Menu With Price > Menu > Just Pies > OH > Columbus > 5212-B N. High Street, Columbus, OH

Just Pies Prices in Columbus, OH 43214

4.4 based on 89 votes
Just Pies Logo
5212-B N. High Street, Columbus, OH
(614) 846-7437
Just Pies Menu

Hours of Operation

Hours may fluctuate. For detailed hours of operation, please contact the store directly.

Restaurant Menu

Fruit Pies

Apple

A perfect mix of jonathan and spy apples sweetened, with a touch of cinnamon.

$5.95 - $17.00

Apple Crumb

This favorite uses the same great jonathan and spy apples, but this time we throw a sweet streusel on top.

$5.95 - $17.00

Blackberry

Fruit pies, we start with our signature, made from scratch crust and fill it to the top with only the best blackberries

$5.95 - $17.00

Blueberry

Blueberry pie starts with our signature, made from scratch crust filled to the top with only the finest blueberries. Served with no preservatives to interrupt the flavor

$5.95 - $17.00

Bumbleberry

Apples, rhubarb, red raspberries and blackberries

$5.95 - $17.00

Cherry

Add a bit of sugar and you get a perfect balance of sweet and tart. Top it with our hand-rolled flaky crust and voila

$5.95 - $17.00

Cherry Crumb

Sour cherries as our original cherry pie, only this one is topped with our sweet streusel instead of the crust to satisfy your sweet tooth.

$5.95 - $17.00

Peach

our signature, made from scratch crust and add sweet, ripe california freestone peaches. Our old fashioned peach pies

$5.95 - $17.00

Peach Riot

California freestone peaches, red tart cherries and succulent blueberries spills over into a blast of flavor for your taste buds.

$5.95 - $17.00

Pecan

Pecan pie the sweet melt in you mouth, choice pecan pieces, and flaky crust meld together for the perfect taste combination.

$5.95 - $17.00

Pecan Chocolate Chip Cookie

A great big cookie in your pie crust. But we do drizzle chocolate over the top for good measure

$5.95 - $17.00

Pineapple

Nothing beats sweet, juicy pineapple, except that same pineapple encased in our signature pie crust.

$5.95 - $17.00

Raisin

When you combine sweet plump raisins and our signature hand-rolled flaky crust

$5.95 - $17.00

Red Raspberry

Made from scratch crust and fill it to the brim with only the finest red raspberries. Our berry pies, we do use the whole berries

$5.95 - $17.00

Rhubarb

Old fashioned crust filled with the best tart rhubarb, sugar, cornstarch, and water.

$5.95 - $17.00

Strawberry Rhubarb

Rhubarb pie, only the strawberries add a wonderful sweetness to the tart rhubarb.

$5.95 - $17.00

Tripleberry

Strawberries, blueberries and red raspberries all together under the same crust.

$5.95 - $17.00

Cream Pies

Banana Cream

Bananas, that’s right, whole, fresh bananas in our banana cream pie.

$5.95 - $17.00

Boston Cream

This dessert has it all--moist cake, our cooked vanilla pudding in the middle, and fudgy icing

$5.95 - $17.00

Buckeye

Pie with a layer of creamy peanut butter silk. Next, we added a layer of our decadent chocolate french silk. Topped with freshly whipped cream, drizzled chocolate and chopped peanuts

$5.95 - $17.00

Butterscotch

Butter and brown sugar, just the way it used to be done. This unique filling is topped off with our beautifully browned meringue.

$5.95 - $17.00

Chocolate

Pudding topped with rich whipped cream and chocolate sprinkles

$5.95 - $17.00

Coconut Cream

Or homemade meringue and for the finishing touch, sprinkle the top with more coconut and brown to perfection.

$5.95 - $17.00

Custard

Creamy custard pies but are not a fan of the fluffy topping.

$5.95 - $17.00

French Silk

Thick and fudgy, this is one of the richest pies. Freshest sugar, butter, eggs, cocoa and vanilla.

$5.95 - $17.00

Key Lime

No description available

$5.95 - $17.00

Lemon Meringue

Sweet mixed with the zing of lemon and finished off with our homemade meringue

$5.95 - $17.00

Peanut Butter

Our homemade vanilla pudding and melt. Our rich whipped topping for a creamy peanut butter sensation.

$5.95 - $17.00

No Sugar Added Pies

No Sugar Added Apple

All american favorite, with the same great apples but this time sweetened with sucralose

$5.95 - $17.00

No Sugar Added Blueberry

Our old-fashioned blueberry pie and made it diabetic-safe.

$5.95 - $17.00

No Sugar Added Cherry

Cherry pie, we use the same red tart cherries

$5.95 - $17.00

No Sugar Added Peach

Same signature crust and is filled with sweet, ripe california freestone peaches.

$5.95 - $17.00

Seasonal & Specialty Pies

Black Raspberry

This berry produces a sweet filling with all the seeds and goodness it can bring.

$5.95 - $17.00

German Chocolate Pecan

Add decadent chocolate chips and sweet coconut to our rich, luscious pie filling. Chocolate and caramel drizzle to create that irresistible bite of heaven.

$5.95 - $17.00

Mince

Combined the perfect mixture of raisins, apples, and spices

$5.95 - $17.00

Pumpkin

No description available

$5.95 - $17.00

Pumpkin Cream Cheese

Pumpkin pie, but are ready to for a new twist, add our Pumpkin Cream Cheese Pie to the menu. With pumpkin, spices, and cream cheese

$5.95 - $17.00

Pumpkin Praline

This pie is a perfect blend of two seasonal favorites: pumpkin on the bottom with a rich layer of pecan praline on top

$5.95 - $17.00

Strawberry Cream Cheese

No description available

$5.95 - $17.00

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading

Hot Menus