Menu With Price > Menu > Mariner's Inn > WI > Madison > 5339 Lighthouse Bay Drive, Madison, WI

Mariner's Inn Prices in Madison, WI 53704

4.6 based on 108 votes
Mariner's Inn Logo
5339 Lighthouse Bay Drive, Madison, WI
(608) 246-3120
Mariner's Inn Menu

Hours of Operation

Hours may fluctuate. For detailed hours of operation, please contact the store directly.

Restaurant Menu

To Begin Your Voyage

Grouper Fingers

A half or full order of lightly breaded strips of grouper, flash fried and served with our island salsa.

$8.99 - $14.99

Tenderloin Stuffed Portobello

Stuffed with tenderloin steak and finished with our house-made whiskey peppercorn sauce, then lightly drizzled with horseradish cream sauce.

$14.99

Seafood Stuffed Mushrooms

Shrimp and crabmeat stuffing, glazed with hollandaise.

$11.99

Shrimp Cocktail

Eight or sixteen scrumptious shrimp served with our house-made cocktail sauce. Gluten free

$9.99 - $19.99

Calamari

No description available

$9.99

Captain's Stack of Rings

Ultra-thin onion rings with our creamy cajun sauce.

$7.99

Cheese Curds

Lightly breaded, served with Parmesan peppercorn sauce.

$7.99

Spinach Stuffed Mushrooms

A delicate blend of chevre cheese and spinach; finished with Hollandaise sauce. Gluten free

$10.99

Mariner's Shrimp

Four of those famous deep fried jumbo shrimp you just can’t find anywhere else

$13.99

Seafood Sampler Platter

Our famous Mariner’s fried jumbo shrimp, paired with scallops and clam strips.

$19.99 - $39.99

Steaks

Steer Tenderloin

Gluten free

$29.99 - $34.99

Admiral's Tenderloin

Twin petite tenderloin filets topped with asparagus, seared scallops, crab, and bearnaise sauce. Gluten free

$34.99

New Pork Strip

Gluten free

$33.99

Portehouse

Gluten free

$34.99

Chef's Tenderloin

Bacon-wrapped and served on a pool of mushroom ragout then finished with our house-made whiskey peppercorn sauce. Served with green beans in addition to your choice of our normal side dishes.

$34.99

Bone-In Ribeye

Gluten free

$38.99

Tenderloin Medallions

A trio of mini tenderloin steaks topped with our most popular steak enhancers… Béarnaise sauce, carmelized onions with crumbled Bleu Cheese, and whiskey peppercorn sauce. (A single enhancer on all t

$33.99

Lighter Fare

Tenderloin Stuffed Portobello

A portobello mushroom stuffed with tenderloin steak, finished with our house-made whiskey peppercorn sauce then lightly drizzled with horseradish cream sauce.

$18.99

Chicken Betty Lou

Chicken breast stuffed with wild rice and a portobello, shitake, button mushroom blend; set atop a bed of sautéed spinach,nestled in tomato and basil bruschetta then glazed with a delicate chardonnay

$17.99

Fried Jumbo Shrimp Trio

No description available

$14.99

Tenderloin Duet

Two tenderloin medallions topped with any of our delicious steak enhancers (add 1.99 for béarnaise & crabmeat).

$18.99

Vegetable Encroute

A blend of fresh vegetables surrounded by flaky golden brown puff pastry, lightly drizzled with a roasted red pepper cream sauce.

$15.99

Petite Salmon Fillet

Gluten free

$12.99

Petite Tenderloin

Served open-face. Gluten free

$14.99

Vegetarian's Delight Alfredo

R.P.’s locally made Fettucini tossed with fresh vegetables in a house-made Alfredo sauce; gluten-free pasta also available. (Add grilled chicken for only 2.99). Gluten free

$16.99

Tenderloin of Romance

A petite tenderloin with scallops, crab, bearnaise sauce, and asparagus. Gluten free

$22.99

Seafood

Mariner's Shrimp

The famous deep-fried jumbo shrimp you just can’t find anywhere else.

$26.99

Macadamia Encrusted Grouper

The decadent flavor of this filet is complemented by our chambord raspberry sauce and a refreshing mango salsa.

$24.99

Cajun Orange Roughy

New zealand roughy, broiled to perfection, set atop a bed of sauteed spinach, topped with a shrimp and scallops, then drizzled with a creamy cajun sauce.

$28.99

Salmon Florentine

Fresh salmon stuffed with spinach, tomatoes, red and green peppers, and mushrooms; then drizzled with a light white wine dill cream sauce.

$26.99

Salmon Florentine

Plain broiled salmon. Gluten free

$23.99

Canadian Walleye

A northwoods tradition broiled to perfection. Gluten free

$21.99

Mediterranean Tilapia

A delicate, mild-flavored fish topped with a refreshing salsa made from fresh tomatoes, black and green olives, bell peppers, red onions and seasoned olive oil. Gluten free

$19.99

Cold Water Lobster Tail

Gluten free

Stuffed Shrimp

Shrimp and crabmeat stuffing glazed with hollandaise.

$27.99

Lobster Tails

Twin 6 oz. tails of succulent lobster, served with drawn butter from wisconsin. Gluten free

$39.99

Sirloin Combo Dinners

Jumbo Shrimp

Available deep fried or stuffed

$30.99

Lobster Tail

Gluten free

$36.99

Tenderloin Combo Dinners

Jumbo Shrimp

Available deep fried or stuffed

$38.99

Lobster Tail

Gluten free

$44.99

Cold Water Lobster

Gluten free

Friday Seafood Specials

Canadian Walleye Fish Fry

A generous, lightly breaded mouth watering filet.

$17.99

Broiled Haddock

Served with soup or salad, plus choice of starch or vegetable. Gluten free

$14.99

Fish Fry

Deep fried Haddock served with fries and cole slaw. Substitute as many side dishes as you wish for just 1.99 each

$12.99

Seafood Combo Platter

Three Mariner’s shrimp paired with a lightly breaded grouper fillet.

$18.99

Side Dishes

World Famous Clam Chowder

The von rutenberg family award winning recipe

Mariner's Dinner Salad

A classic supper club salad. Gluten free

Legendary Hash Browns

No description available

Betty Lou Au Gratin Potatoes

Our version of this classic favorite

Baked Potato

Gluten free

Steak Fries

No description available

Fresh Vegetable

Gluten free

Garlic Mashed Potatoes

House made and simply scrumptious

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading