Anna Maria Oyster Bar Menu and Prices

4.4 based on 144 votes
Anna Maria Oyster Bar Logo
Seafood

Choose My State

FL

Anna Maria Oyster Bar Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Bites, Oysters & Soups

Coconut Shrimp

$9.25

large shrimp dusted with coconut flakes, then fried to a golden brown. served with an apricot horseradish sauce for dipping

Mussels Provencal

$9.25

mussels sauteed in white wine, scallions, garlic, tomato, basil, olive oil and topped with parmesan cheese

Onion Straws

$5.25

thin slivers of onions, deep fried and served with our house horseradish sauce. (local favorites)

Quesadillas

$7.25

flour tortilla filled with seafood or chicken, green chilis, mozzarella and cheddar baked to perfection. served with lettuce, tomatoes, sour cream and salsa

Portabella Mushrooms

$6.25

portabella mushroom strips lightly breaded and deep fried. served with horseradish sauce

Raw Oysters

$7.25 - $11.25

Fried Oysters

$9.75

Steamed Oysters

$12.25 - $20.25

Oysters Rockefeller

$8.75 - $13.75

(local favorites)

Tuna Sashimi

$8.75

a premium cold smoked tuna loin lightly dusted with cajun seasonings and pan seared rare. sliced into thin medallions and accompanied with wasabi, pickled ginger and soy sauce

Peel -N- Eat Shrimp

$5.55 - $15.25

an oyster bar favorite for years and years. large gulf pink shrimp. (local favorites)

Escargot

$8.25

Buffalo Chicken Strips

$7.25

strips of chicken breast in a light batter, tossed with a spicy sauce and served with bleu cheese or ranch dressing

Crab Cake Appetizer

$5.99

a light combo of crab and seafood and special seasonings seared together and served with our homemade mustard sauce. a traditional florida delicacy

Calamari

$8.99

calamari rings and tentacles dusted with spicy italian breading, lightly fried and served with our homemade marinara sauce

New England Clam Chowder Or Spicy Seafood Gumbo

$3.55 - $4.99

Lobster Bisque

$5.99 - $7.99

our award winning recipe!


Salads

Caesar Salad

$5.25

garden fresh romaine, parmesan cheese, croutons and our own special caesar dressing

Garden Salad

$5.25

garden fresh romaine topped with tomato slices, red onion, parmesan cheese and croutons. served with your choice of ranch, honey dijon, bleu cheese, thousand island, italian, fat-free raspberry vinai


Salads.Add any of the following items to your caesar or garden salad to make a great meal!

Grouper Grilled Or Blackened

Price may varies

Shrimp Sauteed

$9.55

Yellow Fin Tuna

$10.55

grilled or blackened. we recommend rare

Chicken Breast

$8.25

fried, grilled or blackened


FishServed with choice of two french fries, red bliss potatoes, our own seasoned rice cole slaw, applesauce, vegetable of the day (substitute a caesar or garden salad for 1.99).

Tilapia Almondine

$14.49

strips of tilapia rolled in sliced almonds and fried, served with amaretto butter for your delight

Cajun Onion Crusted Salmon

$14.99

a salmon filet topped with our mild cajun mustard then baked with our spiced cajun fried onion straws. (local favorites)

Grouper Your Way

Price may varies

everybody's favorite! tell us how you like it; blackened, fried, sauteed or grilled

Grouper Oscar

Price may varies

baked grouper topped with crabmeat stuffing, asparagus and hollandaise sauce

Nutty Grouper

Price may varies

grouper coated with a walnut crust. oven baked or deep fried. served with cajun mustard sauce on the side

Fresh Atlantic Salmon

$14.99

atlantic salmon grilled to perfection and served with hollandaise sauce on the side. or try it blackened. (local favorites)

Stuffed Flounder

$11.49

flaky flounder stuffed with crabmeat stuffing and baked to perfection. topped with hollandaise sauce

Yellow Fin Tuna

$13.99

tuna seared, grilled or blackened. we recommend it rare. (local favorites)

Mahi Mahi

$11.49

a generous portion of mahi mahi grilled, fried or blackened. or try our caribbean jerk seasoned mahi with mango chutney

Farm-Raised Catfish

$12.49

delicious farm-raised catfish filet. fried or blackened

Fish & Chips

$9.99

the biggest seller at the oyster bar! flaky pollock deep fried to a golden brown


Pasta SkilletsAbove pasta dishes are served with your choice of a garden salad or a caesar salad.

Creamy Garlic Alfredo

$9.99 - $14.99

a long time anna maria oyster bar favorite. a traditional cream based sauce loaded with garlic, parmesan cheese and cracked black pepper. sinfully rich and thick. served over linguine

Anna Maria Island Pasta

$16.49

shrimp and scallops sauteed in olive oil and garlic, tossed with artichoke hearts, diced tomatoes, fresh basil and a touch of wine in our own herb sauce. served over linguine

Shrimp/Scallop Pasta

$14.99

all shrimp or all scallops or 1/2 and 1/2. sauteed scampi style over a bed of linguini


Lobster & CrabThe following dinners are served with choice of two: french fries, red bliss potatoes, our own seasoned rice, cole slaw, applesauce, vegetable of the day. (substitute a caesar or garden salad for 1.99).

Live Maine Lobster

Price may varies

whole steamed maine lobster (1 to 1 1/4 lb). served on a beer tray with drawn butter

Baked Stuffed Lobster

Price may varies

whole maine lobster (1 to 1 1/4 lb) stuffed with crabmeat stuffing and baked to perfection. delicious

Florida Lobster Tail

$22.99

warm water lobster tail, baked to perfection. a local favorite!!!

Alaskan King Crab Legs

$19.99

the "big boys"! one full pound (usually a little more) steamed and served with drawn butter. roll up your sleeves and dig in! (local favorites)


Seafood

Fried Gulf Shrimp

$14.49

twelve gulf shrimp beer battered and deep fried. an oyster bar favorite for years and years!!!

Florida Crab Cakes

$13.49

a light combo of crab and seafood and special seasonings seared together and served with our homemade mustard sauce

Sea Scallops

$16.49

ten plump sea scallops that'll just melt in your mouth like "buttah". sauteed or fried

Shrimp & Scallops

$14.99

tasty shrimp and sea scallops all sauteed or all fried golden brown. you gotta try these two!

“Popcorn” Shrimp

$11.99

a boatload of tender shrimp lightly breaded and deep fried. this basket is guaranteed to fill you up!

Coconut Shrimp

$15.49

large round shrimp dusted with coconut flakes, then fried to a golden brown. served with an apricot horseradish sauce for dipping. (local favorites)

Fried Clam Strips

$11.49

clam strips lightly battered and deep fried

Fried Oysters

$16.99

large select oysters beer batter dipped and deep fried to a golden brown

Shrimp Scampi

$14.49

twelve shrimp sauteed in our house scampi sauce. eat a mint before going home!

Captain's Combo

$15.99

all sauteed or all fried tilapia, bay scallops and 6 shrimp all sauteed in olive oil, garlic butter and wine, or beer batter dipped and fried golden brown. what a combo! outstanding flavor. (local fa

First Mate Combo

$13.99

all sauteed or all fried tilapia, 3 shrimp and bay scallops. for the lighter appetite


Not SeafoodServed with choice of two: french fries, red bliss potatoes, our own seasoned rice cole slaw, applesauce, vegetable of the day (substitute a caesar or garden salad for 1.99).

Chicken Marsala

$11.49

a large, tender chicken breast sauteed in marsala wine sauce, garlic and fresh mushrooms

Chicken Breast

$10.49

a large tender breast served any way you want it! grilled, fried, or blackened

Baked Chicken Mullaney

$11.99

a chicken breast topped with fresh brouchetta and mozzarella cheese

Sirloin

$15.49

8 ounce angus sirloin grilled to perfection and topped with an onion straw garnish. add 6 golden fried shrimp for only $2.99

Grilled NY Strip Steak

$18.79

12 oz. usda choice center cut ny strip, grilled to perfection and topped with an onion straw garnish. add 6 golden fried shrimp for only $2.99

Danish Baby Back Ribs

$14.99

one full rack of tender pork ribs, served with our special sweet bbq sauce

Ribs & Chicken

$13.49 - $15.49

1/2 rack of baby back ribs and a grilled chicken breast cooked with our special sweet bbq sauce

Baby Back Ribs & Shrimp

$13.49

half rack of tender pork ribs and six shrimp battered and fried. served with our special sweet bbq sauce


SandwichesAll sandwiches are garnished with lettuce, tomato, red onion and a dill pickle spear. Served with cole slaw and fries. Add bacon, american, cheddar or provolone cheese for $0.75 extra.

Fried Fish Sandwich

$7.25

batter dipped pollock fried crisp on a kaiser roll

Giant Grouper Sandwich

Price may varies

the best grouper sandwich you'll find! your choice of grilled, fried or blackened

“AMOB” Burger

$7.55

1/2 lb. black angus grilled ground beef

Cajun BBQ Burger

$8.55

angus beef grilled to perfection! topped with cajun onions, bbq sauce and cheddar cheese


DessertsAsk your server about today’s special dessert!

Homemade Key Lime Pie

$3.49

Chocolate Seduction Cake

$4.29

Raspberry Amaretto Cheesecake

$4.29

Whole Key Lime Pie

$15.99

(to-go)


Beverages

Coffee, Hot Tea, Hot Chocolate Or Iced Tea

Price may varies

(sweetened or unsweetened) we proudly serve coca cola products.

Soft Drinks

Price may varies

(all of our soft drinks are bottomless) coke, diet coke, sprite, ginger ale, root beer and pink lemonade

Tropicana Orange Or Grapefruit Juice

Price may varies

we are especially proud to serve our hometown tropicana products

Bottled Water

Price may varies

House Wine

Price may varies

chardonnay, merlot, cabernet, white zinfandel

A Full Bar!

Price may varies

martinis, manhattans and our giant house margarita too!


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading