Menu With Price > Menu > Paul & Jimmy's > NY > New York > 123 E 18th St, New York, NY

Paul & Jimmy's Prices in New York, NY 10003

4.8 based on 214 votes
Paul & Jimmy's Logo
123 E 18th St, New York, NY
(212) 475-9540
Paul & Jimmy's Menu

Hours of Operation

Hours may fluctuate. For detailed hours of operation, please contact the store directly.

Restaurant Menu

Antipasti

Frutta Di Mare

squid, octopus, shrimp, olive oil & lemon

$12.00

Vongole Arreganate

clams baked with seasoned bread crumbs

$9.00

Melanzane Rollatini

rolled eggplant stuffed with ricotta & mozzarella baked with tomato sauce

$11.00

Melanzane Alla Parmigiana

eggplant parmigiana

$11.00

Calamari Fritti

battered & fried calamari served with marinara sauce

$11.00

Caprese

homemade mozzarella & tomato

$9.00

Minestrone

fresh vegetable soup

$8.00

Pasta E Fagioli

cannellini beans with pasta in broth

$8.00

Antipasto Misto

assorted cold appetizers

$18.00

Frutta Di Mare

squid, octopus, shrimp, olive oil & lemon

$15.00

Prosciutto Di Parma E Formaggio

italian ham, fontina, pecorino romano, grana padana & olives

$11.00

Vongole Arreganate

clams baked with seasoned bread crumbs

$11.00

Melanzane Rollatini

eggplant stuffed with ricotta & mozzarella baked in tomato sauce

$12.00

Calamari Fritti

battered & fried served with marinara sauce

$13.00

Caprese

homemade mozzarella & tomato

$10.00

Portobello Arrostiti

roasted peppers, arugula, fontina & balsamic vinegar

$11.00

Spiedini Alla Romano

baked mozzarella & bread topped with anchovy sauce

$12.00

Carciofi Fritti

fried artichokes

$12.00

Minestrone

fresh vegetable soup

$9.00

Pasta E Fagioli

cannellini beans with pasta in broth

$9.00

Antipasto Misto

assorted cold appetizers.

$12.00

Caprese

homemade mozzarella, tomatoes and basil.

$10.00

Prosciutto Di Parma E Melone

imported italian ham with seasonal melon.

$11.00

Antipasto Caldo

assorted hot appetizers.

$14.00

Calamari Fritti

fried calamari with marinara sauce.

$13.00

Vongole Arreganate

clams baked with seasoned bread crumbs.

$11.00

Spiedini Alla Romana

baked mozzarella and bread topped with anchovy sauce.

$12.00

Melanzane Alla Parmigiana

eggplant parmigiana.

$13.00

Frutta Di Mare

squid, octopus, shrimp, and scungilli with olive oil, lemon, parsley and basil.

$15.00

Peperoni Rossi Arrostiti E Acciugh

fresh roasted sweet peppers and anchovies.

$10.00

Prosciutto Di Parma E Formaggio

imported italian ham with fontina, pecorino romano, grana padano cheeses and olives.

$11.00

Zucchini Fritti

fried zucchini.

$9.00

Carciofi Aglio Olio

fresh artichokes sautéed in garlic and oil.

$12.00

Vongole Posillipo

clams in marinara sauce.

$12.00

Melanzane Rollatini

rolled eggplant stuffed with ricotta and mozzarella and baked in tomato sauce.

$13.00

Asparagi Con Olio Di Tartufo

asparagus with prosciutto, fortina and truffle oil.

$11.00

Insalate

Insalate Alla Cesare

caesar salad

$9.00

Insalate Mista

mixed greens, roasted peppers & tomatoes with olive oil & vinegar

$8.00

Insalate Di Spinaci

baby spinach with pears, walnuts, bacon & gorgonzola

$11.00

Arugula E Pomodori

field lettuce & tomato wrapped with eggplant & shaved parmesan

$9.00

Tricolore Con Balsamico

radicchio, arugula & endive with balsamic vinaigrette

$10.00

Insalate Di Pera E Gorgonzola

mixed greens with sliced pears & walnuts with gorgonzola dressing

$11.00

Bietole E Carciofi

salt roasted beets, braised artichokes & walnuts

$12.00

Insalate Alla Cesare

No description available

$10.00

Insalate Di Spinaci

baby spinach with pears, walnuts, bacon & gorgonzola

$11.00

Tricolore Con Balsamico

radicchio, arugula, endive, balsamic vinaigrette

$11.00

Insalate Speciale

leaf lettuce, tomatoes, roasted peppers, olives, mozzarella, soppressata & shrimp

$11.00

Bietole E Carciofi

salt roasted beets, braised artichokes & walnuts

$12.00

Insalate Mista

mixed greens with roasted peppers and tomatoes.

$9.00

Insalate Di Portobello

grilled portobello mushrooms with radicchio, arugula and endive.

$11.00

Insalate Alla Cesare

caesar salad.

$10.00

Insalate Di Rucola

arugula wrapped with grilled eggplant, topped with shaved parmesan and tomatoes.

$10.00

Insalate De Spinaci

baby spinach with pears, walnuts, bacon and gorgonzola.

$11.00

Bietole E Carciofi

salt roasted beets with braised artichokes and toasted walnuts.

$12.00

Insalate Speciale

leaf lettuce, tomatoes, roasted peppers, olives, mozzarella, soppressata and shrimp.

$11.00

Tricolore Con Balsamico

radicchio, arugula, and endive, tossed with our house vinaigrette.

$10.00

Insalate Di Cavoletti De Bruxelle

shaved brussel sprouts, walnuts, tomato and grana padana.

$12.00

Primi

Ravioli

homemade cheese-filled pasta with tomato sauce

$16.00

Ziti All Vesuvio Con Polpette

baked ziti with meatballs

$17.00

Linguine Alle Vongole

clams, white wine & garlic

$17.00

Penne Portofino

shrimp, artichokes & sun-dried tomatoes

$18.00

Spaghetti Alla Carbonara

pancetta & onions in cream sauce

$16.00

Fettuccine Filetto Di Pomodoro

homemade pasta with pancetta, prosciutto, onions & plum tomatoes

$16.00

Orecchiette Alla Baresi

hat-shaped pasta with sausage, peas, mushrooms & sun-dried tomatoes

$16.00

Gnocchi Alla Sorrentina

homemade potato dumplings baked with ricotta & tomato sauce

$16.00

Lasagne Alla Napoletana

homemade pasta layered with meat & cheese baked with tomato sauce

$16.00

Rigatoni Alla Bolognese

tubular pasta in a rich meat & mushroom sauce

$16.00

Linguine Alle Vongole

clams, white wine & garlic

$18.00

Penne Portofino

shrimp, artichokes & sun-dried tomatoes

$19.00

Fusilli Alla Puttanesca

spiral-shaped pasta with capers, olives, anchovies & garlic

$18.00

Tortellini Alla Panna

meat-filled pasta with peas & prosciutto in cream sauce

$18.00

Spaghetti Alla Carbonara

pancetta & onions in cream sauce

$18.00

Fettuccine Filetto Di Pomodoro

homemade pasta with pancetta, prosciutto, onions & plum tomatoes

$18.00

Cannelloni Alla Fiorentina

homemade pasta filled with veal & spinach in bechamel sauce

$19.00

Orecchiette Alla Baresi

hat-shaped pasta with sausage, peas, mushrooms & sun-dried tomatoes

$18.00

Gnocchi Alla Sorrentina

homemade potato dumplings baked with ricotta & tomato sauce

$18.00

Lasagne Alla Napoletana

homemade pasta layered with meat & cheese baked with tomato sauce

$19.00

Ravioli Alla Bolognese

homemade pasta filled with cheese

$18.00

Secondi

Pollo Alla Parmigiana

chicken parmigiana served with pasta

$18.00

Pollo Alla Scarpariello

small pieces of chicken sautéed with garlic, vinegar, white wine & lemon

$21.00

Vitello Milanese

pan-fried breaded veal cutlet topped with grilled eggplant & chopped salad

$20.00

Saltimbocca Alla Romano

veal topped with prosciutto in butter sage sauce

$20.00

Filetto Di Salmone Alla Griglia

grilled salmon

$21.00

Gamberi Primavera

shrimp with fresh vegetables in a light tomato sauce

$20.00

Dentice Livornese

red snapper poached with white wine, olives, capers, anchovies and tomato

$21.00

Pollo Al Forno

half roasted chicken with fresh herbs

$21.00

Pollo Alla Campagnola

chicken & sausage sautéed with peppers, onions, mushrooms & tomato

$21.00

Pollo Alla Scarpariello

small pieces of chicken sautéed with garlic, vinegar, white wine & lemon

$21.00

Spiedini Alla Siciliana

veal stuffed with provolone & prosciutto in garlic, lemon & white wine

$24.00

Saltimbocca Alla Romano

veal topped with prosciutto in butter sage sauce

$23.00

Vitello Alla Capricciosa

pan-fried breaded veal cutlet topped with grilled eggplant & chopped salad

$23.00

Scallopini Al Funghi Con Prosecco

veal with shitake mushrooms & prosecco

$23.00

Lombata Di Vitello Con Funghi

veal chop with wild mushrooms with truffle oil

$30.00

Bistecca Alla Pizzaiola

black angus ny strip steak topped with shitake mushrooms in marinara sauce

$30.00

Scampi Al Risotto

shrimp sautéed in garlic, lemon & butter with risotto

$23.00

Filetto Di Salmone Con Asparagi

salmon with asparagus & sun-dried tomatoes in mustard cream sauce

$24.00

Branzino

whole roasted mediterranean sea bass with garlic, olive oil, white wine, lemon & herbs

$26.00

Zuppa Di Pesce

snapper, calamari, shrimp & clams in tomato, garlic broth

$28.00

Dolce

Cannoli

italian pastry shell filled with cream

$6.00

Torta Di Ricotta

italian cheese cake

$7.00

Torta Di Cioccolata

chocolate mousse cake

$7.00

Tiramisu

espresso flavored ladyfingers & mascarpone cheese

$7.00

Zabaglione

italian custard

$7.00

Cannoli

italian pastry shell filled with cream

$6.00

Torta Di Ricotta

italian cheese cake

$7.00

Torta Di Cioccolata

chocolate mousse cake

$7.00

Tiramisu

espresso flavored ladyfingers & mascarpone cheese

$7.00

Zabaglione

italian custard

$7.00

Frutta E Gelati

Spumoni

vanilla, chocolate & pistachio ice cream

$5.00

Tortoni

vanilla ice cream topped with crushed almonds

$5.00

Tartufo

vanilla & chocolate ice cream with chopped nuts & cherry covered in chocolate

$7.00

Sorbetti Assortiti

lemon or orange sorbet

$7.00

Frutta Fresca Di Stagione

fresh seasonal fruit

$7.00

Spumoni

vanilla, chocolate & pistachio ice cream

$5.00

Tortoni

vanilla ice cream topped with crushed almonds

$5.00

Tartufo

vanilla & chocolate ice cream with chopped nuts & cherry covered in chocolate

$7.00

Sorbetti Assortiti

lemon or orange sorbet

$7.00

Frutta Fresca Di Stagione

fresh seasonal fruit

$7.00

Contorni

Zucchine Fritti

No description available

$9.00

Scarola Saute

No description available

$7.00

Broccoli Di Rape Affogati

bitter broccoli with garlic & olive oil

$9.00

Piselli Con Prosciutto

peas sautéed with prosciutto & onion

$7.00

Cavoletto Di Bruxelles

brussel sprouts, shallots & lemon

$7.00

Crocchette Di Patate

potato & cheese rolled & fried

$2.00

Broccoli Saltati

broccoli sautéed with garlic and olive oil.

$7.00

Spinaci Saltati

spinach sautéed with garlic and olive oil.

$7.00

Piselli Con Prosciutto

peas sautéed with prosciutto and onion.

$7.00

Scarola Saltati

escarole sautéed with garlic and olive oil.

$7.00

Broccoli Di Rape Affogati

bitter broccoli with garlic and olive oil.

$9.00

Asparagi Gratinata

asparagus baked with romano cheese and butter.

$8.00

Choice Of One Appetizer

Minestrone

fresh vegetable soup

Vongole Arreganate

baked clams with seasoned bread crumbs

Insalata Mista

mixed greens, roasted peppers & tomatoes with olive oil & vinegar dressing

Peperoni Rossi Arrostiti Con Mozzarella

fresh roasted sweet red peppers with mozzarella

Melanzane Rollatini

rolled eggplant stuffed with ricotta & mozzarella baked with tomato sauce

Choice Of One Entree

Salmone Alla Griglia

broiled salmon

Vermicelli Con Gamberi

thin spaghetti with shrimp in marinara sauce

Vitello Alla Fiorentina

veal cutlet sautéed in butter & wine served with spinach

Scallopini Pizzaiola

scallops of veal sautéed in garlic, mushrooms, white wine & tomato sauce

Petto Di Pollo Francese

boneless chicken breast sautéed with prosciutto, lemon, white wine & butter

And One Dessert

Torta Di Ricotta

creamy italian cheese cake

Cannoli

italian pastry shell filled with cream

Spumoni

vanilla, chocolate & pistachio ice cream

Tortoni

vanilla ice cream topped with crushed almonds

Melon In Season

No description available

Coffee

tea or espresso

Small Plate Menu

Lentil Arugula Grana Padana

No description available

$7.00

Shaved Brussel Sprouts Walnuts Tomato Grana Padana

No description available

$7.00

Ribolitta

tuscan minestrone stew

$8.00

Assorted Olives Fresh Herbs Orange Peel

No description available

$5.00

Caponata Eggplant Zucchini Tomato

No description available

$7.00

Asparagus Prosciutto Fontina Truffle Oil

No description available

$10.00

Stuffed Pepper Caponata Mozzarella

No description available

$7.00

Fried Artichokes

No description available

$7.00

Escarole Cannellini Beans

No description available

$8.00

Prosciutto Di Parma Mortatella Sopressata Capicola

No description available

$9.00

Homemade Mozzarella Tomato Roasted Pepper

No description available

$7.00

Mozzarella Grana Padana Fontina Provolone

No description available

$8.00

Wild Mushroom Risotto Truffle Oil

No description available

$10.00

Cavatelli Mushrooms Mascarpone

No description available

$10.00

Crab Asparagus Crostini

No description available

$9.00

Chicken Liver Crostini

No description available

$7.00

Chicken Wings Bacon Port Wine Reduction

No description available

$7.00

Walnut Crusted Chicken Breast Honey Mustard

No description available

$9.00

Meatballs Garlic Toast

No description available

$8.00

Grilled Calamari

arugula, garlic, olive oil, lemon

$9.00

Smoked Salmon Fennel Lemon Capers

No description available

$9.00

Mussels Shallot Broth Saffron

No description available

$9.00

Shrimp

wrapped with prosciutto honey mustard

$9.00

Scallops Bacon

No description available

$9.00

Shrimp BLT

No description available

$7.00

Bluepoint Oysters

No description available

$2.00

Clams Casino

No description available

$8.00

Grilled Octopus Chick Pea Puree

No description available

$9.00

White

Jacobs Creek Chardonnay

australia

$10.00

Due Torre Pinot Grigio

veneto

$11.00

Bancroft Sauvignon Blanc

new zealand

$11.00

Red

Estrella Merlot

california

$9.00

Collegiata Montepulciano D'abruzzo

abruzzo

$9.00

Campobello Chianti

tuscany

$11.00

Estrella Cabernet Sauvignon

california

$11.00

Jacobs Creek Shiraz

australia

$11.00

Casarsa Pinot Noir

italy

$11.00

Blush

Montevina White Zinfandel

amadore county

$9.00

Sparkling

Mionetto Prosecco Brut

italy

$11.00

Marquis De La Tour Brut NV

france

$12.00

Zuppa $9

Minestrone

fresh vegetable soup.

Stracciatella Alla Fiorentina

consommé with egg, spinach, and romano cheese.

Pasta E Fagioli

cannellini beans with pasta.

Primi Piatti

Fettuccini Filetto Di Pomodoro

homemade pasta with pancetta, prosciutto, onions and plum tomatoes.

$18.00

Fettuccini Filetto Di Pomodoro

appetizer

$14.00

Fettuccini Filetto Di Pomodoro

pasta option: substitute w/ whole grain spaghetti, substitute w/ penne.

Ravioli

homemade pasta filled with cheese.

$18.00

Ravioli

appetizer

$14.00

Cannelloni Alla Fiorentina

homemade pasta filled with veal and spinach in a bechamel sauce.

$19.00

Cannelloni Alla Fiorentina

appetizer

$15.00

Cannelloni Alla Fiorentina

pasta option: substitute w/ whole grain spaghetti, substitute w/ penne.

Gnocchi Alla Sorrentina

homemade potato dumplings baked with ricotta and tomato sauce.

$18.00

Gnocchi Alla Sorrentina

appetizer

$14.00

Vermicelli Con Gamberi

thin spaghetti with shrimp in a marinara sauce.

$19.00

Vermicelli Con Gamberi

appetizer

$15.00

Vermicelli Con Gamberi

pasta option: substitute w/ whole grain spaghetti, substitute w/ penne.

Fusilli Alla Primavera

spiral-shaped pasta in a sauce of fresh vegetables.

$18.00

Fusilli Alla Primavera

appetizer

$14.00

Fusilli Alla Primavera

pasta option: substitute w/ whole grain spaghetti, substitute w/ penne.

Penne Alla Vodka

pasta option: substitute w/ whole grain spaghetti, substitute w/ penne.

$18.00

Penne Alla Vodka

appetizer

$14.00

Bucatini Puttanesca

thick spaghetti with capers, olives, garlic and anchovies in tomato sauce.

$18.00

Bucatini Puttanesca

appetizer

$14.00

Bucatini Puttanesca

pasta option: substitute w/ whole grain spaghetti, substitute w/ penne.

Lasagna All Napoletana

homemade pasta layered with meat and cheese and baked in tomato sauce.

$18.00

Tortellini Alla Panna

meat-filled pasta with peas and prosciutto in a cream sauce.

$18.00

Tortellini Alla Panna

appetizer

$14.00

Tortellini Alla Panna

pasta option: substitute w/ whole grain spaghetti, substitute w/ penne.

Orechietti Alla Barese

hat-shaped pasta with sausage, peas, mushrooms and sun-dried tomatoes.

$18.00

Orechietti Alla Barese

appetizer

$14.00

Orechietti Alla Barese

pasta option: substitute w/ whole grain spaghetti, substitute w/ penne.

Penne Portofino

shrimp, artichokes and sun-dried tomatoes.

$19.00

Penne Portofino

appetizer

$15.00

Penne Portofino

pasta option: substitute w/ whole grain spaghetti, substitute w/ penne.

Spaghetti Alla Carbonara

pancetta and onions in a cream sauce.

$18.00

Spaghetti Alla Carbonara

appetizer

$14.00

Spaghetti Alla Carbonara

pasta option: substitute w/ whole grain spaghetti, substitute w/ penne.

Fettuccini Alla Bolognese

homemade pasta with meat sauce.

$18.00

Fettuccini Alla Bolognese

appetizer

$14.00

Fettuccini Alla Bolognese

pasta option: substitute w/ whole grain spaghetti, substitute w/ penne.

Linguini Alla Vongole

linguini in red or white clam sauce.

$18.00

Linguini Alla Vongole

appetizer

$14.00

Linguini Alla Vongole

pasta option: substitute w/ whole grain spaghetti, substitute w/ penne.

Linguini Alla Vongole

linguine sauce: red sauce, white sauce.

Ziti Vesuvio Con Polpetti

baked ziti with meatballs.

$19.00

Ziti Vesuvio Con Polpetti

appetizer

$15.00

Ziti Vesuvio Con Polpetti

pasta option: substitute w/ whole grain spaghetti, substitute w/ penne.

Pollo $21

Pollo Alla Scarpariello*

small pieces of chicken sautéed with garlic, vinegar, white wine and lemon.

Pollo Alla Scarpariello*

bone in/boneless option: bone in, boneless.

Pollo Alla Campagnola*

chicken and sausage sautéed with peppers, onions, mushrooms and tomato.

Pollo Alla Campagnola*

bone in/boneless option: bone in, boneless.

Pollo Alla Forno

half roasted chicken with fresh herbs.

Pollo Alla Toscana

boneless chicken topped with fontina cheese in a bechamel and tomato sauce.

Pollo Alla Cacciatore*

hunter style chicken with mushrooms, prosciutto and and tomato.

Pollo Alla Cacciatore*

bone in/boneless option: bone in, boneless.

Petto Di Pollo Alla Bolognese

boneless chicken topped with prosciutto and mozzarella and baked in a marsala butter sauce.

Petto Di Pollo Francese

boneless chicken sautéed with prosciutto, lemon, white wine and butter.

Pollo Alla Parmigiana

chicken parmigiana.

Carne

Bistecca Alla Griglia

grilled n.y. strip steak.

$30.00

Bistecca Alla Pizzaiola

black angus n.y. strip steak topped with shiitake mushrooms in a marinara sauce.

$30.00

Fegato Alla Veneziana

calf's liver sautéed with onions, white wine and vinegar.

$23.00

Bistecca Alla Siciliana

black angus n.y. strip steak topped with bread crumb seasonings, white wine and lemon.

$30.00

Salsiccia Con Brocoli Di Rape

sausage with sautéed onions, red peppers and broccoli rabe.

$22.00

Vitello

Vitello Alla Capriciosa

pan-fried breaded veal cutlet topped with grilled eggplant and chopped salad.

$23.00

Scaloppine A Limone

No description available

$23.00

Spiedini Alla Siciliana

veal stuffed with provolone and prosciutto in garlic, lemon and white wine.

$24.00

Scallopini Sorrentina

veal baked with eggplant, prosciutto and mozzarella.

$23.00

Lombata Mediterraneo

veal chop with shallots, white wine, rosemary and tomato sauce.

$30.00

Lombata Arrabiata

veal chop with hot cherry peppers, garlic, olive oil and white wine.

$30.00

Saltimbocca Alla Romano

veal topped with prosciutto in a butter-sage sauce.

$23.00

Scaloppine Alla Porto Con Funghi

scallops of veal with shiitake mushrooms in a port wine sauce.

$23.00

Vitello Alla Parmigiana

No description available

$23.00

Rollatine Marsala E Funghi

veal stuffed with mozzarella and prosciutto in marsala and mushroom sauce.

$24.00

Lombata Con Portobello

veal chop with portobello mushroom, shallots and balsamic vinegar.

$30.00

Pesce

Scampi Al Risotto

shrimp sautéed with garlic, lemon and butter served with risotto.

$23.00

Filetto Di Salmone Con Asparagi

salmon with asparagus and sun-dried tomatoes in a mustard cream sauce.

$24.00

Zuppa Di Pesce

red snapper poached with clams, sole, squid, shrimp, and scallops in a light tomato sauce.

$28.00

Gamberi Francese

batter-fried shrimp sautéed with butter, lemon and white wine.

$23.00

Dentice Livornese

red snapper poached with white wine, olives, capers, anchovies and tomato.

$24.00

Gamberetti Primavera

shrimp with fresh vegetables.

$23.00

Dessert

Tiramisu

homemade.

$7.00

Cannoli

italian pastry shell filled with cream.

$6.00

Torta Di Ricotta

italian cheese cake.

$7.00

Chocolate Mousse Cake

No description available

$7.00

Beverages

Soda

soda choice: coke, diet coke, sprite.

$3.00

Pellegrino

sparkling water.

$4.00 - $7.00

Iced Tea

No description available

$3.00

Panna

flat water.

$7.00 - $4.00

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading