Barnum & Tibbetts Menu and Prices

4.3 based on 72 votes
Barnum & Tibbetts Logo
Steak

Choose My State

OH

Barnum & Tibbetts Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Starters

Artesian Cheese Selection

$12.00

dried fruit, assorted nuts

Soup Of The Day

$5.00

chef’s selection

Tomato, Basil & Artichoke, Soup

$5.00

parmesan grana, cream

Marinated Olives

$5.00

cheese & crackers

Thai Stire Fried Calamari

$6.00

snow peas, cilantro, peanuts

Steamed Mussels

$7.00

jalapeno tomato butter, scallion lime aioli, crostinis

Tuna Sashimi Tacos

$8.00

mango, avocado, wasabi aioli, tamarind chili sauce

Pumpkin Ravioli

$7.00

brown butter-spiced rum sauce, grilled pears, parmesan grana

Beef & Shrimp Satay

$8.00

sesame cucumber noodles, red miso dip

Blackened Sea Scallops

$9.00

yuzu-mustard vinaigrette, maytag bleu cheese

Butternut Squash Gnocchi

$7.00

roasted chicken, cranberry-pecan chutney

Crostinis

$12.00


Salads

House

$5.00

maple mustard vinaigrette, spiced walnuts, white cheddar, dried apricot

Bibb

$7.00

bibb lettuce, liquid roquefort, apple wood smoked bacon, tomatoes, scallions

Caesar

$4.00

romaine, radicchio, asiago, parmesan crouton

Chop Salad

$5.00

mixed greens, tomato, cucumber, kalamata olives, almonds, feta cheese, red wine herb vinaigrette

Caprese

Price may varies


Pasta

Beef Tenderloin Tips

$14.00

torchio pasta, green peppercorn sauce, asparagus, candied walnuts, maytag bleu cheese

Jumbo Shrimp & Angel Hair

$17.00

roasted peppers, pine nuts, baby spinach, lemon zest, virgin olive oil, shaved parmesan grana

Grilled Chicken Penne

$13.00

smoked tomato pesto, portobellos, artichoke hearts, scallions, asiago cheese


Seafood

Mahi-Mahi

$17.00

sweet potatoes fries, zucchini noodles, balsamic-maple butter sauce

Cracker Crusted Walleye

$19.00

toasted lemon crab sauce, parsnip scallop potatoes, broccoli

Seared Scallop Risotto

$18.00

sweet peas, yellow squash, radicchio, goat cheese, charred tomato coulis

Crispy Salmon

$18.00

sticky rice cakes, orange-fennel salad, wasabi-giner butter sauce, tamari soy syrup


Meatsour beef is hand selected, dry aged and cut in house. Steaks may be prepared with cracked pepper & green peppercorn sauce for an additional $2 or blackened with lemon-crab sauce for $3

Filet Mignon

$25.00 - $29.00

red onion jam, garlic mashed yukon potatoes, demi sauce

New York Strip

$28.00 - $31.00

roast shiitakes, pearl onions, whipped zinfandel-roguefort, house fries

Braised Lamb Shank

$21.00

natural jus, brussel sprouts, capers, parmesan, mint pesto, mashed yukon gold potatoes

Pork Tenderloin

$17.00

apple braised cabbage, acorn squash, carmalized apple wood bacon, spiced walnut gremolata

Veal & Shiitake Mushrooms

$19.00

sauteed with lemon, capers, parsley, white wine sauce, garlic mashed yukon potatoes

Stuffed Chicken Breast

$15.00

roasted pepper pan sauce, goat cheese, pinenuts, broccoli, yukon gold potatoes

Short Ribs

$17.00

sage cranberry dressing, cider glazed carrots, zinfandel reduction


Wines By The Glass - White

Chard

$7.00 - $3.50

hidden mesa, monterey

Chard

$7.50 - $3.75

tortoise creek “unoaked”, france

Chard

$9.50 - $4.75

chateau st. jean, sonoma

Chard

$13.00 - $6.50

joel gott, napa valley

Pinot Grigio

$6.00 - $3.00

biso, italy

Pinot Grigio

$10.00 - $5.00

bollino, italy

Sauvignon Blanc

$7.00 - $3.50

casa lapostolle, rapel valley, chile

Sauvignon Blanc

$13.00 - $6.50

groth, napa valley

Riesling

$6.00 - $3.00

schloss zell, germany

Riesling

$8.00 - $4.00

bonny doon, “paci? c rim” santa cruz, ca

Sparkling

$8.00 - $4.00

“so? a”, by coppola, napa valley

Sparkling

$22.00 - $11.00

veuve clicquot, “yellow label” france


Wines By The Glass - Red

Sangiovese

$7.00 - $3.50

petraio, italy

Chianti

$7.00 - $3.50

tnuta farneta, italy

Pinot Noir

$9.00 - $4.50

castle rock, sonoma, ca

Pinot Noir

$15.00 - $7.50

au bon climat, snata maria valley, ca

Merlot

$8.00 - $4.00

greyson, paso robles, ca

Merlot

$9.00 - $4.50

st. francis, napa valley

Zinfandel

$8.00 - $4.00

monkey business, sonoma, ca

Zinfandel

$11.00 - $5.50

“zen of zin”, sonoma

Cabernet

$7.00 - $3.50

cellar no. 8, ca

Cabernet

$10.00 - $5.00

bishop’s peak, ‘rock solid red”, paso robles, ca

Cabernet

$13.00 - $6.50

sketchbook, mendicino

Meritage

$10.00 - $5.00

steltzner claret, napa valley

Cote Du Rhone

$7.00 - $3.50

gicon le ferme, rhone

Malbec

$6.00 - $3.00

falling star, argentina

Shiraz

$9.00 - $4.50

ferngrove, frankland river, australia


Wines By The Bottle - Champagne & Sparkling

Brut Dargent

$25.00

france

Roederer Estate

$38.00

anderson valley

Domaine Carneros

$45.00

by taittinger

Nicholas Feuillatte Brut Rose

$73.00

france

Taittinger

$81.00

“la francaise”, france

Veuve Cliquot

$88.00

“yellow label”, france

Dom Perignon

$175.00

france


Wines By The Bottle - Sauvignon Blanc

Allan Scott

$26.00

marlborough, new sealand

Mudhouse

$27.00

marlborough,new zealand

Mason

$30.00

napa valley

Pascal Jolivet

$38.00

sancerre, france

Duckhorn

$46.00

napa valley

Crocker & Starr

$50.00

napa valley

Rochioli

$51.00

russian river


Wines By The Bottle - Pinot Grigio, Pinot Gris, & Other Whites

Vinum

$22.00

“chard no way”, chenin blanc, napa valley

Esparto

$25.00

pinot grigio, italy

King Estate

$27.00

pinot gris, oregon

Ca’montini

$27.00

piot griio, italy

A To Z

$27.00

pinot gris, oregon

Luna

$30.00

pinot grigio napa valley

Gregory Graham

$34.00

viognier, napa valley

Robert Weil Estate

$38.00

qba riesling rheingau, germany

Gundlachbundschu

$42.00

gewurztraminer, sonoma, ca

Santa Margherita

$43.00

pinot grigio, italy


Wines By The Bottle - Chardonnay

Benziger

$24.00

sonoma

Evans & Tate

$32.00

margaret river, australia

Louis Latour

$33.00

pouilly fuisse, france

Napa Cellars

$33.00

napa valley

Domaine Chandon

$34.00

carneros

Clos La Chance

$35.00

santa cruz mountain

Scherrer

$42.00

aleexander valley

Pine Ridge

$46.00

“dijon clones”, carneros

Talley

$47.00

“oliver’s vineyard”, edna valley, ca

Melville

$50.00

santa rita hills

Frank Family

$50.00

napa valley

Rombauer

$50.00

carnerso

Calk Hill

$50.00

sonoma

Ferrari-Carano

$55.00

carneros

Chateau Montelena

$62.00

napa valley

Ramey

$65.00

russioan river

Flowers

$69.00

sonoma coast

Patz & Hall

$70.00

hyde vineyards, sonoma

Far Niente

$75.00

napa valley

Louis Jadot

$75.00

puligny montrachet, france

Kistler

$90.00

sonoma coast


Wines By The Bottle - Half Bottles

Domaine Chandon

$24.00

champagne, napa valley

Dolce

$123.00

dessert, by far niente, napa valley

Honig

$21.00

sauvignon blanc, napa valley

Selene

$27.00

sauvignon blanc, hyde vineyards, napa valley

Landmark

$26.00

chard, “overlook”, sonoma

Talley

$29.00

chard, arroyo grande, california

Benton Lane

$22.00

pnot noir, oregon

Etude

$40.00

pinot noir, carneros

Rutherfod Hill

$27.00

merlot, napa valley

Havens

$27.00

merlot, napa valley

Storybook

$27.00

sinfandel, napa valley

D Cubed

$28.00

zinfandel, napa valley

Justin

$26.00

cabernet, paso robles

Staglin

$65.00

cabernet, napa valley


Wines By The Bottle - Pinot Noir

Gino Da Pinot

$24.00

monterey

Joseph Voillot

$123.00

burgundy, france

Dan Jean-Barthaux

$21.00

givry, france

Acacia

$27.00

carneros

Cristom

$26.00

“mt. jefferson”, oregon

Saintsbury

$29.00

carneros

David Bruce

$22.00

sonoma

Zd

$40.00

carneros

Four Graces

$27.00

willamette valley

Domaine Drouhin

$27.00

oregon

Etude

$27.00

carneros

Rochioli

$28.00

russian river

Patz & Hall

$26.00

alder springs

Domaine Serene

$65.00

willamette valley


Wines By The Bottle - Merlot

Sagelands

$25.00

washington

Franciscan

$30.00

napa valley

Whitehall Lane

$46.00

napa valley

Swanson

$55.00

napa valley

Frog’s leap

$65.00

napa valley

Paradigm

$72.00

napa valley

Selene

$72.00

napa valley

Duckhorn

$82.00

napa valley

Duckhorn

$116.00

3 palms, napa valley


Wines By The Bottle - Zinfandel

Graziano

$27.00

mendocino

St. Francis

$32.00

“old vines”, sonoma

Rosenblum

$33.00

“appellation series” san francisco

Hendry

$55.00

“block 7”, napa valley

Brown Estate

$66.00

napa valley

Biale

$76.00

“aldos vineyard,”, napa valley

Nickel & Nickel

$78.00

“ponzo”, russian river


Wines By The Bottle - Cabernet Sauvignon And Meritage

Los Vascos

$30.00

“reserve,” chile

Montes

$35.00

“alpha,” chile

Cinnabar

$35.00

“mercury rising”, california

Bordeauz

$40.00

ch. siaurac, pomerol, france

White Oak

$42.00

napa valley

Simi

$42.00

sonoma

Paul Hobbs

$43.00

“cocodrillo”, mendoza, argentina

Cain Cuvee

$43.00

napa valley

Bennett Lane

$50.00

“maximus”, napa valley

Bonny Doon

$50.00

“cigar volant”, santa cruz

Sequoia Grove

$53.00

napa valley

Cafaro

$65.00

napa valley

Silverado

$67.00

napa valley

Rocket Science

$67.00

“formula 103”, napa valley

Mount Veeder

$68.00

napa valley

Turnbull

$70.00

napa valley

Crocker & Starr Cab Franc

$70.00

napa valley

Heitz

$70.00

napa valley

Joseph Phelps

$75.00

napa valley

Jordan

$77.00

alexander valley

Faust

$78.00

by quintessa, napa valley

Paradigm

$82.00

napa valley

Ristow

$85.00

napa valley

Shafer

$90.00

napa valley

Justin

$90.00

“isosceles”, paso robles

Corison

$93.00

napa valley

Showkett

$93.00

napa valley

Selene

$98.00

napa valley

Silver Oak

$105.00

alexander valley

Nickel & Nickel

$128.00

“rock cairn”, napa valley

Silver Oak

$146.00

napa valley

Far Niente

$263.00

“cave collection”, napa valley 1996

Heitz

$282.00

“martha’s vineyard”, napa valley 1997

Far Niente

$400.00

“cave collection”, napa valley 1997


Wines By The Bottle - Syrah And Shiraz

Wishing Tree

$25.00

australia

Havens

$33.00

napa valley

D’arenberg

$33.00

“the footbolt”, australia

Cliff Edge

$35.00

“mount langi ghiran”, australia

Elderton

$49.00

australia

August Briggs

$58.00

napa valley

Palmeri

$75.00

“stagecoach vineyard”, napa valley

Neyers

$82.00

“hudson vineyard”, napa valley


Wines By The Bottle - Wines Of The World

Dolcetto ‘D’ Alba

$29.00

mauro veglio, italy

Rioja

$37.00

palacious romondo, spain

Rioja

$38.00

muga, spain

Chianti

$38.00

le corti, italy

Chauteauneuf Du Pape

$42.00

lazaret, france

Montefalco Rosso

$42.00

caprai, umbria, italy

Barbaresco

$50.00

marchesi ‘d’ gresy, piedmont, italy 1996

Bandol

$63.00

domaine tempier rouge, france

Barolo

$69.00

chiarlo, italy

Amarone

$81.00

masi, italy

Gaja Sito Moresco

$82.00

italy


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading