Menu With Price > Menu > Brother Jimmy's > NY > New York > 116 E 16th St, New York, NY

Brother Jimmy's Prices in New York, NY 10003

4.2 based on 114 votes
Brother Jimmy's Logo
116 E 16th St, New York, NY
(929) 200-1459
Brother Jimmy's Menu

Hours of Operation

Hours may fluctuate. For detailed hours of operation, please contact the store directly.

Restaurant Menu

Beginnings

Hush Puppies

w/ maple butter

$7.25

Frickles

w/ horseradish sauce

$7.95

Peel & Eat Shrimp

w/ lemon & old bay

$12.50

Popcorn Shrimp

w/ cajun mayo

$9.75

Spinach And Artichoke Dip

No description available

$10.25

Fried Green Tomatoes

w/ spicy aioli

$8.25

Jimmy’s Burgershack ‘Minis’

choose one style: (3 per order) cheeseburgers, turkey burgers fried buffalo chicken sliders

$10.50

BBQ Minis

choose any style: (3 per order) pulled pork, pulled chicken or smoked brisket

$10.50

Rib Tips

northern style

$9.50

Bucket O’ Tips

No description available

$17.50

Hot Wings

buffalo, chipotle or crispy naked

$9.95

Bucket O’ Hot Wings

No description available

$17.50

BBQ Wings

cut wings dusted w/ our southern rub, smoked & basted w/ our "special" wing sauce

$10.50

Quesadilla

w/ salsa & sour cream pulled pork, bbq grilled chicken or smoked brisket

$10.50

Jalapeño Poppers

homemade & stuffed w/ a mixture of cream cheese & spices served w/ ranch dressing

$9.25

Brother Jimmy’s BBQ Humongous Nachos

chips, bbq beans, chili, cheese, sour cream, salsa & guacamole

$12.50

Hush Puppies

w/ maple butter

$7.25

Fried Green Tomatoes

w/ spicy aioli

$8.25

Popcorn Shrimp

w/ cajun mayo

$9.75

Peel & Eat Shrimp

w/ lemon & old bay

$12.50

Onion Straws

No description available

$7.50

Spinach And Artichoke Dip

No description available

$10.25

Quesadilla

w/ salsa & sour cream pulled pork, bbq grilled chicken or smoked brisket

$10.50

Jimmy’s Burgershack ‘Minis’

choose one style: (3 per order) cheeseburgers, turkey burgers & fried buffalo chicken sliders

$10.50

BBQ Minis

choose any style: (3 per order) pulled pork, pulled chicken or smoked brisket

$10.50

Frickles

w/ horseradish sauce

$7.95

Rib Tips

northern style

$9.50

Bucket O’ Tips

No description available

$17.50

Hot Wings

buffalo, chipotle or crispy naked

$9.95

Bucket O’ Hot Wings

No description available

$17.50

BBQ Wings

cut wings dusted w/ our southern rub, smoked & basted w/ our "special" wing sauce

$10.50

Chicken Fingers

original, buffalo or chipotle

$9.25

Jalapeño Poppers

homemade & stuffed w/ a mixture of cream cheese & spices served w/ ranch dressing

$9.25

Brother Jimmy’s BBQ Humongous Nachos

chips, bbq beans, chili, cheese, sour cream, salsa & guacamole

$12.50

Hot Wings

buffalo, chipotle, or crispy naked

$9.95

Bucket O' Hot Wings

No description available

$17.50

Quesadilla

w/ salsa & sour cream. pulled pork, bbq grilled chicken, or smoked brisket

$9.50

Brother Jimmy's BBQ Nachos

chips, bbq sauce, chili, cheese, sour cream, salsa, & guacamole

$12.50

Hush Puppies

w/ maple butter

$7.25

Fried Green Tomatoes

w/ spicy aioli

$8.25

Frickles

w/ horseradish sauce

$7.95

Spinach And Artichoke Dip

No description available

$10.25

Fried Burgershack 'Minis'

choose one style: (3 per order): cheeseburgers, turkey burgers & fried buffalo chicken sliders

$10.50

Rib Tips

No description available

$9.50

Bucket O' Tips

No description available

$17.50

Salads & Stews

House Salad

No description available

$6.95

House Salad

add chicken any style

$3.00

House Salad

add pulled pork

$4.00

Chopped Cobb Salad

lettuce, onion, tomato, buckboard bacon, crumbled blue cheese, avocado & grilled, fried or buffalo chicken

$12.95

Brother Jimmy’s BBQ Chili

topped w/ melted cheddar, served w/ sour cream & diced onion

$6.25

The Wright Salad

romaine, wild rice, yams, pecans, sweet onions, dried cherries, apples, poblano peppers & herb vinaigrette

$10.95

The Wright Salad

add grilled chicken

$3.00

Brunswick Stew

a tomato based southern stew w/ corn, smoked chicken & pork

$5.75

House Salad

No description available

$6.95

House Salad

add chicken any style

$3.00

House Salad

add pulled pork

$4.00

Chopped Cobb Salad

lettuce, onion, tomato, bacon bits, crumbled blue cheese, avocado & grilled, fried or buffalo chicken

$12.95

Jimmy’s Wedge

iceberg lettuce, bacon bits, diced tomato, smothered in blue cheese dressing & covered w/ onion straws

$9.50

The Wright Salad

romaine, wild rice, yams, pecans, sweet onions, dried cherries, apples, poblano peppers & herb vinaigrette

$10.95

The Wright Salad

add grilled chicken

$3.00

Brunswick Stew

a tomato based southern stew w/ corn, smoked chicken & pork

$5.75

Brother Jimmy’s BBQ Chili

topped w/ melted cheddar, served w/ sour cream & diced onion

$6.25

House Salad

No description available

$6.95

House Salad

add chicken any style

$3.00

House Salad

add pulled pork

$4.00

Chopped Cobb Salad

lettuce, onion, tomato, bacon, crumbled blue cheese, avocado, & grilled, fried, or buffalo chicken

$12.95

The Wright Salad

romaine, wild rice, yams, pecans, sweet onions, diced cherries, apples, pablano peppers, & herb vinaigrette.

$10.95

The Wright Salad

add grilled chicken

$3.00

Brunswick Stew

a tomato based southern stew w/ corn, smoked chicken, & pork

$5.75

Sandwiches N’ Burgers

Pulled Pork Wrap

pulled pork, pickles & slaw

$9.25

Pulled Chicken Wrap

pulled chicken, bacon & cheddar

$8.75

Smoked Turkey Wrap

avocado, house smoked turkey, shredded lettuce & honey mustard

$9.25

Burgers

No description available

$9.75

Burgers

add chili, bacon or cheese

$1.00

BJ’s BBQ Burger

grilled w/ chipotle bbq sauce, cheddar & topped w/ onion straws

$10.75

BBQ Grilled Chicken

basted with bbq sauce on a roll w/ lettuce, tomato & onion

$9.95

Po’ Boys

blackened or fried catfish, blackened chicken or fried shrimp on french bread w/ lettuce, tomato & cajun mayo

$10.75

Fried Chicken

buffalo style or original on a roll

$10.25

Press‘d Bourbon BBQ Brisket

with bourbon bbq sauce, gouda & onion straws pressed on texas toast

$10.75

Brother Jimmy’s Cuban

sliced smoked pork, country ham, gruyere cheese & frickles

$9.25

B.L.F.G.T.

applewood bacon, lettuce & fried green tomatoes on country white bread served w/ french fries

$9.75

Po’ Boys

blackened or fried catfish, blackened chicken or fried shrimp on french bread w/ lettuce, tomato & cajun mayo

$10.75

BBQ Grilled Chicken

basted with bbq sauce on a roll w/ lettuce, tomato & onion

$9.95

Fried Chicken

buffalo style or original on a roll

$10.25

Burgers

No description available

$9.75

Burgers

add chili, bacon or cheese

$1.00

BJ’s BBQ Burger

grilled w/ chipotle bbq sauce, cheddar & topped w/ onion straws

$10.75

Press’d Bourbon BBQ Brisket

w/ bourbon bbq sauce, gouda & onion straws pressed on texas toast

$10.75

Entrees

Steak N’ Fries

grilled skirt steak w/ homemade steak sauce & hand cut fries (no sides included)

$20.50

Blackened Catfish

a southern seafood staple with a kick to it

$17.95

Fried Chicken Dinner

tossed in our seasonal flour then finished off w/ toasted garlic

$17.25

Nag’s Head Veggie

beer battered yams, grilled zucchini & squash, onion rings & wild rice salad (no sides included)

$14.50

BBQ Lunch Special

choice of brunswick stew or house sal ad & choose from any style ribs, pulled pork, brisket, 1/4 bbq chick en or pulled chicken. served w/ choice of t wo sides

$14.95

Sides

Potato Salad

No description available

$4.25

Cole Slaw

No description available

$4.25

French Fries

No description available

$4.25

Sweet Potato Fries

No description available

$4.75

Spiced String Beans

No description available

$4.75

Black Eyed Peas

w/ bacon

$4.75

Corn On The Cob

2 ears

$4.75

Mashed Potatoes

w/ gravy

$4.75

Fried Okra

No description available

$4.75

Macaroni & Cheese

No description available

$5.50

BBQ Baked Beans

w/ pulled pork

$5.50

Candied Yams

w/ walnuts

$5.50

Collard Greens

No description available

$5.50

Fried Brussel Sprouts

No description available

$5.50

Wild Rice Salad

No description available

$5.50

Potato Salad

No description available

$4.25

Cole Slaw

No description available

$4.25

French Fries

No description available

$4.25

Sweet Potato Fries

No description available

$4.75

Spiced String Beans

No description available

$4.75

Black Eyed Peas

w/ bacon

$4.75

Corn On The Cob

2 ears

$4.75

Mashed Potatoes

w/ gravy

$4.75

Fried Okra

No description available

$4.75

Macaroni & Cheese

No description available

$5.50

BBQ Baked Beans

w/ pulled pork

$5.50

Candied Yams

w/ walnuts

$5.50

Collard Greens

No description available

$5.50

Fried Brussel Sprouts

No description available

$5.50

Wild Rice Salad

No description available

$5.50

French Fries

No description available

$4.25

Sweet Potato Fries

No description available

$4.75

Spiced String Beans

No description available

$4.75

Black Eyed Peas

w/ bacon

$4.75

Corn On The Cob

2 ears

$4.75

Mashed Potato

w/ gravy

$4.75

Macaroni & Cheese

No description available

$5.50

BBQ Baked Beans

w/ pulled pork

$5.50

Candied Yams

w/ walnuts

$5.50

Collard Greens

No description available

$5.50

Fried Brussel Sprouts

No description available

$5.50

Wild Rice Salad

No description available

$5.50

Potato Salad

No description available

$4.25

Cole Slaw

No description available

$4.25

Platters

Northern Style Ribs

smoked & then grilled w/ brother jimmy’s original bbq sauce

Southern Style Ribs

smoked w/ brother jimmy’s memphis-style rub

Brother Jimmy’s Dry Rub Ribs

smoked w/ brother jimmy’s signature rub- tastes like a country sausage

Combo Rib Platter

choose from our 3 styles of ribs, ‘lil’ more than a half rack

$23.50

Carolina Pulled Pork

pork shoulder slow smoked & pulled w/ brother jimmy’s carolina bbq

$16.95

Pulled Chicken

smoked & pulled w/ brother jimmy’s original bbq sauce

$16.75

Sliced Brisket

smoked for up to 12 hours lean or marbled

$17.95

1/2 BBQ Chicken

smoked, grilled & basted in brother jimmy’s original bbq sauce

$17.25

BBQ Meatloaf

beef & pork wrapped in bacon & smoked

$15.95

Northern Style Ribs

smoked & then grilled w/ brother jimmy’s original bbq sauce

Southern Style Ribs

smoked w/ brother jimmy’s memphis-style rub

Brother Jimmy’s Dry Rub Ribs

smoked w/ brother jimmy’s signature rub-tastes like a country sausage

Combo Rib Platter

choose from our 3 styles of ribs, ‘lil’ more than a half rack

$23.50

Carolina Pulled Pork

pork shoulder slow smoked & pulled w/ brother jimmy’s carolina bbq

$16.95

Pulled Chicken

smoked & pulled w/ brother jimmy’s original bbq sauce

$16.75

Sliced Brisket

smoked for up to 12 hours lean or marbled

$17.95

1/2 BBQ Chicken

smoked, grilled & basted in brother jimmy’s original bbq sauce

$17.25

BBQ Chicken & Ribs

No description available

$19.50

BBQ Meatloaf

beef & pork wrapped in bacon & smoked

$15.95

Sandwiches

Carolina Pulled Pork

No description available

$10.50

Pulled Chicken

No description available

$10.50

Sliced Brisket

lean or marbled

$10.75

BBQ Meatloaf

on grilled texas toast w/ tomato

$10.25

Carolina Pulled Pork

No description available

$10.50

Pulled Chicken

No description available

$10.50

Sliced Brisket

lean or marbled

$10.75

BBQ Meatloaf

on grilled texas toast w/ tomato

$10.25

Jimmy’s Pig Pick

choose any 4 items from the following selections: northern, southern or dry rub ribs, pulled pork, brisket, bbq chicken or pulled chicken served with hush puppies and cole slaw.

$25.95

Southern Specialties

Country Fried Steak W/ Gravy

top round steak, tenderized & dredged in our seasoned flour, fried ‘til crisp & tender and topped w/ gravy

$17.95

Fried Chicken Dinner

tossed in our seasoned flour then finished off w/ toasted garlic

$17.25

Steak N’ Fries

grilled skirt steak w/ homemade steak sauce & hand cut fries (no sides included)

$20.50

Blackened Chicken

dipped in our special blackening spice- nice n’ spicy

$16.95

Blackened Catfish

a southern seafood staple with a kick to it

$17.95

Nag’s Head Veggie

beer battered yams, grilled zucchini & squash, onion rings & wild rice salad (no sides included)

$13.50

Fried Chicken Dinner

mashed potatoes & corn on the cob

$17.25

Brunch

Grilled Cheese

cheddar cheese & apple wood bacon served w/ french fries

$8.95

Beat The Farm

a pat lafrieda bacon cheeseburger cooked to your liking - topped w/ a fried egg served over cheese fries.

$9.95

BJ's Egg Sandwich

2 fried eggs, ham, bbq onions & cheddar cheese on a jumbo english muffin served w/ home fries

$8.95

Omelets

choose 2 fillings: bacon, ham, sausage, cheddar, gruyere, red peppers, mushrooms, tomato & onion.

$9.25

Omelets

served w/ home fries - each additional filling

$1.00

B.L.F.G.T

applewood bacon, lettuce & fried green tomatoes on country white bread served w/ french fries

$9.75

Chicken N' Waffles

cornmeal waffle w/ fried chicken breast & pure maple syrup

$10.50

Specials

Brunch Special

choice of eye opener, coffee, or tea with any brunch entree

$19.95

BBQ Platters

1/2 BBQ Chicken

smoked, grilled, & basted in brother jimmy's bbq sauce

$17.25

BBQ Chicken & Ribs

No description available

$19.50

Northern Style Ribs

smoked & then grilled w/ brother jimmy' s original bbq sauce

$22.50

Southern Style Ribs

smoked w/ brother jimmy's memphis-style rub

$22.50

Brother Jimmy's Dry Rub Ribs

smoked w/ brother jimmy's signature rub tastes like a country sausage

$22.50

Carolina Pulled Pork

pork shoulder slow smoked & pulled w/ brother jimmy's carolina bbq sauce

$16.95

Pulled Chicken

smoked & pulled w/ brother jimmy's original bbq sauce

$16.75

Sliced Brisket

smoked for up to 12 hours. lean or marbled

$17.95

BBQ Sandwiches

Carolina Pulled Pork

No description available

$10.50

Pulled Chicken

No description available

$10.50

Sliced Brisket

lean or marbled

$10.75

BBQ Meatloaf

on grilled texas toast w/ tomato

$10.25

Sandwiches, Burgers, N' More

Po' Boys

blackened or fried catfish, blackened chicken, or fried shrimp on french bread with lettuce, tomato, & cajun mayo

$10.75

BBQ Grilled Chicken

basted w/ bbq sauce on a roll w/ lettuce, tomato, & onion

$9.95

Nag's Head Veggie

beer battered yams, grilled zucchini & squash, onion rings & wild rice salad (no sides included)

$13.50

Fried Chicken

buffalo style or original on a roll

$10.25

Burgers

No description available

$9.75

Burgers

add chili, applewood bacon, or cheese

$1.00

BJ's BBQ Burger

grilled w/ chipotle bbq sauce, cheddar, & topped with onion straws

$10.75

Blackened Catfish

collard greens & mac n’ cheese

$17.95

Press'd Bourbon BBQ Brisket

w/ bourbon bbq sauce, gouda, & onion straws pressed on texas toast

$10.75

Brunch Sides

Toast Or English Muffin

No description available

$2.00

Ham

bacon, or country sausage

$4.95

Home Fries

No description available

$3.25

Cornmeal Waffle

No description available

$5.00

Eye Openers

Bloody Mary

garnished w/ pickled string beans olives, celery & rimmed w/ our special rimming spice

$9.00

Bloody Sunday

our spicey bloody mary kicked up a notch with southern comfort fiery pepper and an applewood bacon stirrer

$9.00

Bloody Beer

budweiser, tomato juice, tabasco, worcestershire & fresh lime

$6.00

White Peach Sangria

No description available

$9.00

Mimosa

No description available

$7.00

Bellini

No description available

$7.00

Concoctions

Palmetto Punch

a carolina rum runner containing oakheart spiced rum and bacardi coco

$31.00 - $9.00

Ultimat Carolina Cooler

a new take on a brother jimmy’s classic cocktail made with ultimat vodka, fresh lemonade, blue curacao and muddled lemons

$31.00 - $9.00

Louisville Lemonade

a whiskey infused glass of lemonade made with jim beam devil’s cut, triple sec and sprite

$31.00 - $9.00

The Charleston A.P.

south carolina sweet tea infused vodka, fresh lemonade and a splash of soda

$31.00 - $9.00

Myrtle Beach Margarita

a jumbo margarita either frozen or on the rocks add a flavor: strawberry, raspberry, peach or mango

$31.00 - $9.00

Jimmy’s Dark & Stormy

bacardi 8 dark rum, ginger beer & fresh lime

$31.00 - $9.00

Charlotte Tea

a southern version of a long island iced tea made with five kinds of booze and a hint of the tropics

$10.00 - $34.00

The Grand Strand Margarita

a top shelf margarita made with milargo silver tequila, grand marnier and lime

$14.00 - $44.00

The Battle Of Antietam Bloody Mary

a classic spicy bloody with a festive array of garnishes and a taste of the old bay

$9.00

Party Drinks

Swamp Water

our legendary cocktail served in a 64 oz fish bowl hasn’t changed in 20 years!!!

$22.00

Trashcan Punch

2.5 gallons of high octane punch served in a mason jar a perfect drink for a party!

$90.00

Bottled Beer

Abita

amber

$7.00

Abita

turbo dog

$7.00

Flying Dog

snake dog ipa

$7.00

Magic Hat #9

No description available

$7.00

Saranac

black and tan

$7.00

Sierra Nevada

pale ale

$7.00

Natural Light

No description available

$4.50

PBR

No description available

$4.50

Amstel Light

No description available

$6.50

Blue Moon

No description available

$6.50

Corona

No description available

$6.50

Corona Light

No description available

$6.50

Angry Orchard Cider

No description available

$6.50

Heineken

No description available

$6.50

Bud

No description available

$5.50

Bud Light

No description available

$5.50

Coors Light

No description available

$5.50

Miller High Life

No description available

$5.50

O’Douls

No description available

$5.50

Draft Beer

Brooklyn Penant Ale

No description available

$22.00 - $6.50

Heineken

No description available

$22.00 - $6.50

Sam Adams

No description available

$22.00 - $6.50

Sam Seasonal

No description available

$22.00 - $6.50

Shock Top

belgium white

$22.00 - $6.50

Stella

No description available

$22.00 - $6.50

Yuengling

No description available

$22.00 - $6.50

Bud

No description available

$18.00 - $5.50

Bud Light

No description available

$18.00 - $5.50

Top Shelf

Johnny Walker Blue

No description available

$45.00

Patron Platinum

No description available

$40.00

Jose Cuervo Reserve De La Familia

No description available

$20.00

Glenfiddich 15

No description available

$14.00

Soda Pop

Monster

No description available

$3.00 - $7.00

Boylans Soda

ginger ale, orange, root beer, diet root beer, black cherry

$3.50

Ginger Beer

No description available

$3.50

Coke

No description available

$3.25

Diet Coke

No description available

$3.25

Sprite

No description available

$3.25

Fiji Water

No description available

$3.00

Cheerwine Cherry Soda

a carolina favorite since 1917

$3.00

Cheerwine Icecream Float

No description available

$5.00

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading