sour Cream Spice Cake

$5.50 - $45.00

Hummingbird Cake

$5.50 - $45.00

Apple Walnut Cake

$5.50 - $45.00

Signature Three Layer CakesThese cakes can accommodate the following frosting flavors: Vanilla, chocolate, mocha, lemon, peanut butter

Lemon

$6.00 - $55.00

Coconut

$6.00 - $55.00

Mochaccino

$6.00 - $55.00

Carrot Cake

$6.00 - $55.00

Lady Baltimore

$6.00 - $55.00

Red Velvet

$6.00 - $55.00

German Chocolate

$6.00 - $55.00

Peanut Butter & Jelly

$6.00 - $55.00

Puddings & Trifles

Buttercup’s Famous Banana Pudding

$5.00 - $32.00

Creamy vanilla pudding nestled between layers of freshly sliced bananas and nilla wafers

Classic Chocolate Trifle

$5.00 - $32.00

Rich chocolate pudding layered with chocolate cake crumbs and a fresh whipped cream

Raspberry Lemon Trifle

$5.00 - $32.00

Fresh raspberries and gingersnap crumbles wrapped in a blanket of tangy lemon pudding

Seasonal Pies

Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

$8.00 - $24.00

Gingersnap Lime Pie

$8.00 - $24.00

Apple Crumb Pie

$8.00 - $24.00

Chocolate Pudding Pie

$8.00 - $24.00

Lemon Meringue Pie

$8.00 - $24.00

Pecan Pie

$8.00 - $24.00

Pumpkin Pie

$8.00 - $24.00

Peach Pandowdy Pie

$8.00 - $24.00

Brownies with Bars & Cookies

Brownies or Walnut Brownies

$3.00

Raspberry Fruit Bars

$3.00

Apple Pie Bars

$3.00

Peanut Butter Mud Bars

$3.00

Pecan Pie Bars

$3.00

Chocolate Chip Cookie Bars

$3.00

Magic Cookie Bars

$3.00

Rice Krispie Treats

$3.00

Oatmeal Chocolate Chip

$1.50

Sugar and chocolate chip cookies

Coffee & Bundt Cakes

Amaretto Bundt Cake

$4.50 - $32.00

Angel Food Cake (Strawberry Glaze Option)

$4.50 - $32.00

Blueberry Coffee Cake

$4.50 - $32.00

Chocolate Sour Cream Cake

$4.50 - $32.00

Lemon Vanilla Bundt Cake

$4.50 - $32.00

Mini Cheesecakes

Caramel Pecan

$6.00

Chocolate Almond

$6.00

Chocolate Swirl

$6.00

Peanut Butter

$6.00

Red Velvet

$6.00

Raspberry Marzipan

$6.00

Pumpkin Spice

$6.00

Assorted Breakfast Items

Blueberry Muffins

$2.50

Oatmeal Muffins

$2.50

Raspberry Cream Cheese Buns

$2.50

Sour Cream Pecan Buns

$2.50

Raspberry Orange Bread

$2.50

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading

Popular Brands