Menu With Price > Menu > Smoking Al's > NY > Bay Shore > 19 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY

Smoking Al's Prices in Bay Shore, NY 11706

3.9 based on 65 votes
Smoking Al's Logo
19 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY
(631) 206-3000
Smoking Al's Menu

Hours of Operation

Hours may fluctuate. For detailed hours of operation, please contact the store directly.

Restaurant Menu

Appetizers

Al's BBQ Nachos

A huge pile of corn tortilla chips, smothered with melted jack and cheddar cheeses, lettuce, tomato, salsa, jalapenos, and sour cream and then topped with your choice of al’s famous chili or chopped

$15.99

Al's Famous Chili

A delicious bowl of gourmet chili topped with melted cheddar and jack cheese.

$11.99

Haystack Of Onions

Wow! A huge stack of fried onion straws served with al's famous haystack sauce.

$14.99

Burnt Endz

A texas delicacy. After 12 hours of smokin’, the crusted seasoned ends of our brisket are chopped and served with al’s original sauce over a bed of haystack onions.

$12.99

Fried Pickles

Due to popular demand al has brought his version of an old southern delicacy to the menu. Served with al's famous pickle dipping sauce.

$10.99

Hush Puppies

A down home southern dish. Al's searched the south for the very best hush puppies. Give em' a try!

$10.99

Let's Wing It

Smoked chicken wings seasoned in al’s famous rub and then drenched in al’s famous original bbq sauce.

Some Like It Hot

Chicken wings, rubbed, smoked and then smothered with al's famous rattlesnake sauce.

BBQ Shrimp

Freshly grilled and coated with al's original sauce.

$12.99

Brunswick Stew

The roots of this legendary southern dish of meats and vegetables vary, we're just glad someone came up with it. Now try our version.

$9.99

Marc's Crock

Marc loves al's onion soup, so here it is! A heaping crock of home made onion soup smothered with melted cheese.

$9.99

Salads

Al's Famous Caesar

For over 2 decades al has served his caesar to all his loved ones, and they love it! Now it's your turn!

$12.99

BBQ Caesar

Al's caesar topped with your choice of our smokin'que.

$19.99

BBQ Garden Salad

A huge garden of salad topped with your choice of bbq meat or grilled chicken mixed with your choice of dressing.

$18.99

The Big House Salad

A large platter of lettuce, tomatoes, mushrooms, onions, and carrots with your choice of dressing.

$10.99

Fork N' Knife Sandwiches

Carolina Pulled Pork Sandwich

A southern classic. After 13 hours of being rubbed, mopped and slow smoked, our succulent pork softly pulls apart, then is marinated in smokin al's sweet talkin' sauce. Have it carolina style with ou

$11.99

Pulled Chicken Sandwich

Our slow smoked chicken is pulled apart and marinated in al's sweet talkin sauce and piled on a soft bun.

$11.99

Texas Sliced Brisket Of Beef Sandwich

Rubbed and slowly smoked to perfection for over 12 hours, then sliced to order or chopped and marinated in al's original bbq sauce.

$11.99

Grilled Chicken Sandwich

For those anti-bbq (shame on you) however you're our guest! We take a large succulent chicken breast and simply grill it and serve it on a soft bun with lettuce, tomato, and if you want we would love

$12.99

Al's Famous Bow Wow

We take the 2nd biggest hot dog you ever saw (1/2 pounder), grill it to perfection, place it on a long soft bun, then pile on al's famous chili - baked beans - cole slaw - and melted cheese, and then

$14.99

Let's Wrap It Up! BBQ Style

We take your choice of one of our chopped or pulled meats, shredded lettuce, chopped tomato & onion, and wrap it in a giant flour tortilla.

$12.99

Smoked Chicken Sandwich

Tender chicken thighs basted in al's rub, perfectly smoked, then placed on a soft bun, covered with warm bbq sauce.

$12.99

Smoked Sausage Sandwich

We smoke these sausages for hours, then grill ‘em, slice em and pile them on a po- boy bun topped with melted cheese and our haystack onions.

$13.99

The BBQ Spud

A huge piping hot baked potato topped with butter, cheddar cheese, sour cream, and chives. If you want we will fill it with your choice of bbq meat.

$9.99

The Big Melt

The big melt - take any of our bbq meats, smother it with our melted cheddar & jack cheeses and then top it with our famous haystack onions.

$15.99

The Works

For those who want it all! We take a long po-boy hero roll and stuff it with chopped brisket, pulled pork, smoked chicken, and smoked sausage. Smothered with melted cheese and then topped with our fa

$15.99

Burgers

BBQ Three Quarter Pounder Plus

No description available

$10.99

Chili Burger

Smokin’ al’s famous chili smothered on our 3/4 pounder plus with melted cheddar and jack cheese.

$14.99

Mile High Burger

Cheese, mushrooms, onions, and bacon all piled on this succulent 12 ounce burger.

$15.99

Two Mile High Challenge!!

If you have the appetite this one is for you! Two 12 oz. (that’s 1-1/2 pound total) burgers loaded with cheese, mushrooms, onions, bacon, lettuce & tomatoes piled high on one large sesame bun!

$23.99

Ribs! Ribs! Ribs!

Al's Specialty Baby Backs

This is al's signature dish! These tender babies are first rubbed with al's famous rub and then slowly smoked for up to 6 hours and blanketed with 3 separate coats of your choice of one of al's famou

St.Louie Grand Backs

This hearty cut of pork ribs are spiced with al's rub and then are left alone to be slow smoked for up to seven hours until the meat is just falling off the bone.

Monster Beef Bones

They say the meat is sweetest at the bone, and these big boys prove it! These meaty beef rib bones are rubbed, smoked and slathered with your choice of al's famous sauces.

The Combos

Combo 1 - Ribs N' Chicken

A half rack of st. louie grand ribs and half a smoked chicken.

$24.99

Combo 2 - Ribs N' Meat

A half rack of smoked baby backs and a choice of one of our bbq meats or smoked meats.

$23.99

Combo 3 - Ribs N' Ribs

This is for those who don't want to miss either of our pork ribs. A half rack of smoked baby back ribs and a half rack of st. louie grand ribs.

$24.99

Combo 4 - Ribs! Ribs! & More Ribs!

A feast of ribs which includes a half rack of baby backs, a half rack of st. louie grand ribs, and 4 monster bones.

$35.99

Platters

Platters

(Single platter choose 1 meat, double platter choose 2 meats, triple platter choose 3 meats).

$15.99 - $31.99

Meat

Pulled Pork, chopped brisket, pulled chicken, smoked chicken, grilled chicken breast, smoked sausage, sliced smoked brisket of beef, half a bbq chicken.

$1.00

Pulled Pork

After 13 hours of being rubbed, mopped and slow smoked our succulent pork softly pulls apart and then is marinated in smokin' al's sweet talkin' sauce. A southern delight!

Sides

Baked beans, macaroni n cheese, cole slaw, collard greens, garlic mashed potatoes, corn on the cob, fresh cut sweet potatoes fries, fresh cut potato fries, fresh cut potato fries w/ melted cheddar ch

$1.50

Chopped Brisket Of Beef

Smoked brisket chopped and marinated in al's original bbq sauce to perfection.

Pulled Chicken

Slowly smoked chicken, pulled apart and topped with al's sweet talkin' sauce.

Sliced Smoked Brisket

After 12 hours of being slow smoked with tender care enjoy the flavor and the tenderness of these slices of succulent meat. Warmly topped with your choice of al's sauces.

Smoked Chicken

Tender chicken thighs rubbed with al's famous rub, smoked and then warmly topped in al's bbq sauce of your choice.

Smoked Sausage

Sweet sausages slowly smoked and then grilled and slathered with al's original sauce.

Grilled Chicken Breast

Two succulent chicken breasts grilled and topped with your choice of al's bbq sauce or dry if you choose. (Come on! A little sauce won't hurt you!)

Half A BBQ Chicken

Add $1.00 for each 1/2 chicken to above prices. A plump meaty chicken smoked for hours, have it topped with your choice of al's sauces or dry.

Sides

Sauce Bottles

An authentic bottle of smokin' al's famous bbq sauce.

$6.00

Baked Beans

No description available

$6.00

Cole Slaw

No description available

Collard Greens

No description available

Corn On The Cob

No description available

Fresh Cut Potato Fries

No description available

Fresh Cut Sweet Potato Fries

No description available

Garlic Mashed Potatoes

No description available

Macaroni N' Cheese

No description available

Corn Bread

(Each piece).

$1.25

Roll

(Each).

$1.25

Kid's Menu

Chicken Fingers

No description available

$6.99

Grilled Cheese

No description available

$6.99

Hot Dog

No description available

$6.99

Jr. Hamburger

No description available

$6.99

Macaroni N Cheese

No description available

$6.99

Mozzarella Sticks

No description available

$6.99

Desserts

Fried Cheesecake

No description available

$6.75

Bourbon Street Crunch

No description available

$6.25

Bread Pudding

No description available

$6.75

Carrot Cake

No description available

$6.25

Crumby Apple Pie

No description available

$6.75

Key Lime Pie

No description available

$6.25

Miss Essie's Pecan Pie

No description available

$6.75

Mississippi Mud Pie

No description available

$6.25

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading