Choose My State

NY

Goat's Milk

Fig & Honey Chèvre

Price may varies

Humboldt Fog

Price may varies

Truffle Tremor

Price may varies

Midnight Moon

Price may varies

Green Chile Jack*

Price may varies

Classic Blue Log

Price may varies

Manchester*

Price may varies

Snowddrop

Price may varies

Sheep's Milk

Lamb Chopper

Price may varies

Ewe's Blue

Price may varies

Battenkill Brebis

Price may varies

Mixed Milk

Kunik

Price may varies

Hudson Valley Camembert

Price may varies

Buttercup

Price may varies

Cow's Milk

Asiago*

Price may varies

Oregonzola Blue*

Price may varies

Smokey Oregon Blue*

Price may varies

Tarentaise*

Price may varies

Tumbleweed*

Price may varies

Barely Buzzed

Price may varies

Robinson Family Swiss*

Price may varies

Marieke Gouda*

Price may varies

Grand Cru

Price may varies

SarVecchio Parm

Price may varies

Bella Balsamic

Price may varies

Lillè

Price may varies

Alpha Tolman*

Price may varies

Alehouse Cheddar

Price may varies

Cheese Plates

$18.00 - $32.00

3 Cheeses served with fresh bread, fig spread and toasted nuts

U-Pic

Soft

Price may varies

Fig & Honey, Classic Blue Log, Lillè

Semi

Price may varies

Buttercup, Robinson Family Swiss, Aged Marieke Gouda, Oregonzola

Firm

Price may varies

Bella Balsamic, Tumbleweed, Farmhouse Asiago, Tarentaise

We-Pic

Price may varies

See black board for house cheese plate selections

Creminelli Fine Meats, Utah

Finocchiona

$8.00

Dry cured salami infused with fennel

Sopressa

$8.00

Dry cured salami, garlic and black pepper

Copa

$9.00

Dry cured whole pork shoulder

Calabrese

$8.00

Dry cured salami with cayenne

Olli Salumeria, Virginia

Bresaola

$9.00

Dry cured hand rubbed beef, cinnamon and cardamom

Wild Boar

$9.00

Applewood smoked with Sangiovese

Additional Accompaniments

Fresh Bread

$2.00

Housemade Crostini

$3.00

House Mix Nuts & Dried Fruit

$3.00

Warm House Marinated Olives

$5.00

Pickled Things

$5.00

Gluten Free Crackers

$3.00

Small Platesavailable after 5pm Thursday - Saturday; August - 2016

American Onion Soup

$6.00

Slow braised onions, House-made crostini, melted Tarantaise

Fresh Fried Chèvre Salad

$10.00

Mixed greens, roasted beets, sliced apple, toasted walnuts, blood orange vinaigrette

Roasted Pork Tenderloin Flatbread

$14.00

House-roasted pork tenderloin, grilled pineapple, fresh mozzarella, house-blend cheeses, Sriracha drizzle

Fried Fresh Mozzarella Skewers

$10.00

Farmstand tomato peach bruschetta, fig balsamic drizzle

Bacon Wrapped Dates

$9.00

Bella Balsamic stuffed dates wrapped in bacon, Sriracha aioli

Triple Jerk Smoked Wings

$11.00

Brined, rubbed and sauced in jerk, Oregonzola dressing

All American Angus Sliders

$12.00

Paired with weekly changing accompaniments on a toasted bun!

Drink Specials

Blood Orange Bellini

$10.00

Pomegranate Bellini

$10.00

Springtime White Sangria

$10.00

Dessert

Price may varies

Ask about our fresh house-made desserts!

Wines and Beers

Price may varies

We have fantastic wines by the glass, and awesome local craft beer on tap! Wines change seasonally and local beers change weekly! Stop by for a glass of wine while tasting cheese at the counter, or h

Soup

American Onion

$6.00

Salad

Fried Fresh Chèvre Salad

$10.00

Mixed greens, crisp gala apple, port-soaked cherries, citrus vinaigrette

An American in Greece

$11.00

Crisp greens, tomato, cucumber, house-marinated olives, farm fresh feta, vinaigrette, toasted pita & tzatziki

Grilled Cheese Panini

Chutney & Cheese

$9.00

House-blend cheeses & seasonal Fruit Chutney

Roasted Mozz

$9.00

Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Tomato & Red Pepper, and Fig Balsamic

Le Bacon

$10.00

Aged Gouda, Virginia Ham, and Crispy Bacon

The Hawaiian

$11.00

House-roasted Pork Tenderloin, Grilled Pineapple, Swiss, Sriracha aioli

Local Roasted Coffee & Tea

Thunder Island Roasters, Southhampton

Price may varies

InFuse Tea Bar, West Sayville

Price may varies

House Made Desserts & Candies

Price may varies

FondueFondue is available in the Eatery all day all the time! For 2 - $28, For 4 - $48. Served with seasonal accompaniments & fresh bread. Choice of:

Traditional Swiss Style

Price may varies

Creamy Oregonzola Blue

Price may varies

How it WorksWe have lots of platter options, something to fit every occasion. How much should you order? 1 lb. of cheese feeds approximately 6-8 people. So, you build your plate according to you what you like. 2 pieces, 1/2 lb. each, 3 pieces, 1/3 lb. each, 4 quarter lb. pieces. 4 pieces, 1/2 lb. each would feed aproximately 12 - 16 people. Stop in for a taste and build your platter, or let us do it for you. Check out our website for some of our most popular combinations!

Slate

Price may varies

Slates make a beautiful cheese presentation and come in 2 sizes. Slates must be returned to American Cheese, or purchased at retail price. 2 sizes available for purchase. 3 Cheeses, 1/3 lb. each. 4 C

Bamboo

Price may varies

Our Bamboo plates and patters are environmentally friendly and disposable! 2 sizes available

Other Options

Large Catering

Price may varies

Let artisanal cheeses be the star at your next event!

Celebration Cakes

Price may varies

Types of Cheeses

Fresh

Price may varies

young and soft; Smooth and mild to tart and tangy; Think: fresh goat cheese (chèvre), mozzarella, ricotta, feta

Bloomy

Price may varies

rich, creamy, milky; Mild and buttery to earthy and mushroomy; Think: brie, camembert

Washed-Rind

Price may varies

pungent and intense; Mild and fruity to strong and funky; Think: munster, taleggio, chimay

Semi-Soft

Price may varies

earthy, pliable; Smooth and earthy to grassy and barnyard; Think: tomme, fontina

Firm

Price may varies

dense but supple; Fruity and grassy to sharp and nutty; Think: cheddar, gruyere, manchego

Hard

Price may varies

dry, caramelly, grainy; Sharp and crumbly to sweet and butterscotchy; Think: aged gouda, dry jack, parmigiano -reggiano

Blue

Price may varies

bold and sharp-edged; Mild and creamy to punchy and complex; Think: gorgonzola, roquefort, stilton

What does Artisanal mean?

Price may varies

The term artisanal simply means handcrafted in small batches, using traditional methods; the opposite of mass-produced, factory-made, and processed

Why is It Better?There are several reasons why artisanal cheeses are better than mass produced supermarket cheeses:

1st - Supporting small-scale farms and dairies supports local communities

Price may varies

keeping revenue in the community and away from major corporations and foreign competitors

2nd - By supporting smaller dairies and farms, you're supporting the environment.

Price may varies

The negative impacts of factory farms on the natural environment, animal welfare, and the health and well-being of people are well documented. Supporting local farms also cuts down on food transporta

3rd - And most importantly

Price may varies

The unsurpassed flavor! Once you try it, you'll be reluctant to settle for lesser quality

Info

What Does Farmstead Mean?

Price may varies

The term farmstead means the product was made using only milk from the animals from that particular farm

How Do I Store Cheese?

Price may varies

The best way to store cheese is not to store cheese! Eat it fresh, and buy smaller amounts more often. In case you don't have your own cheese cave, the vegetable drawer in your refrigerator will do f

How Do I Pair Cheese?

Price may varies

Just like a wine's flavor changes as it breathes, cheese will take on different flavors when paired with different items. There is no real science to this but there are two different methods: pairing

FavoritesTry some of these favorites:

Toasted almonds, walnuts, hazelnuts

Price may varies

toasting nuts brings out their flavor!

Crisp green apples, pears, kiwis, strawberries, grapes

Price may varies

Mild preserves like apricot and peach

Price may varies

Grape tomatoes, sliced cucumber, roasted red peppers

Price may varies

Savory spreads like pesto, chutney and hummus

Price may varies

Sweet drizzled honey or reduced balsamic vinegar

Price may varies

Main

Chocolate Pomegranate Bellini

Price may varies

Warm Mulled Wine

Price may varies

Gruet Sparkling White

Price may varies

American Onion Soup

Price may varies

Fried Chèvre Salad

Price may varies

Radicchio, greens, roasted beets, poached egg, blood orange vinaigrette

Winter Mussels

Price may varies

Fennel, shallots, shaved prosciutto, cream, toasts

Oysters Rock

Price may varies

House-blend & spinach, Hudson Valley Camembert

Lobster Mac & Cheese Stuffed Shells

Price may varies

Our famous shells with decadent lobster and fondue sauce

Roasted Pork Tenderloin

Price may varies

Cognac cream, cherry apple compote, toasted pearl couscous

Grilled Hanger Steak

Price may varies

Smashed fingerlings, Port wine reduction, melted Oregonzola

Delightful house-made desserts

Price may varies

American Cheese Menu and Prices

Choose My State