Butler Inn Menu and Prices

4.5 based on 396 votes
Butler Inn Logo

Choose My State

IN WI

Butler Inn Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Appetizers

Saganaki

$8.95

thick slices of imported Kefalogravyera cheese from the Island of create soaked in brandy, flambéed at your table, then doused with lemon juice

Haystack Onion Rings

$6.95

Potato Skins

$6.95

with cheddar cheese and bacon bits

Mozzarella Sticks

$6.95

with marinara sauce

Shrimp Cocktail

$10.95

Breaded Mushrooms

$6.95

with cucumber dressing

Breaded Zucchini

$6.95

with marinara sauce

Chicken Wings

$6.95

with BBQ sauce

Breaded Clam Strips

$6.95

with cocktail sauce

Create-Your-Own Combo Platters

Price may varies

price determined by number of appetizers and people.


Soups

Louie’s Famous Homemade Soup

$2.50 - $3.95


Saladschoice of dressings: Parmesan Peppercorn, Buttermilk Ranch, French, Thousand Island, Italian, Blue Cheese, No-Fat Honey Mustard, No-Fat Raspberry Vinaigrette, Balsamic Vinaigrette, or House Greek Aegean. Roquefort, add $ 1.25. Feta Cheese, add $ 1.50. Al

Caesar Salad

$9.95

crisp romaine and leaf lettuce tossed in our own special Caesar dressing and homemade croutons

Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad

$10.95

our same Caesar salad topped with grilled herb marinated

Louie’s Steak Salad

$12.95

mixed iceberg and field greens, bacon, tomatoes, cucumbers and red onions tossed with our house balsamic vinaigrette then topped with sliced filet mignon and blue cheese crumbles

Greek Salad

$9.95

a gourmet’s delight of feta cheese, cucumbers, green pepper, onion, tomato wedges, anchovies and Greek olives on a bed of lettuce with our special Greek dressing

Garden Salad

$3.25


Black Angus Steakwe proudly serve Black Angus Beef. Our steaks are charred and broiled to perfection and served with sautéed mushrooms and shredded onion rings.

Louie's Five Star Signature Steak

$30.95

a filet mignon seasoned with Louie’s secret recipe. Unbelievably Addicting!

For The Five Star Signature Steak

$24.95

Rib Eye

$28.95

the same flavorful cut used as prime rib

Chopped Sirloin

$14.95

freshly ground sirloin

New York Strip

$28.95

Said to be the tastiest of all cuts

Filet Mignon

$28.95

the tenderest of cuts

Petite Filet Mignon

$22.95

for the lighter appetite


Combinations

Sea Scallops ‘n Turf

$34.95

broiled sea scallops and a oz. broiled filet mignon

Surf ‘n Turf

Price may varies

tenderloin and one broiled cold water South African lobster tail

Shrimp ‘n Turf

$32.95

three jumbo shrimp and a broiled filet mignon


From the Sea

Sea Scallops

$18.95

prepared to your preference broiled, sautèed or deep-fried

Lobster Tails

Price may varies

cold water South African lobster tails the finest in the world One tail Market Two tails Market

Six Fan-tailed Jumbo Shrimp

$16.95

breaded and deep-fried, served with homemade cocktail sauce

Broiled Cod

$14.95

Icelandic cod served with drawn butter

Broiled Alaskan Salmon Steak

$15.95

Served with drawn butter

Lake Perch

$14.95

lightly breaded fillets, deep-fried and served with homemade tartar sauce

Breaded Cod

$13.95

lightly breaded and deep-fried, with homemade tartar sauce


Traditional Favorites

Baby Beef Liver

$12.95

sautèed to the peak of tenderness. Served with crisp bacon and sautèed onions

Half Fried Chicken

$12.95

a generous portion, deep-fried golden brown

Broiled Chicken Breast

$14.95

two chicken breasts seasoned and broiled to perfection

Pork Chops

$18.95

two juicy center cut pork chops, broiled


Sandwichesall sandwiches served with French fries and pickle spear.

Beefburger

$7.50

broiled 1/2 pound of fresh ground sirloin

Cheeseburger

$7.95

our beefburger, broiled and topped with melted American cheese

Louie’s Famous Tenderloin Steak Sandwich

$14.95

the 'best' steak sandwich in the state! Broiled to perfection and topped with mushrooms, served open-faced

Chicken Breast

$7.25

your choice of deep-fried or broiled chicken breast. Open- faced with lettuce and tomato

Fish Sandwich

$7.95

lightly breaded, deep-fried cod. A meal in itself!


Friday Specials

Beer-Battered Cod

$9.95

Greek Style Baked Cod

$11.95

baked with fresh spinach, celery, tomato, onion, olive oil and spices

Lake Perch

$12.95

lightly breaded and deep-fried

Six Fan-Tail Jumbo Shrimp

$13.95

deep-fried

Broiled Icelandic Cod

$12.95

served with drawn butter

Broiled Alaskan Salmon Steak

$14.95

Fisherman’s Platter

$15.95

beer-battered cod, lake perch, shrimp and breaded scallops


Saturday Specials

BBQ Baby Back Pork Ribs

$21.95 - $15.95

BBQ Chicken

$14.95


Saturday Combinations

Steak Ribs

$28.95

BBQ Chicken Ribs

$17.95

Shrimp Ribs

$20.95

BBQ Chicken Shrimp

$17.95


Sunday Specials

Black Angus Prime Rib

$19.95

with soup or salad and choice of potato


Kid’s Menufor our guests 12 years old and younger.

Lake Perch

$6.95

two pieces, deep-fried, served with French fries and applesauce

Chicken

$6.95

two pieces of deep-fried chicken served with French fries and applesauce

Beer-Battered Cod

$6.95

one piece, deep-fried, served with French fries and applesauce

Butterflied Shrimp

$6.95

three deep-fried shrimp, served Three deep-fried shrimp, served

Grilled Cheese Sandwich

$5.95

served with French fries, applesauce and pickle


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading