BlackFly Menu and Prices

3.8 based on 65 votes
BlackFly Logo

Choose My State

FL

BlackFly Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Appetizers

Authentic Bahamian Conch Fritters

$9.00

House made from a family recipe with datil pepper remoulade

Spinach Artichoke Cheese Pot

$8.00

Served with house fried flatbread

Lump Crab Cakes

$11.00

Datil pepper remoulade, pineapple chutney, baby greens

Shrimp Fried Rice

$9.00

Fried rice topped with bite size shrimp tossed in sweet chili sauce

Spicy Sriracha Shrimp

$10.00

Shrimp sauteed with toasted garlic, finished with a sriracha butter sauce

Steak & Cheese Risotto

$9.00

Mushrooms, onions, red pepper cream, candied bacon

Black Bean Hummus

$7.00

Blended with cumin & cilantro, served with tomato salsa & house fried flatbread

Crab Cocktail Claws

$8.00

Blue crab claws served with datil aioli & cocktail sauce

Coconut Curry Clams

$9.00

Little neck clams sauteed in coconut curry sauce with grilled focaccia

Fried Green Tomato

$9.00

Topped with cucumber-tomato salad, crumbled goat cheese & balsamic Syrup

Pan Seared Salmon

$10.00

Over a ragout of white beans, artichoke hearts, sundried tomato & basil

Buffalo Style Fried Calamari

$8.00

Hot sauce drizzle, gorgonzola crumbles & cucumber celery ranch

Five Spice Ahi Tuna

$12.00

Seared rare with seaweed salad, sesame-soy aioli, wasabi & pickled ginger


Soups & Salads & Apps

Bahamian Conch Chowder

$6.00

Soup of the Day

$6.00

Cider House Salad

$8.00

Spicy candied pecans, apples, gorgonzola crumbles, spiced apple vinaigrette

Baby Greens Salad

$7.00

Tomato, carrot, cucumber, tomato-black pepper vinaigrette. Add gorgonzola crumbles to your salad for $0.50

Roasted Beet Salad

$9.00

Toasted pistachios, creamy goat cheese, orange-thyme vinaigrette

Caesar Salad

$7.00

Rosemary crostini, shredded parmesan, creamy caesar dressing. Add anchovy filets to your caesar for $1.00

Five Spice Ahi Tuna

$12.00

Seared rare with seaweed salad, sesame-soy aioli, wasabi & pickled ginger

Spinach Artichoke Cheese Pot

$8.00

Served with house fried flatbread

Crab Cocktail Claws

$8.00

Blue crab claws served with lemon aioli, datil aioli & cocktail sauce

Black Bean Hummus

$7.00

Blended with cumin & cilantro, served with tomato salsa & house fried flatbread


Soups & SaladsAdd grilled chicken $5.00, 4 grilled shrimp $7.00, fresh catch, salmon, or 3 jumbo scallops $12.00

Bahamian Conch Chowder

$6.00

Soup of the Day

$6.00

Cider House Salad

$8.00

Spicy candied pecans, apples, gorgonzola crumbles, spiced apple vinaigrette

Baby Greens Salad

$7.00

Tomato, carrot, cucumber, tomato-black pepper vinaigrette. Add gorgonzola crumbles to your salad for $0.50 or add goat cheese for $1.00

Roasted Beet Salad

$9.00

Toasted pistachios, creamy goat cheese, orange-thyme vinaigrette

Caesar Salad

$7.00

Rosemary crostini, shredded parmesan, creamy caesar dressing. Add anchovy filets to your caesar for $1.00


EntreesDelicious additions 4 grilled shrimp $7.00, crab cakes $10.00, 3 jumbo scallops $12.00, 4 oz. sauteed lump crab $12.00, 5 oz. maine lobster tail $14.00

Seared Fresh Catch

Price may varies

Served with mashed red potatoes, vegetable of the day and tomato-bacon compound butter

Fried Shrimp

$17.00

Lightly breaded shrimp with skin on steak fries, pineapple slaw & datil pepper remoulade

Seared Sea Scallops

$25.00

Caramelized sea scallops with a creamy parmesan risotto, vegetable of the day & tomato datil cream sauce

Grilled Scottish Salmon

$23.00

House fried rice, vegetable of the day, golden pineapple chutney and a black & white sesame seed crisp

Linguine with Clams

$15.00

Littleneck clams sauteed with fresh garlic finished with a white wine butter sauce and grilled focaccia

Maine Lobster Mac and Cheese

$22.00

Cavatappi pasta, maine lobster meat and sauteed red onion tossed with a creamy truffle and white cheddar sauce

Capellini with Lump Blue Crab

$20.00

Toasted garlic, jumbo lump blue crab and basil with a delicate white wine cream sauce

Vegetable Cavatappi

$14.00

Sun dried tomatoes, artichoke hearts, toasted garlic, sauteed spinach and cavatappi pasta finished with a white wine butter sauce

Spinach & Feta Stuffed Chicken

$19.00

Pan roasted, served alongside mashed red potatoes and vegetable of the day, sauced with a roasted red pepper cream

Grilled 12 oz. Pork Loin Chop

$22.00

Accompanied by sweet potato-bacon hash, vegetable of the day and a bourbon dijon cream sauce

Grilled 8 oz. Flat Iron Steak

$22.00

Steak fries tossed with truffle salt, vegetable of the day, sunnyside egg and blackfly steak sauce

Grilled Lamb Porterhouse (8 oz.)

$24.00

With a sweet pea and parmesan risotto, vegetable of the day and an au poivre style marsala mushroom sauce

Grilled Lamb Porterhouse (12 oz.)

$28.00

With a sweet pea and parmesan risotto, vegetable of the day and an au poivre style marsala mushroom

Grilled 8 oz. Center Cut Filet Mignon

$32.00

Served with mashed red potatoes & vegetable try any one of the following preparations or have it topless

Truffle Butter

Price may varies

Marsala Mushroom Sauce

Price may varies

Portabella mushrooms in a marsala style au poivre

Steak Sauce

Price may varies

Our house steak sauce with sweetwater 420 pale ale & honey whiskey

Tomato-Bacon Butter

Price may varies

Our own compound of fire roasted tomatoes and apple wood bacon


10" Brick Oven PizzasAdd anchovies or truffle oil $1.00, add bacon, pepperoni, or chorizo $2.00, add grilled chicken $3.00, add shrimp $6.00, add maine lobster $8.00

Margherita

$13.00

Fresh mozzarella, toasted garlic, tomato, torn basil, marinara

Mushroom

$14.00

Roasted mushrooms, red onion, truffle oil, basil, goat cheese

Lobster

$18.00

Maine lobster, roasted garlic oil, bacon, tomato, basil

Mediterranean

$14.00

Kalamata olives, spinach, roasted red peppers, artichoke hearts, feta

Crab Rangoon

$17.00

Spinach artichoke cream, blue crab, crisp wontons, sweet chili sauce

Four Seasons

$15.00

Margherita, spinach artichoke, mushroom, bacon-sweet potato hash

Blackened Chicken Pizza

$14.00

Spinach artichoke cream, blackened chicken artichokes, spinach

Carnivore

$15.00

Pepperoni, bacon, chorizo, grilled chicken, marinara

Cajun Shrimp

$16.00

Shrimp, chorizo, green pepper, red onion, sriracha, marinara


Late Night Brick Oven PizzasAdd anchovies or truffle oil $1.00, add bacon, pepperoni, or chorizo $2.00, add grilled chicken $3.00, add shrimp $6.00, add maine lobster $8.00

Margherita

$13.00

Fresh mozzarella, toasted garlic, tomato, torn basil, marinara

Mushroom

$14.00

Roasted mushrooms, red onion, truffle oil, basil, goat cheese

Lobster

$18.00

Maine lobster, roasted garlic oil, bacon, tomato, basil

Mediterranean

$14.00

Kalamata olives, spinach, roasted red peppers, artichoke hearts, feta

Crab Rangoon

$17.00

Spinach artichoke cream, blue crab, crisp wontons, sweet chili sauce

Four Seasons

$15.00

Margherita, spinach artichoke, mushroom, bacon-sweet potato hash

Blackened Chicken Pizza

$14.00

Spinach artichoke cream, blackened chicken artichokes, spinach

Carnivore

$15.00

Pepperoni, bacon, chorizo, grilled chicken, marinara

Cajun Shrimp

$16.00

Shrimp, chorizo, green pepper, red onion, sriracha, marinara


Desserts

Creme Brulee

$6.00

Today's flavor, whipped cream

Coconut Brownies

$8.00

Toasted coconut crusted ice cream

Banana Rangoons

$7.00

Cinnamon rum caramel sauce, cinnamon caramel ice cream

Moms Carrot Cake

$8.00

Cream cheese frosting, bruleed pineapple, blood orange sauce

Graham Cracker Cake

$7.00

Blueberry cheesecake ice cream, strawberry puree

Chocolate Ganache Tart

$8.00

Mixed berry compote, whipped cream


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading