A Taste of the Big Apple Menu and Prices

3.9 based on 91 votes
A Taste of the Big Apple Logo

Choose My State

SD

A Taste of the Big Apple Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Appetizers

Garlic Cheese Bread

$4.00 - $6.00

Thick slices of garlic bread topped with mozzarella & served with marinara sauce

Grandma’s Knish

$8.00

4 Handmade potato filled pastries seasoned with onions & garlic. Served with yellow mustard

Stuffed Mushrooms Veggie or Sausage

$9.00

Fresh mushrooms stuffed with spinach & artichoke mix baked with mozzarella on top

Strombol

$10.00

A blend of spinach, artichoke & ricotta cheese baked in our pizza dough

Risotto Rice Balls

$9.00

3 Handmade risotto rice balls blended with herbs & Italian cheeses

Pepperoni Pinwheels

$9.00

A tasty blend of ricotta, mozzarella and provolone cheeses mixed together and rolled up into our homemade pizza dough with pepperoni, cut up into 4 easy to eat rolls

Crab Cakes

$10.00

Two delicious crab cakes on a bed of lettuce served with slices of lemon

Shrimp Cocktail

$10.00

Six jumbo shrimp served with homemade cocktail sauce


Soupsa and SaladsSalad dressing selections: Blue cheese, buttermilk ranch, caesar, french, italian,light raspberry vinaigrette, thousand island

Soup

$3.00 - $5.00

Choice of french onion or our soup of the day

Garden Salad

$3.00 - $6.00

Bowl of lettuce served with tomatoes, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, croutons and parmesan sprinkles served with your choice of dressings

Grilled Chicken Salad

$10.00

Grilled chicken slices served on a bowl of lettuce, veggies, croutons & parmesan cheese sprinkles with your choice of dressing

Chicken Caesar Salad

$10.00

Grilled chicken slices served on a bowl of lettuce, veggies, croutons & parmesan cheese sprinkles and tossed in caesar dressing

Buffalo Chicken Salad

$10.00

Grilled chicken tossed in buffalo sauce and placed on top of a bowl of lettuce, veggies, croutons & parmesan cheese sprinkles served with your choice of dressing


PastaServed with garlic bread & a small salad

Alfredo Chicken or Shrimp

$15.00

Penne pasta tossed in alfredo sauce topped with your choice of grilled chicken or sauteed jumbo shrimp

Baked Lasagna Beef or Veggie

$15.00

Lasagna rolls baked & topped with melted mozzarella

Chicken Marinara

$14.00

Penne pasta baked in marina & topped with grilled chicken

Parmesan Chicken or Eggplant

$14.00

Penne pasta baked in marinara topped with your choice of breaded chicken or breaded eggplant

Sausage, Pepper & Onion Pasta

$13.00

Penne pasta baked in marinara then topped with sausage, green peppers & onions

Meatball Pasta

$13.00

Penne pasta baked in marinara topped with juicy meatballs

Baked Ziti

$12.00

Penne pasta mixed with a blend of cheeses with a touch of marinara sauce


New York Pizza PiesAdd your own toppings: $1.50 Each anchovies, artichokes, black olives, canadian bacon, extra cheese, green olives, green peppers, hamburger, jalapenos, mushrooms, onions, pepperoni, pineapple, roasted red pepper & onion mix, sauerkraut, sausage, tomat

New Yorker

$19.00 - $22.00

Pepperoni, canadian bacon, hamburger & sausage

Original

$18.00 - $21.00

Pepperoni, sausage, onion & mushrooms

Flatiron

$18.00 - $21.00

Pepperoni, green pepper, onion & black olives

Liberty

$18.00 - $21.00

Pepperoni, canadian bacon, black olive & green olives

Beach Bum

$17.00 - $19.00

Canadian bacon & pineapple

Big Cheese

$14.00 - $16.00

Plain cheese or add your own toppings for $1.50 each

Veggie

$18.00 - $21.00

Onion, mushroom, green pepper & tomato

Rooftop BBQ

$19.00 - $22.00

BBQ sauce, chicken, pineapple, caramelized onions & bacon

Jimmy the Greek

$18.00 - $21.00

Feta, tomato, mozzarella, garlic oil & marinara sauce

Little Italy’s Garden

$19.00 - $22.00

Onion, mushroom, artichoke, tomato & marinara sauce

Sheepshead Bay Shrimp

$20.00 - $24.00

Jumbo shrimp, artichoke, garlic oil, bacon & scallions

Freddy the Chicken

$19.00 - $22.00

Chicken, alfredo sauce & roasted red pepper & caramelized onion mix

Buffalo Chicken

$19.00 - $22.00

Buffalo chicken, onion, green peppers & your choice of ranch or blue cheese as your sauce

Spanish Harlem

$25.00

Taco seasoned hamburger, black olives and mozzarella baked & topped with cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomatoes & tortilla chips. Served with a side of taco sauce & sour cream

Jersey Junker

$29.00

Pepperoni, canadian bacon, onion, mushroom, tomatoes, green peppers, green olives, black olives, hamburger, sausage & pineapple

Gluten Free Crust

$10.00

Build your own pizza, starting with a 10” gluten free crust already topped with sauce & mozzarella cheese. Add $1.00 for each topping


CalzonesServed with our signature pizza dough, ricotta cheese blend & side of marinara sauce. Calzone toppings: Anchovies, artichokes, black olives, canadian bacon, green olives, green peppers, hamburger, jalapenos, mushrooms, onions, pepperoni, pineapple, sa

Combo

$12.00

Pepperoni, sausage, onion & mushrooms

Veggie

$12.00

Onion, mushroom and mushrooms

Spicy Meatball

$12.00

Meatballs, jalapenos & crushed red pepper flakes

Cheese

$12.00

Plain cheese or build your own by choosing up to 4 toppings from the list of toppings below


Sandwiches

Buffalo Chicken

$9.00

A crispy chicken breast drenched in buffalo sauce on a kaiser bun topped with provolone, lettuce, tomatoes & ranch dressing. Served with a side of potato salad

French Dip

$9.00

Roast beef served on a hero bun, topped with melted cheese & served with a cup of au jus to dip your sandwich in. Served with a side of potato salad

Lamb & Beef Gyro

$12.00

Lamb & beef mixed meat topped with lettuce, onion, tomato, black olive, cucumber sauce & feta cheese on a pita

Meatball Mozza Hero

$9.00

Juicy meatballs smothered in mozzarella cheese & marinara sauce on a hero bun. Served with a side of pasta salad

New York Pastrami

$9.00

New york deli style pastrami on grilled rye bread. Served with a side of potato salad

Reuben Melt

$9.00

Corned beef smothered in sauerkraut, provolone cheese & thousand island dressing on grilled rye. Served with a side of pasta salad

Sausage, Pepper & Onion Hero

$9.00

A mild sausage link smothered in roasted red pepper & caramelized onion mix served on a hero bun. Served with a side of pasta salad

Turkey Melt

$9.00

Sliced turkey with melted provolone cheese on grilled rye bread. Served with a side of potato salad


Desserts

Cannoli

$5.00

A tube shaped shell of fried pastry dough, filled with a sweet, creamy chocolate chip mascarpone filling & dusted with powdered sugar

Funnel Cake Fries

$6.00

Tasty funnel cake batter baked into easy to eat fries & sprinkled with powdered sugar

New York Cheesecake

$6.00

Our cheesecake is creamy, smooth, rich, dense & absolutely delicious

Tiramisu

$7.00

Made of biscuits dipped in coffee, layered with a whipped mixture of egg yolks and mascarpone and flavored with liquor and cocoa

Gluten Free Brownie

$5.00

Densely chocolaty and deliciously chewy, these all natural fudge brownies have zero grams of trans fat per serving and no artificial colors or preservatives

Gluten Free Chocolate Chip Cookie

$5.00

Chocolate chip cookies made with gluten free dough. Has zero grams of trans fat and is certified gluten free


BeveragesAsk your server for our beer, spirits & wine menu. We proudly offer coca cola products

Fountain Soda

$2.25

Coke, diet coke, lemonade, mellow yellow, mr. pibb, sprite, kid’s size $0.75

Bottled Soda (20 oz.)

$1.95

Coke, diet coke, coke zero, cherry coke, sprite, sprite zero, fanta orange, a&w cream soda

Iced Tea

$2.25

Green, raspberry, sweetened, unsweetened

Coffee

$1.25

Regular only no decaf

Hot Tea

$1.25

Lipton brand tea bags served with steaming water

Juice

$2.00

Apple, cranberry, orange

Milk

$2.00

2% White or chocolate

Water - San Pellegrino

$4.00

Water - Evian Bottled Water

$1.95

Water - Club Soda

$1.25


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading