Arthur Avenue Cafe Menu and Prices

4.2 based on 138 votes
Arthur Avenue Cafe Logo
Coffee
Italian
Coffee & Tea

Choose My State

NY

Arthur Avenue Cafe Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Salads

Billy Goat Salad

$6.00 - $10.00

Mesclun lettuce topped with goat cheese, cherry tomato, walnuts and raisins

Cavatelli Pasta Salad

$14.00 - $22.00

Served with broccoli, sausage, olive oil and grated cheese

Chef’s Salad

$6.00 - $10.00

House salad with ham, turkey, salami, american and swiss cheese

Fruit Salad

$4.00 - $10.00

Grilled Chicken Salad

$6.00 - $10.00

Mixed light mayonnaise, carrots, celery, peppers on a bed of lettuce

House Salad

$4.00 - $8.00

Mixed lettuce with carrot, tomato and onion

Julius Caesar Salad

$5.00 - $9.00

Chopped romaine, special caesar dressing, focaccia croutons and grated cheese

Julius Caesar Salad w/ Grilled Chicken

$7.00 - $12.00

Junior’s Favorite Spinach Salad

$7.00 - $14.00

Fresh spinach, pear, blue cheese, crispy pancetta & walnuts

Junior’s Favorite Spinach Salad w/ Shrimp

$10.00 - $20.00

Mediterranean Salad

$7.00 - $12.00

Fresh greens, tomato, onion, scoop of rice, diced grilled chicken, olives and lemon oil and balsamic

Popeye’s Favorite

$6.00 - $10.00

Fresh spinach, feta cheese, onions, olives and focaccia

Tuna Portofino Salad

$6.50 - $10.50

Pineapple and chopped peppers with mayo, served on a bed of lettuce

Tuna Salad

$6.50 - $10.50

Light mayonnaise, served on a bed of lettuce and tomato

Mixed Pesto Salad

$8.99

Served with pesto sauce, sun-dried tomatoes and smoked mozzarella

Penne Pasta Salad

$8.99

Served with ricotta salata, smoked turkey and gaeta olives

Homemade Cole Slaw, Potato, Sicilian Potato or Macaroni Salad

$6.99

American Cole Slaw, Potato or Macaroni Salad

$3.99


Homemade Soup

Chicken Soup

$5.50 - $7.50

Broccoli Rabe Soup

$5.50 - $7.50

Escarole and Bean Soup

$5.50 - $7.50

Pasta Fagiole Soup

$5.50 - $7.50

Pastina or Spinach Soup

$5.50 - $7.50


Pasta

Farfalle con Funghi

$11.00 - $18.00

Bowtie pasta with porcini and cremini mushrooms in a light mascarpone sauce

Fried Baby Ravioli

$11.00 - $18.00

Served with a dipping tomato sauce

Linguine with Clams or Shrimp

$14.00 - $22.00

Served with white or red sauce

Manicotti, Ravioli or Stuffed Shells

$11.00 - $18.00

Served in our homemade tomato sauce

Penne a la Vodka

$11.00 - $18.00

Served in a light cream tomato sauce, peas and a touch of vodka

Rigatoni Alla Ava

$11.00 - $20.00

Pasta primavera with garlic and butter sauce

Rigatoni Alla Giuliano

$14.00 - $22.00

White wine reduction and peppers

Rigatoni Alla Isabella

$11.00 - $18.00

Light cream sauce with grilled zucchini and grilled chicken

Rigatoni Melenzana

$11.00 - $18.00

Served with grilled chicken, chopped eggplant and fresh spinach

Baked Ziti

$12.00 - $25.00

Served with meat

Lasagna

$12.00 - $25.00

Served with meat

Veggie Lasagne

$12.00 - $25.00

Served with mixed veggies


Hot Rolls, Heros, Focaccia & Platters

Big Boy Brooke’s Famous Porchetta

$9.00 - $20.00

Spicy calabrese-style roast pork, served with smoked mozzarella and hot or sweet peppers

Chicken Cutlet Milanese

$7.50 - $18.00

Grilled or breaded, served with lettuce, tomato, red onion and Italian dressing

Chicken Parmigiana

$7.50 - $18.00

Breaded chicken cutlets covered with homemade tomato sauce and mozzarella

Eggplant Parmigiana

$7.50 - $18.00

Sliced eggplant covered with homemade tomato sauce and mozzarella

Marco Polo

$7.50 - $18.00

Seared chicken breast with plum tomatoes, mushrooms, raisins and fresh or smoked mozzarella

Mario’s Special

$9.50 - $23.00

Grilled veal, thin-sliced prosciutto di parma and fresh mozzarella

Meatball Parmigiana

$7.50 - $18.00

Delicious meatballs covered with homemade tomato sauce and mozzarella

Poor Boy Shrimp Special

$8.50 - $23.00

Breaded shrimp deep fried and served on a bed of lettuce and tomato with hot sauce

Sausage and Peppers

$7.50 - $18.00

Grilled sweet sausage with roasted peppers and onions

Shrimp Parmigiana

$8.50 - $23.00

Sea-fresh breaded shrimp covered with homemade tomato sauce and mozzarella

Veal Alla Giuliano

$9.50 - $24.00

Tender veal with white wine reduction and peppers

Veal Parmigiana

$8.50 - $24.00

Tender veal covered with homemade tomato sauce and mozzarella


From the Grill

Grilled Chicken

$7.50 - $19.00

Served with lemon or honey mustard sauce and choice of escarole or sauteed broccoli rabe

Grilled Swordfish

$11.00 - $30.00

Served in a lemon mustard sauce

Grilled Beefsteak

$8.50 - $18.00

Served with cheese, add $0.50 extra

Chicken Teriyaki with Broccoli

$8.50 - $18.00


Individual Platters

Arthur Avenue Style Antipasto Platter

$14.00 - $26.00

The best prosciutto, dry sausage, mixed cheeses, roasted peppers, olives and toasted focaccia

Cheese and Fruit Platter

$12.00 - $22.00

Seasonal fresh fruit served with mixed cheeses, sun-dried tomato bread and toasted focaccia

Fresh Mozzarella and Tomato

$8.00 - $18.00

Bruschetta Crostini

$6.50 - $12.00

Fresh chopped tomatoes served on thin-sliced crostini with fresh mozzarella

Caponata Crostini

$6.50 - $12.00

Eggplant, peppers, onion in tomato caper sauce

Burrata Platter

$12.00 - $24.00

Homemade burrata with radicchio, truffle oil and crispy speck


House Panini

Da True Bronx Tale

$8.00

Mortadella, fresh mozzarella, shavings of sharp provolone, tomato with oregano, basil and olive oil on focaccia

Hillary Clinton’s Favorite

$6.00

Salami, smoked mozzarella, sun-dried tomatoes, sweet peppers and olive oil on Italian seeded bread

Italian Combo

$8.00

Mortadella, ham, salami, capicolo, provolone, lettuce and sweet peppers on focaccia

Michelangelo

$6.00

Fresh mozzarella, prosciutto, lettuce, tomato and basil on Italian seeded bread

Paula Deen

$10.00

Prosciutto di parma, hot sopressata, radicchio, fresh mozzarella, sun-dried tomatoes and truffle oil on focaccia

Veggie Special

$8.00

Grilled zucchini, grilled eggplant, sweet peppers, onions and lettuce on focaccia


Stuffed Breads

Chicken

$5.50 - $9.00

Chicken and Broccoli Rabe

$5.50 - $9.00

Eggplant

$5.50 - $9.00

Meatball

$5.50 - $9.00

Mushroom and Broccoli

$5.50 - $9.00

Pasta and Fagioli

$5.50 - $9.00

Pepperoni and Cheese

$5.50 - $9.00

Sausage and Broccoli Rabe

$5.50 - $9.00

Greco Special

$5.50 - $9.00

Shrimp

$7.00 - $12.00

Veal and Peppers

$7.00 - $12.00


Good Ole Favorites

Big Mike Combo

$7.50 - $9.00

Mortadella, ham, salami, capicolo and provolone

Big Vinny’s Favorite

$8.00 - $9.50

Sopressata, ricotta salata and homemade roasted peppers

The Godfather

$8.00 - $9.50

Served with oldani salami and imported provolone

Herb’s Sandwich

$8.00 - $9.50

Goat cheese with fresh tomato and roasted peppers or sun-dried tomatoes

King David

$9.00 - $12.00

Sopressata with chunks of 4-year-old parmigiano, roasted peppers and basil

Michelangelo

$10.50 - $12.00

Served with fresh mozzarella and prosciutto

The Mussolini

$8.00 - $9.50

Capicolo, shavings of fontinella cheese and anchovies

The Raging Bull

$8.00 - $9.50

Hot sopressata and sharp provolone

Sophia Loren

$6.50 - $8.00

Swiss lorraine and turkey

Towering Inferno

$8.00 - $9.50

Smoked mozzarella and smoked prosciutto

Virgin Mary

$6.00 - $7.50

Pure, white & fresh mozzarella

The Wanderer

$8.00 - $9.50

Sweet sopressata & homemade dry mozzarella


Special Combinations

The Albanian Special

$9.00 - $12.00

Dry filet mignon bresaola with fresh mozzarella or feta cheese

Big Ben

$7.50 - $9.00

Virginia ham, peppered ham, salami and provolone

Cool Steve’s Favorite

$8.50 - $10.00

Ham, sopressata, fresh mozzarella, topped with sweet peppers and marinated mushrooms

Da True Bronx Tale

$7.50 - $9.00

Mortadella, fresh mozzarella, shavings of sharp provolone, tomato with oregano, basil and olive oil

Don Michele

$8.50 - $10.00

Homemade hot sopressata, dry mozzarella with hot peppers

Emeril’s Spice

$9.00 - $12.00

Capicolo, peppered ham, pecorino, lettuce, hot peppers, sauteed mushrooms and onions

Follow the Leader

$9.00 - $12.00

Grilled chicken topped with eggplant parmigiana

Garden of Eden

$7.50 - $9.00

An assortment of grilled vegetables with lettuce, tomato and onion

Hey Charlie

$6.50 - $8.50

Chopped tuna salad with celery, carrots & light mayonnaise

Hillary favorite

$7.00 - $9.00

Salami, smoked mozzarella, sun-dried tomatoes, sweet peppers and lettuce

Isabella Special (7-Grain Bread)

$7.00

Sliced provolone, avocado, lettuce, tomato, onion and crispy pancetta

John Wayne

$7.50 - $9.00

Roast beef with imported swiss cheese

Lidia’s Favorite

$8.00 - $10.00

Smoked prosciutto, taleggio, apples and walnuts

Marvin Goes Italiano

$8.00 - $9.50

Hot or cold lean pastrami, topped with fresh mozzarella

Paula Deen Special

$9.00 - $12.00

Prosciutto di parma, hot sopressata, radicchio, fresh mozzarella, sun-dried tomatoes and truffle oil

Pavarotti

$8.50 - $10.00

Napolitano-style eggplant, smoked prosciutto and fresh mozzarella, available hot or cold

SGT. Holder’s Special

$8.50 - $10.00

Grilled or breaded chicken, smoked mozzarella and sun-dried tomatoes

Sweet Bird

$7.00 - $8.50

Honey roasted turkey, smoked mozzarella and sun-dried tomatoes

T.C.-The Fireman Special

$10.50 - $12.00

Oldani salami, peppered ham, sopressata, fresh mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, sun-dried tomatoes and roasted peppers

The Three Tenors

$8.50 - $10.00

Smoked mozzarella accompanied by three tender meats-prosciutto, mortadella and capicolo

Yankee Stadium Big Boy

$11.50 - $13.00

Mortadella, ham, salami, capicolo and mozzarella extra heavy with lettuce, sweet or hot peppers

The Monster (1/2 Pizza Bread)

$6.00

Roasted pork, roasted crispy spec, shoe string fries, mushrooms, onions, swiss, lettuce, tomato, hot peppers and greco special.

The Monster (Full)

$30.00

Roasted pork, roasted crispy spec, shoe string fries, mushrooms, onions, swiss, lettuce, tomato, hot peppers and greco special.


Toppings and Extras

Eggplant

$0.75

Grilled, fried or marinated

Sun-Dried Tomatoes

$1.00

Artichokes, Mushroom or Stuffed Peppers

$1.50

Fresh Mozzarella

$1.50

Imported Prosciutto

$3.00

Fully Loaded

$2.00

Lettuce, tomato, peppers, onions, salt, pepper, oil and reduced balsamic

Brooklyn Style

Price may varies

Add mayo to any Italian sandwich for no additional charge


Side Orders

Broccoli Rabe, Escarole or Spinach

$4.50

Homemade Mixed Grilled Vegetables

$4.50

Rice Balls

$4.00

Potato Croquettes

$2.00

Special Shoestring French Fries (Sm)

$5.50

Special Shoestring French Fries (Lg)

$8.00


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading