Menu With Price > Menu > Jake's Dilemma > NY > New York > 430 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY

Jake's Dilemma Prices in New York, NY 10024

4.6 based on 77 votes
Jake's Dilemma Logo
430 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY
(212) 580-0556
Jake's Dilemma Menu

Hours of Operation

Hours may fluctuate. For detailed hours of operation, please contact the store directly.

Restaurant Menu

Appetizers & Pizza

Appetizer Sampler Platter

4 of wings, mozz. sticks, poppers & fingers & 1 cheese quesadilla (no substitutions). choice of any 4 sauces: honey mustard, ranch, bbq, marinara, bleu cheese, salsa, sour cream

$16.99

Jake's Dilemma Quesadillas

melted cheddar jack cheese sandwiched between a soft flour tortilla, available with salsa & sour cream

$6.99

Jake's Dilemma Nachos Grande

huge plate of corn tortilla chips topped w. cheddar jack, black beans, jalapenos & pico de gallo. available w/salsa & sour cream.

$10.99

Quesadilla & Nacho Add On's

add chicken, buffalo chicken, pulled pork or chili

$2.50

Quesadilla & Nacho Add On's

add sautéed vegetables (quesadilla only)

$1.50

Quesadilla & Nacho Add On's

guacamole

$2.50

Chips And Salsa

No description available

$4.99

Chips

w/ homemade guacamole

$8.50

Warm Spinach Artichoke Dip

w/ tortilla chips

$8.50

Hand Cut Idaho French Fries Or Tater Tots

No description available

$4.99

Seasoned French Fries Or Tots

No description available

$6.99

Seasoned French Fries Or Tots

add cheese or gravy

$1.00

Seasoned French Fries Or Tots

add for both

$6.99

Homemade Crispy Onion Rings

w/ homemade dipping sauce

$6.99

Sweet Potato Tater Tots

with choice of bbq, honey mustard or maple chipotle mayo

$6.99

Smothered Fries Or Tots

smothered with chili, cheese and jalapenos. available with sour cream

$8.99

Cheddar & Bacon Fries Or Tots

available with a side of ranch

$8.99

Potato Skins

topped with bacon, cheddar cheese, chives available w/ sour cream w/chili, pulled pork, chicken

$7.99

Potato Skins

add buffalo chicken

$1.00

Hot Dog

No description available

$2.99

Hot Dog

add chili, cheese or onions

$1.00

Hot Dog

with fries/tots

$4.99

Mozzarella Sticks

served with marinara

$6.99

Deep Fried Pickles

with house sauce

$6.99

Jalapeno Poppers

filled with cream cheese. available with sour cream

$6.99

Mac N Cheese Wedges

No description available

$6.99

Homemade Mac N' Cheese

a four cheese macaroni & cheese topped with a parmesan crust

$8.99

Chili Con Carne

topped with cheddar jack cheese. served with tortilla chips available with sour cream.

$7.99

Old Fashioned Sliders

topped with old fashioned american cheese and grilled onions

$8.99

Flatbread Pizza

No description available

$7.99

Flatbread Pizza

add toppings: onions, mushrooms, jalapenos, bell peppers

$1.00

Flatbread Pizza

add pepperoni, bacon, chicken, pulled pork, avocado

$1.50

Salads

House Salad

No description available

$7.99

Caesar Salad

No description available

$7.99

Caesar Salad

add grilled chicken or crispy chicken any salad

$2.50

Fingers And Wings

Chicken Fingers

served with choice of bbq, honey mustard or ranch

$8.99

Boneless Buffalo Wings

available with bleu cheese or ranch, carrots and celery

$8.99

Buffalo Wings

No description available

$9.99

Buffalo Wings

mild, medium, hot, bbq or plain. available with bleu cheese or ranch, carrots and celery

$17.99

Slider Menu

Slider Sampler

8 sliders in total. 2 each of the following: pulled pork, "cb", california and mac n' cheese sliders

$19.99

Bacon

egg & cheese sliders

$8.99

Pulled Pork Sliders

No description available

$8.99

Old Fashioned Sliders

our classic, topped with american cheese and grilled onions

$8.99

Chicken Parm Sliders

topped with mozzarella cheese and marinara

$9.99

Buffalo Chicken Sliders

our homemade fried chicken tenders covered in our house buffalo sauce served with a side of ranch or bleu cheese

$9.99

"Cb" Sliders

sliders topped with "cheddar & bacon"

$9.99

California Sliders

sliders topped with bacon & avocado

$9.99

Meat & Potato Sliders

sliders topped with grilled onions & a potato pancake

$9.99

Mac N' Cheese Sliders

sliders topped with american cheese & fried mac n' cheese wedge

$9.99

Cheesy Sliders

sliders topped with american, cheddar, swiss & mozzarella cheese

$9.99

Sloppy Joe Sliders

No description available

$9.99

Chicken Philly Sliders

No description available

$9.99

Philly Cheese Sliders

ny strip steak topped with provolone, grilled onions & peppers

$10.99

Meatapalooza Sliders

our sliders topped with bacon & pulled pork

$10.99

Sandwiches And Stuff

NY Strip Steak Sandwich

served on a toasted garlic portuguese roll with grilled onions and mozzarella cheese

$12.99

Grilled Chicken Sandwich Plain Or Buffalo Style

No description available

$9.99

Southern Fried Chicken Sandwich

dipped in buttermilk served on a hero with chipotle mayonnaise available buffalo style

$9.99

Pulled Pork Sandwich

topped with our homemade bbq sauce

$9.99

Grilled Chicken Wrap

No description available

$9.99

Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap

No description available

$9.99

Grilled Cheese Sandwich

No description available

$6.99

Grilled Cheese Sandwich

add tomato

$0.75

Grilled Cheese Sandwich

add bacon

$1.50

Bacon

egg and cheese

$6.99

Fish & Chips

served with a side of tartar sauce

$9.99

Specialty Burgers

The "Healthy" Alternative

(defibrillator not included) a cheese burger sandwiched between 2 grilled cheese (1 with bacon, 1 with tomato)

$15.99

The Jake's Burger

piled high with mushrooms, bacon, grilled onions, jalapenos and topped with american cheese.

$12.99

Chili Cheese Burger

topped with our homemade chili & american cheese

$12.99

Pulled Pork Burger

our classic burger topped with pulled pork and covered in our homemade bbq sauce.

$12.99

Texas Burger

topped with bacon, cheddar cheese, bbq sauce & a fried egg.

$12.99

Buffalo Burger

this one is hot!!! our classic burger topped with mozzarella cheese and dipped in our homemade buffalo sauce. served with a side of bleu cheese or ranch

$11.99

Homemade Jerk Chicken Burger

our homemade patty of ground chicken with jerk seasoning. served with a bbq mango chutney sauce

$9.99

Make Your Own

hamburger, turkey or veggie burger

$9.99

Make Your Own Hamburger, Turkey Or Veggie Burger

add toppings: bacon, avocado, fried egg

$1.50

Make Your Own Hamburger, Turkey Or Veggie Burger

add toppings: mushrooms, grilled onions, jalapenos

$1.00

Make Your Own Hamburger, Turkey Or Veggie Burger

add cheese: american, cheddar, mozzarella, provolone, swiss, cheddar-jack

$1.00

Desserts

Deep Fried Oreos

No description available

$5.99

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading