Menu With Price > Menu > Madison and Main > NY > Sag Harbor > 126 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY

Madison and Main Prices in Sag Harbor, NY 11963

4.3 based on 71 votes
Madison and Main Logo
126 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY
(631) 808-3600
Madison and Main Menu

Hours of Operation

Hours may fluctuate. For detailed hours of operation, please contact the store directly.

Restaurant Menu

Super - Starters

Bouchot Mussels 1 lb

Herbs, garlic, shallots, white wine, garlic toast

$12.00

Braised Angus Short Ribs of Beef & Barley Risotto

Crispy red onions

$14.00

Charleston Wild Giant Shrimp

Creamy grits, crispy shallots

$15.00

Fresh Jumbo Lump Crab Cakes

Roasted corn, avocado, tomato, salad

$16.00

Whole Belly Ipswich Clams

Crispy, chipotle tartare sauce

$16.00

Fritto Misto

Calamari, scallops, shrimp, zucchini, shiitake, herbs, lemon aioli

$16.00

Eastern Shore Steamer Clams 1 lb

Savory old bay herb broth

$18.00

Super - Soups & Salads

Roasted Corn, Carrot, Fresh Pea Chowder

Brushetta of summer mushrooms

$10.00

North Fork Baby Lettuce Salad

Champagne vinegar, heirloom tomatoes, vermont goat cheese

$12.00

Romaine Hearts & Treviso Caesar Salad

Parmesan, garlic toast, anchovy dressing

$12.00

Peconic Fisherman’s Soup

Shrimp, scallop, fish, garlic toast, saffron, aioli, fennel

$14.00

Iceberg Wedge Salad

Crisp bacon lardons, heirloom tomato, maytag blue cheese dressing

$14.00

Super - Mains, Fish & Pasta

Petite Ravioli of Fresh Peas

Braised summer vegetable broth

$22.00

Pan Seared Local Fillet of Sole

Brown butter, capers, lemon, parsley, red potatoes

$28.00

Roasted Black Sea Bass

Summer vegetable cous-cous, heirloom tomatoes, baby clams

$28.00

Montauk Tuna

Roasted, sicilian style, eggplant, garlic, pine nuts, balsamic glaze

$29.00

Eastern Sea Scallops

Seared, white beans, corn & summer vegetable succotash

$29.00

Supper - Raw Bar

Eastern Shore Clams

Little necks (6)

$9.00

Eastern Shore Oysters

Montauk, blue point, blue island (6)

$16.00

Wild Giant Shrimp Cocktail

Chilled & iced (6)

$18.00

Hard Shell Maine Lobster

Chilled & iced half 2 lb lobster

$19.00

Raw Bar Platters

Iced half 2 lb chilled lobster 6 little neck clams 6 local oysters 6 giant shrimp cocktail

$49.00

Super - For the Table

Crispy Stuffed Meatballs

Sheep milk cheese, herbs & lemon

$10.00

Crab Stuffed Top Neck Clam

Seafood stuffed cherry stone clams

$13.00

Wild Mushroom Flat Bread

Spinach, parmesan & goat cheese

$14.00

Charred Octopus, Hot Chili Peppers, Olives & Tomato

Garlic

$16.00

Local Tuna Citrus Ceviche

Roasted pineapple salsa & tobiko

$16.00

Lobster Slider

Fresh shucked lobster, lemon, potato roll

$18.00

Super - Mains, Meat & Poultry

Nicolas Prime Angus Burger

Smoked bacon, caramel onions, wisconsin cheddar, fried potatoes

$18.00

Charcoal Grilled Organic Chicken Paillard

Chopped mediterranean salad, feta cheese

$22.00

Organic Chicken

Herb crusted, cast iron pressed, parmesan mashed potatoes

$25.00

Roasted Crisp Crescent LI Duck

North fork root vegetables, orange & cherry jus

$29.00

Fried Herb Potatoes

Fried Idaho Potatoes

No description available

$8.00

Parmesan Mashed Potatoes

No description available

$8.00

Market Vegetables

Steamed Mixed Vegetables

No description available

$10.00

Creamed Parmesan Spinach

No description available

$10.00

Madison & Main's Specialties

Bone-in NY Strip Steak

No description available

$39.00

Bone-in Double Rib Eye Steak

No description available

$49.00

Double Barrel Cut Filet Mignon

No description available

$39.00

2 lb Hard Shell Eastern Shore Lobster

Steamed lemon & butter

$45.00

Kid's Menu - Main Course

Chicken Tenders

French fries

$10.00

All Natural Hamburger on Potato Bun

French fries

$10.00

All Natural Cheddar Cheese Burger on Potato Bun

French fries

$10.00

Rigatoni with Fresh Tomato Sauce & Parmesan

No description available

$10.00

Desserts

Brioche Molten Chocolate Bread Pudding

Fresh cherries jubilee

Caramelized Apple & Almond Tart

Tahitian vanilla gelato

Double Chocolate Gooey Cake

Pistachio gelato

Aunt Carol’s Graham Cracker Key Lime Pie

French meringue

Greek Yogurt Pannacotta

Honey tahitian vanilla & fresh blue berries

Seasonal Melon & Fresh Berries

Drizzled with local honey & lemon

Michael’s Cookie Monster Sundae

Fresh baked chocolate chip cookie, vanilla gelato & homemade chocolate syrup

Kids Menu - Desserts

Michael's Cookie Monster Sundae

No description available

$10.00

Kids Menu - Drinks

Milk

No description available

$10.00

Juice

No description available

$10.00

Shirley Temple

No description available

$10.00

Any Fountain Soda

No description available

$10.00

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading