Benchwarmers Restaurant & Sports Bar Menu and Prices

4.3 based on 299 votes
Benchwarmers Restaurant & Sports Bar Logo
Burger
Hot Dogs
Pub Food

Choose My State

NY

Benchwarmers Restaurant & Sports Bar Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Starting Line-Up

Bench-Fries

$2.25

Beer-Battered Onion Rings

$3.99

Boneless Buffalo Wings

$6.99

tender white meat breaded chicken, lightly fried and tossed in a choice of mild, medium or hot buffalo wing sauce, or try our own sweet & slightly spicy "sideline sauce"; served w/bleu chee

Buffalo Wings

$6.99

our famous "over sized" wings are served mild, medium or hot or try our own sweet & slightly spicy "sideline sauce;" all served w/bleu cheese dressing and celery sticks

Breaded Chicken Tenders

$5.95

choose a sauce for dipping

Cheese Fries & Chili-Cheese Fries

$3.25

a heaping dish of French-fries oven-baked with melted cheddar cheese

Cheezy Oven-Baked Garlic Bread

$4.25 - $6.25

Cheese Fries & Chili-Cheese Fries Add Chili

$4.50

Garbage Fries

$5.25

topped with melted cheddar, pieces of grilled bacon & diced scallions

Benchwarmers' Nachos

$6.50

a huge platter or oven-baked tri-colored tortilla chips smothered in melted monterey jack & cheddar cheeses & topped w/diced tomatoes, black olives & sliced jalapeno peppers

Benchwarmers' Nachos Add Benchwarmers' Chili and Pieces of Char-Grilled Chicken Breast

$8.95

Jalapeno Poppers

$5.25

breaded jalapeno peppers stuffed w/melted cheddar and served w/a side or ranch dressing

Pizza Sticks

$6.25

crispy fried dough stuffed with bits of pepperoni, melted mozzarella cheese marinara (substitute onion rings or a small garden salad w/any sandwich or sub for $1.00)


1/2-Pound Burgers w/Fries

Bench Burger

$6.50

cooked to order and served on a fresh kaiser roll w/lettuce & tomato

Bench Burger Add cheese to Your Burger

$6.99

cooked to order and served on a fresh kaiser roll w/lettuce & tomato

Bomber Burger

$7.75

topped with your choice of melted cheese and grilled bacon w/lettuce & tomato

The Linebacker Burger

$8.99

an entire pound of flame broiled ground angus beef topped w/grilled bacon, choice of melted cheese, lettuce and tomato

Black-N-Bleu Burger

$7.99

blackened with spicy cajun seasonings and topped w/melted bleu cheese crumbles and pickled red onion

California Burger

$7.99

topped w/melted monterey jack cheese, grilled bacon, guacamole and sliced red onion

Smokehouse Burger

$7.99

topped w/melted monterey jack cheese, grilled bacon & cattleman's gold bbq sauce

Full-Court-Press Burger

$7.99

topped w/melted cheddar cheese, diced scallions and smothered in benchwarmers' famous chili


Pastaserved w/garlic bread

Alfredo Penne

$9.99

tender penne pasta sauteed in a rich alfredo cheese sauce

Alfredo Penne

$12.99

Add Charbroiled Chicken Breast or Blackened Chicken Breast

Chicken & Bacon Alfredo

$13.99

penne pasta sauteed in a rich alfredo cheese sauce with pieces of breaded chicken breast and grilled bacon

Chicken Parm Penne

$13.99

penne pasta oven-baked in zesty marinara sauce & topped w/pieces of breaded chicken breast and melted mozzarella cheese


Wraps w/fries

Buffalo Chicken Wrap

$7.25

pieces of breaded chicken breast tossed in a medium buffalo wing sauce and wrapped inside a jalapeno & cheddar tortilla with shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes and creamy bleu cheese dressing

Chicken Caesar Wrap

$6.95

strips of charbroiled chicken breast wrapped inside a flour tortilla with crisp romaine lettuce, garlic dusted croutons and a creamy caesar dressing

Chicken Club Wrap

$7.99

pieces of breaded chicken breast wrapped inside a jalapeno & cheddar tortilla with grilled bacon, shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes & mayo

Chicken Spiedie Wrap

$7.25

marinated pieces of char-grilled chicken breast (chicken spiedies) wrapped inside a flour tortilla w/shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes & ranch dressing

Chicken Fajita Wrap

$7.99

strips of grilled chicken breast wrapped inside a jalapeno & cheddar tortilla with grilled onions & peppers, melted jack & cheddar cheeses, shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes, sour cream and salsa

Philly Cheese Steak Wrap

$7.25

sliced grilled steak wrapped inside a jalapeno & cheddar tortilla with melted American cheese and grilled onions & peppers

Veggie Wrap

$5.99

shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes, cucumbers, black olives & guacamole wrapped inside a flour tortilla with a choice of dressing served on the side.(add choice of cheese for 50-cents)


Hot Sandwicheswith fries

BBQ Chicken Sandwich

$7.25

a breaded chicken breast fillet served on a kaiser roll and topped melted monterey jock cheese, grilled bacon and sweet baby ray's bbq sauce

Best Catch

$6.95

hand battered fresh Atlantic cod lightly fried & served on a fresh kaiser roll w/lettuce, tomato and a wedge of fresh lemon (choice of tarter sauce or cocktail sauce)

Big-Ass BLT

$6.55

Boca Burger

$5.95

save a cow, dude eat a veggie burger served on a fresh kaiser roll w/lettuce and tomato (add cheese for 50-cents)

Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

$7.25

a breaded chicken breast fillet tossed in a medium buffalo style wing sauce, served on a kaiser roll and topped w/bleu cheese dressing, lettuce & tomato

Charbroiled Chicken breast sandwich

$6.95

a charbroiled chicken breast fillet served on a fresh kaiser roll with lettuce, sliced tomato and a side of lemon-pepper mayo

Grilled Reubens

$7.29

tender grilled comed beef or thinly sliced hot turkey breast served on oversized grilled rye w/sauerkraut. Thousand Island dressing and melted Swiss cheese

Italian-Chicken Panini

$8.29

charbroiled chicken breast, roasted red peppers, melted provolone cheese and parmesan-peppercorn dressing served on press-grilled panini bread

Pesto-Chicken Panini

$8.29

charbroiled chicken breast, topped w/ melted provolone cheese, sliced ripe tomato and a zesty pesto sauce; served on press-grilled panini bread

Pulled-Pork Panini

$8.29

shredded pork, tenderloin, melted cheddar cheese, diced dill pickles and sweet baby ray's bbq sauce served on press-grilled panini bread

Turkey Club Melt

$7.29

thinly sliced hot turkey breast, grilled bacon and melted cheddar cheese w/lettuce, sliced tomato and mayonnaise served on grilled sour dough bread

West Coast Club

$7.29

thinly sliced smoked turkey breast, grilled bacon and melted monterey jack cheese served on toasted sour dough bread w/sliced ripe tomatoes and guacamole


Entreeschoice of fries or onion rings

Chicken Parmesan

$9.95

oven-baked breaded chicken breast topped w/a zesty marinara sauce and melted mozzarella and parmesan cheeses

Chicken Chimis

$8.99

a deep-fried jalapeno & cheddar tortilla stuffed w/strips of charbroiled chicken breast & melted monterey jack & cheddar cheeses; topped w/a guacamole-ranch sauce

Fish Fry

$9.95

lightly fried fresh Atlantic cod & hand battered in our own original recipe

Mediterranean Chicken

$9.95

charbroiled chicken breast oven-baked and topped w/melted provolone cheese, feta, black olives, diced tomatoes, and select spices


Quesadillasw/salsa a sour cream

Cheese Quesa-

$5.25

a flat grilled jalapeno & cheddar tortilla folded over loads of melted monterey jack & cheddar cheeses

Veggie Quesa-

$6.25

a flat grilled jalapeno & cheddar tortilla folded over loads of melted monterey jack & cheddar cheeses and grilled onions & peppers

Chicken Fajita Quesa-

$7.25

a flat grilled jalapeno & cheddar tortilla folded over loads of melted monterey jack & cheddar cheeses and grilled onions & peppers and strips of charbroiled chicken breast

BBQ Chicken Quesa-

$8.25

a flat grilled jalapeno & cheddar tortilla folded over loads of melted monterey jack & cheddar cheeses and grilled bacon and pieces of breaded chicken breast w/ a choice of cattleman's gold bbq sauce

Philly Steak Quesa-

$8.25

a flat grilled jalapeno & cheddar tortilla folded over grilled steak, grilled onions & peppers and melted American cheese (add sauteed mushrooms for 75-cents)


The "Fat Chick"eat the whole thing in under 30 minutes & get a free t-shirt!

The "Fat Chick"

$15.95

20oz of breaded chicken breast, way too much grilled bacon, loads of melted monterey jack cheese and a mound of sauteed onions served on a toasted kaiser roll with what can only be described as an ex


Soup, Chili & Salads

Benchwarmers' Oven-Baked Chili

$4.95

our award winning chili is oven-baked after being topped with cheddar cheese and diced scallions; served w/ tri-colored tortilla chips

French Onion Soup

$3.95

our own recipe topped with garlic parmesan croutons and melted provolone cheese

Meal Size Caesar Salad

$6.95

crisp romaine lettuce and garlic-parmesan croutons tossed in a creamy caesar dressing

Meal Size Caesar Salad Add Charbroiled Chicken Breast or Blackened Chicken Breast

$8.50

Chicken Spiedie Salad

$7.99

mixed greens, tomatoes, celery, cucumbers & red onion topped with pieces of tangy charbroiled marinated chicken breast (chicken spiedies); served w/ choice of dressing


Oven-Baked Mac & Cheese

Oven-Baked Mac & Cheese

$4.95

an American classic topped with melted cheddar cheese


Oven-Baked Subsw/fries

Chicken Parmesan Sub

$6.95

breaded white meat chicken topped with zesty marinara sauce and melted mozzarella and parmesan cheeses

The Original "Chicken-Wing" Sub

$6.25

marinated pieces of charbrolled chicken breast served on a toasted sub roll & topped with our own original sideline wing sauce and creamy bleu cheese dressing

Chicken Spiedie Salad Sub

$6.75

marinated pieces of charbroiled chicken breast served on a toasted sub roll with diced tomatoes, cucumbers and black olives; served with dressing on the side. (add cheese for 50-cents)

Philly Cheese Steak

$6.99

thinly sliced grilled steak, grilled onions & peppers and melted American cheese (add sauteed mushrooms for 75-cents)

The Longest Yard

$6.25

well, not quite a yard. It's a foot-long grilled frank smothered with chili and melted jack & cheddar cheeses; topped with diced scallions and served on an oven toasted sub roll


Little Leaguer's Menulight weights under 12 yrs old get a free batter-up sundae & collectable mini batter's helmet!

Bantamweight Burger & Fries

$5.25

add cheese for 50-cents

Kid's Chicken Tenders & Fries

$4.95

Hot Dog & Fries

$4.50

Grilled Cheese & Fries

$4.95

Just Mac & Cheese

$4.95

without the extra melted cheddar


Desserts

Enormous Root Beer Float

Price may varies

Reese's Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie

Price may varies

Fried Ice Cream

Price may varies

Batter-Up Sundae

Price may varies

Giant 23oz Smoothies

Price may varies

strawberry, raspberry & orange cream


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading