Menu With Price > Menu > Popover Cafe > NY > New York > 551 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY

Popover Cafe Prices in New York, NY 10024

4.9 based on 312 votes
Popover Cafe Logo
551 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY
(212) 595-8555
Popover Cafe Menu

Hours of Operation

Hours may fluctuate. For detailed hours of operation, please contact the store directly.

Restaurant Menu

Appetizers

Potato Latkes

(wheat free) with apple sauce, sour cream & chives entree portion with popover & garden salad $15.50

$8.75

Polenta Fries

With chipotle dip

$4.95

Salads

Free Range Bengali Chicken Salad

With apples, currants, red onion, scallion & garam masala in an orange dressing garnished with fresh fruit

$16.50

Garden Roasted Veggies

Portobello mushroom, artichoke heart, red onion, zucchini, red pepper & tomato on organic mesclun greens

$13.75

Nice Dice

Diced freshly roasted turkey breast with cucumber, red pepper, red onion, scallion, tomato, carrot, low fat jarlsberg with shredded spinach and dressing

$15.50

Baby Spinach & Goat Cheese Salad

With spiced candied walnuts, roasted pear, nueske's apple smoked bacon and red onion

$15.75

Riviera Salad

Chunk white tuna, mixed greens, artichoke heart, capers, string beans, niciose olives, red onion, fresh red pepper, hard boiled egg & tomato

$15.95

Frank’s Florida Salad

Mixed greens, grated carrot, avocado, artichoke heart, nueske's apple smoked bacon, tomato & hard boiled egg

$16.50

Bistro Salad

Arugula, goat cheese, roasted pear, toasted pecans, red onion

$13.95

Chopped Salad

Chunks of tomato, avocado, mozzarella, mushrooms, black forest ham, scallion & roasted red pepper on romaine with balsamic dressing

$15.50

Chef Salad

Mixed greens, free range chicken breast, black forest ham, gruyere, cheddar, mushroom, tomato & hard boiled egg

$16.95

What’s Up Waldorf

Carrots, walnuts, apple, raisins & blue cheese on organic mesclun greens

$14.75

Small Garden Salad

Romaine lettuce, tomato, cucumber & grated carrot

$5.25

Small Cafe Salad

Mushrooms, scallion & tomato on organic mesclun greens. Available without a popover for $4.50

$6.50

Small Cafe Salad

Mushrooms, scallion & tomato on organic mesclun greens. Available without a popover for $5.25

$6.50

Entree Salads

Sliced Filet Mignon Salad

With artichoke heart, avocado, tomato, roasted potato, roasted red pepper, organic mesclun greens & fizzled onions with balsamic vinaigrette

$18.75

Blackened Shrimp Salad

With orange segments, avocado, tomato, grilled red onion & herb croutons on wild greens with orange vinaigrette

$17.50

Grilled Free Range Chicken Greek Caesar

With feta, cucumber, tomato, kalamata olives, red onion & herb croutons on romaine with anchovy-parmesan dressing

$16.25

Herbed Free Range Chicken Tender Salad

With toasted pecan, pears, danish blue cheese, organic mesclun greens & lemon vinaigrette

$17.25

Seared Salmon Salad

Organic mesclun greens tossed with toasted almonds, tomato, bean sprouts, scallions, water chestnuts & maple tamari vinaigrette

$17.25

Fresh Grilled Salmon Riviera Salad

Mixed greens, artichoke heart, capers, string beans, nicoise olives, red onion, fresh red pepper, hard boiled egg & tomato

$17.50

Soups

Russian Beef & Cabbage Borscht

Served with a popover or served solo

$8.50 - $5.75

Soups of the Day

Served with a popover or served solo

$7.50 - $4.95

Entrees

Prime Filet Mignon

(8-9 Oz. Portion) au natural with your choice of potato and vegetable

$25.25

Petite

(4-5 Oz. Portion) served as above

$20.75

Salmon Health Watch (no added Fat)

Seared with black & white sesame seeds served with mashed sweet potato & string bean & orange soy sauce

$19.95

Free Range Chicken Pop Pie

A split popover filled with chunks of boneless chicken breast & seasonal vegetables (string beans, mushrooms, carrots, zucchini, potatoes, onions, peas & garlic) in a light cream gravy (extra popover

$17.75

Vegetarian Black Bean Chili (Topped with the Works)

The works: sour cream, cheddar cheese, avocado, scallion, red onion & diced tomato (can sub yogurt and low fat cheese - low fat/good carbs)

$15.95

Vegetarian Spaghetti Squash Primavera

Pomodoro sauce & diced vegetables (onions, carrots, zucchini, garlic, red pepper, green pepper, broccoli) tossed with spaghetti squash & fontina cheese on a bed of fresh spinach (low fat/good carbs)

$16.50

Vegetarian Spaghetti Squash Primavera - without Fontina Cheese

Pomodoro sauce & diced vegetables (onions, carrots, zucchini, garlic, red pepper, green pepper, broccoli) tossed with spaghetti squash & fontina cheese on a bed of fresh spinach (low fat/good carbs)

$14.95

Entrees After 5 Pm Additions

Blackened Fish Tacos (3)

With chipotle crema & grilled lime with a side of black bean chili & guacamole

$15.95

Almond Crusted Tilapia

With a hollandaise drizzle, brown rice pilaf & scafatta (a mix of snow peas, apple smoked bacon, leek & caramelized onion

$18.95

Specials - Entrees

Cheddar & Apple Stuffed Chicken Breast

Julienned vegetables & roasted garlic mashed potatoes

$19.25

Salmon or Tilapia En Papillote

Foil wrapped with capers, grape tomatoes, onion, dijon mustard & wine served with grilled asparagus & polenta triangles

$18.95

Gulf Shrimp with Wasabi-Lime Buerre Blanc

With brown rice pilaf and broccoli florets

$21.95

Filet Mignon Stroganoff

Sauced with mushrooms, onions, creme fraiche & dill on egg noodles with roasted carrots & zucchini

$19.95

Pumpkin Filled Ravioli

With toasted walnuts on a bed of spinach with a lemon & fresh herb buerre blanc

$17.95

Burgers

Prime Kobe Beef Burger

Served with roasted potatoes, lettuce & tomato

$14.95

Prime Kobe Beef Burger - with Sauteed Onions

Served with roasted potatoes, lettuce & tomato

$15.50

Prime Kobe Beef Burger - with Cheddar

Served with roasted potatoes, lettuce & tomato

$15.95

Prime Kobe Beef Burger - with Nueske's Apple Smoked Bacon & Cheddar

Served with roasted potatoes, lettuce & tomato

$17.50

Prime Kobe Beef Burger - with Garlic and Mozzarella

Served with roasted potatoes, lettuce & tomato

$15.95

Prime Kobe Beef Burger - Joannies’s Way with Horseradish-Cheddar & Russian Dressing

Served with roasted potatoes, lettuce & tomato

$15.95

Prime Sirloin Burger

One-half pound sirloin on eli’s sesame sandwich roll with roasted potatoes, lettuce & tomato

$12.25

Prime Sirloin Burger - with Sauteed Onions

One-half pound sirloin on eli’s sesame sandwich roll with roasted potatoes, lettuce & tomato

$12.75

Prime Sirloin Burger - with Cheddar

One-half pound sirloin on eli’s sesame sandwich roll with roasted potatoes, lettuce & tomato

$13.25

Prime Sirloin Burger - with Nueske's Apple Smoked Bacon & Cheddar

One-half pound sirloin on eli’s sesame sandwich roll with roasted potatoes, lettuce & tomato

$14.75

Prime Sirloin Burger - with Garlic and Mozzarella

One-half pound sirloin on eli’s sesame sandwich roll with roasted potatoes, lettuce & tomato

$13.25

Prime Sirloin Burger - Joannies’s way with Horseradish-Cheddar & Russian Dressing

One-half pound sirloin on eli’s sesame sandwich roll with roasted potatoes, lettuce & tomato

$13.25

Salmon Burger

Chunks of salmon seasoned with sauteed onions & herbs, on an eli’s sesame sandwich roll with arugula, tomato, tartar sauce & rosemary roasted potatoes

$13.95

Turkey Burger

Freshly ground bell & evans turkey burger on a kaiser roll with arugula & tomato with a side of rosemary roasted potatoes

$10.95

Slim Bear Low Carb Turkey Pizza Burger

Freshly ground bell & evans turkey burger on a platter topped with pomodoro sauce & melted mozzarella with a side of sauteed vegetables

$11.95

Vegetarian Burger

On a kaiser roll with arugula & tomato served with a yogu1t-cucumber dill dressing & roasted potatoes

$8.95

Melted Sandwiches

Quesadilla

Filled with free range chicken, grilled red onion, scallion, black bean chili, cheddar & mozzarella with a tomato avocado salsa

$13.95

Grilled Free Range Chicken

With red onion, roasted red pepper, portobello mushroom, arugula, mozzarella & chipotle ciabatta with a side of rosemary roasted potatoes

$13.95

Grilled Sliced Filet Mignon

Tossed with sauteed onions & red peppers, topped with melted mozzarella, tomato, arugula & mayo on rosemary ciabatta mayonnaise on rosemary with a side of rosemary roasted potatoes

$15.95

Mad Russian

Black forest ham, free range chicken breast, nueske's apple smoked bacon, tomato, melted gruyere, russian dressing, with a side of pasta salad

$12.95

Granny

Fresh bell & evans turkey breast, granny smith apple, turkey, bacon, melted cheddar, red onion, arugula, raisin-horseradish dressing with a side of pasta salad

$12.95

Sweet William

Melted gruyere, black forest ham, pear, arugula, russian, with a side of pasta salad

$11.95

Turkey Tarantella

Roasted bell & evans turkey breast, roasted red pepper, red onion, arugula, herb vinaigrette & melted mozzarella with a side of pasta salad

$11.95

Sorry Charlie

Tuna salad, avocado, tomato & melted cheddar & arugula served open-faced with a side of pasta salad

$13.95

Kathleen’s Vegetarian Avocado Melt

Avocado, mushroom, tomato, arugula, melted gruyere and russian dressing with a side of pasta sala

$10.95

Grilled Vegetables on Ciabatta

Zucchini, red pepper, portobello mushroom & artichoke heart with melted mozzarella & basil garlic oil with a side of pasta salad

$11.25

Vegetarian Pop Art

Try this on a popover-a little messy but a knockout) marinated artichoke, roasted red pepper, arugula, red onion, melted mozzarella & russian with a side of pasta salad

$10.95

Sandwiches

Sunshine Cab Co

Free range chicken breast, nueske's apple smoked bacon, avocado & mayonnaise

$10.25

Sunshine Cab Co - Cabby

With the works: red onion, lettuce, tomato

$10.95

Sandy’s Favorite

Nueske's apple smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato, sliced hard boiled egg & russian dressing

$8.95

Wassanova

Smoked salmon, wasabi cream cheese, tomato, red onion & arugula

$11.95

Chunky Chicken Salad

Poached free range white meat chicken tossed with celery, carrot, scallion & mayo

$9.95

Chunky Chicken Salad - with Nueske's Apple Smoked bacon

Poached free range white meat chicken tossed with celery, carrot, scallion & mayo

$11.95

Tuna Salad

Tossed with celery, carrot, scallion & mayo

$9.95

Tuna Salad - Tuna

With the works: red onion, lettuce tomato

$10.65

Popovers

Basket of Three Popovers

No description available

$7.75

Single Popover

No description available

$2.95

Omelettes & Scrambles

Cranberry, Nueske's Apple Smoked Bacon & Cheddar

No description available

$12.95

The Capricorn

Goat cheese, wild shitake mushroom & spinach

$13.95

Sauteed Mushroom, Mozzarella & Rosemary Roasted Potatoes

No description available

$11.95

Santa Fe

Onion, peppers, tomatoes, chilies & cheddar cheese, sauteed onions & diced tomato

$11.95

The Real New Yorker

Horseradish, cheddar cheese, sauteed onions & diced tomato

$11.95

Health Watch - Egg White Omlette

With jarlsberg, diced tomato, scallion. Fresh basil & sauteed mushrooms served with a low-fat chicken-apple sausage (200 cal) or andouile sausage (150 cal) with whole grain toast or a popover

$13.95

Special Scramble

Three eggs scrambled with smoked norwegian salmon, cream cheese & chives & a popover

$13.95

Aegean Scramble

With feta cheese, herb roasted tomatoes, sauteed onion & black olives, chives & a popover

$11.95

Creole Scramble

With andouille sausage, garlic, onion, horseradish, cheddar & tomato & a popover

$12.95

Omelight

Any omelette made with egg white add $1.25

$1.25

Griddle

Challah French Toast

Topped with strawberries, cinnamon sugar & pure organic maple syrup

$11.95

Coconut-Almond Crusted Challah French Toast

Made with egg white & skim milk with bananas

$12.95

Mel’s Health Watch Baked Orange-Vanilla Challah French Toast

Made with egg white and skim milk) served with a strawberry-orange compote

$11.95

Lemon Twist Pancakes

With fresh berries & a side of our lemon syrup

$10.95

Multi-Grain (Wheat, Corn, Rice) Buttermilk Flapjacks

With warm blueberry compote

$10.95

Cereals

Our Own Toasted Honey-Vanilla Granola

With grains, nuts & dried fruits served milk or yogurt & topped with bananas

$7.95

Steel Cut Irish Oatmeal

Served until 11:30 am topped with chunky apple sauce & brown sugar served with heavy cream or milk.

$7.95

Eggstras

Kobe Corned Beef Hash

No description available

$8.95

Fresh Chicken and Apple Sausage (no Pork)

No description available

$4.50

Black Forest Ham

No description available

$4.50

Nueske's Apple Smoked Bacon or Turkey Bacon

No description available

$4.50

Fresh Chunk Black Pearl Salmon, Onion & Herb Patty

No description available

$5.50

Cheese-Onion-Pepper Grits

No description available

$4.75

Rosemary Roasted Potatoes

No description available

$4.25

Fresh Fruit Cup

No description available

$6.95

Eggspecialies

Eggs Benedict Arnold

A split-open popover filled with black forest ham, three fried eggs & lemon hollandaise

$14.95

Eggs Benedict Arnold - with Smoked Norwegian Salmon Instead of Ham

A split-open popover filled with black forest ham, three fried eggs & lemon hollandaise

$15.95

Eggs Popeye

A split-open popover filled with norwegian smoked salmon, creamed spinach, three fried eggs & lemon hollandaise

$16.50

Italian Eggs Benedict

Sauteed polenta triangles topped with with black forest ham, 3 fried eggs & lemon hollandaise sauce

$14.95

Kobe Corned Beef Hash

With 3 eggs. Fried or scrambled & a popover

$14.95

Carolina Dinah Special

Back by popular demand. Grilled jambon de paris, (that’s a french ham steak, hereabouts) with red-eye gravy, cheddar-onion-pepper grits, 3 eggs, fried or scrambled & a popover

$15.25

Flopover

An eggy, baked pancake (like a hearty crepe) filled with sauteed apples, pears & currants topped with cinnamon sugar and sour cream

$12.95

French Flopover

An eggy, baked pancake (like a hearty crepe) filled with fontina, roasted pears, diced jambon de paris & scallions

$13.95

Drinks

Chilled Fresh Apple Cider or Cranberry Apricot Punch

No description available

$3.95

Hot Mulled Apple Cider or Apricot Punch

No description available

$4.25

Natural Lemonade

No description available

$3.95

Arnold Palmer (½ Lemonade/½ Iced Tea)

No description available

$3.95

Orange Juice Squeezed on Premises

No description available

$4.50 - $6.25

Florida Squeezed Grapefruit

No description available

$3.50 - $4.25

Pomegranate Juice

No description available

$6.00

Cranberry Juice

No description available

$3.50

Sacramento Tomato Juice or Mott’s Apple Juice

No description available

$2.75

S. Pellegrino

No description available

$2.95 - $6.50

Seltzer (Two Cents Plain)

No description available

$1.95

Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Ginger Ale

No description available

$2.50

Milk or Skim Milk

No description available

$2.50

Milk Shakes (Vanilla, Black & White, Chai or Espresso)

No description available

$4.95

Milk Shakes (Pomegranate or Creamsicle)

No description available

$5.50

Coke Float

No description available

$4.50

Coffees

House Blend - Fair Trade Regular or Decaf

No description available

$2.95

Cappuccino or Latte

No description available

$4.25

Mint, Almond or Hazelnut Cappuccino

No description available

$4.50

Espresso

No description available

$3.25

Decaf Espresso

No description available

$3.50

Mocachaccino (no Sugar Added)

No description available

$4.50

Teas

Organic Earl Grey, English Breakfast, Chai, Green, Fiji Green

With wild pineapple & papaya, mint, chamomile or cinnamon orange.

$2.95

Iced Orange Pekoe (In Season)

No description available

$2.95

Decaf Earl Grey or English Breakfast

No description available

$2.95

Sweetened Chai (Spiced Honey Tea Steamed With Milk)

No description available

$4.25

Iced Chai

No description available

$4.25

Cocoas & Hot Chocolate

Belgian Cocoa

With a side of homemade whipped cream add $1.25

$4.25

Mint, Almond or Hazelnut Cocoa

No description available

$4.50

Super Fudge Belgian Cocoa

No description available

$4.75

Charlie Brown Peanut Cocoa

No description available

$4.75

White Cloud Caramelcino

Contains no chocolate, coffee or caffeine

$4.25

Mexican Hot Chocolate

The new favorite. Thick with real bittersweet chocolate, spiced with ancho chili, cinnamon and vanilla (available without chili)

$4.50

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading