Menu With Price > Menu > Brother Jimmy's > NY > New York > 428 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY

Brother Jimmy's Prices in New York, NY 10024

4.2 based on 114 votes

428 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY

(917) 962-8307

Brother Jimmy's Menu

Hours of Operation

Hours may fluctuate. For detailed hours of operation, please contact the store directly.

Restaurant Menu

Beverages

Soda

No description available

$3.25

Cheerwine Soda

A Carolina favorite since 1917.

$3.25

Homemade Iced Tea

Sold by the quart because one cup is never enough.

$5.25

Raspberry Lemonade

Sold by the quart because one cup is never enough.

$5.25

Boylan Soda

No description available

$3.50

Ginger Beer

Non alcoholic.

$3.50

Lemonade

Sold by the quart because one cup is never enough.

$5.25

Beginnings

Hush Puppies

Served with maple butter.

$7.75

Popcorn Shrimp

Served with Cajun mayonnaise.

$10.50

Chicken Fingers

No description available

$10.50

Bucket o' Hot Wings

No description available

$21.00

Warm Homemade Potato Chips

With Buffalo blue cheese dip.

$7.75

Frickles

Served with horseradish sauce.

$9.50

Brother Jimmy's BBQ Humongous Nachos

Chips, BBQ beans, cheese, sour cream, salsa and guacamole.

$17.25

Quesadilla

Served with salsa and sour cream.

$11.00

Hot Wings

No description available

$11.50

Spinach and Artichoke Dip

No description available

$10.75

BBQ Snacks

BBQ Wings

Cut wings, dusted with our Southern rub and basted with our ``special`` wing sauce.

$12.25

Rib Tips

Northern-style.

$10.00

Bucket O' Tips

No description available

$18.50

Pulled Pork Minis

No description available

Pulled Chicken Minis

No description available

$12.50

Salads

House Salad

No description available

$7.50

Chopped Cobb Salad

Romaine lettuce, onions, tomatoes, bacon, crumbled blue cheese and avocado.

$14.75

Jimmy's Wedge Salad

Iceberg lettuce, bacon bits and diced tomato smothered in blue cheese dressing and covered with onion rings.

$11.00

BBQ Sandwiches

Carolina Pulled Pork Sandwich

Served on a white bun, with your choice of a side and pickles.

$12.50

Sliced Marble Brisket Sandwich

Served on a white bun, with your choice of a side and pickles. Subject to change due to market pricing.

$14.00

Pulled Chicken Sandwich

Served on a white bun, with your choice of a side and pickles.

$12.50

BBQ Platters

Northern-Style Ribs Platter

Half rack of St. Louis-style ribs. Smoked and then grilled with Brother Jimmy's original BBQ sauce. Served with your choice of up to two sides, cornbread and pickles.

$23.75

Combo Rib Platter

Choose from our two styles of ribs, lil more than a half rack. Served with your choice of up to two sides, cornbread and pickles.

$24.75

Pulled Chicken Platter

Smoked and pulled with brother jimmy's original BBQ sauce. Served with your choice of up to two sides, cornbread and pickles.

$16.75

Southern-style Ribs Platter

A half rack of St. Louis-style ribs. Smoked with Brother Jimmy's Memphis-style rub. Served with your choice of up to two sides, cornbread and pickles.

$23.75

Carolina Pulled Pork Platter

Pork shoulder slow-smoked and pulled with Brother Jimmy's Carolina BBQ sauce. Served with your choice of up to two sides, cornbread and pickles.

$18.50

Baby Back Ribs Platter

Smoked and finished on the grill with a sweet & tangy sauce.

$24.75

Sliced Brisket Platter

Smoked for up to 12 hours. Subject to change due to market pricing.

$21.00

1/2 BBQ Chicken Platter

Smoked, grilled and basted in Brother Jimmy's Original BBQ Sauce.

$17.25

Southern Fried Specialties

Blackened Catfish Dinner

A southern seafood staple, with a spicy kick to it.

$20.00

Fried Chicken Dinner

Tossed in our seasoned flour, then finished off with toasted garlic.

$18.25

Jimmy's Pig Pick for Two

Northern or Southern-style ribs, pulled pork, brisket and pulled chicken served with your choice of 4 sides.

$45.00

Blackened Chicken

Dipped in our special blackening spice. Nice & spicy.

Sandwiches N Burgers

Blackened Catfish Sandwich

With roasted tomato tartar sauce served with avocado & tomato.

$13.50

BBQ Grilled Chicken Sandwich

Basted with BBQ sauce, served with shredded lettuce, tomatoes and onions.

$11.50

Fried Chicken Sandwich

No description available

$11.75

BJ's Burger

Our half pound custom burger blend grilled to perfection.

$13.00

BJ's Signature BBQ Burger

Our half pound custom blend basted with chipotle BBQ sauce, Cheddar & topped with onion rings.

$14.00

Turkey Burger

Our custom turkey blend, with grilled onions and chipotle BBQ mayonnaise.

$13.00

Portobello Burger

Grilled Portobellos with Swiss cheese and topped with onion rings and Chipotle BBQ mayo.

$12.00

Press'd Bourbon Brisket Sandwich

Smoked Brisket with Cheddar, onion rings and our homemade Bourbon BBQ Sauce. Subject to change due to market pricing.

$13.50

Family Meals

Ribs Family Meal

2 racks of ribs.

$70.25

Chicken & Ribs Family Meal

1 rack of ribs and 1 whole chicken.

$60.25

Chicken & Pork Family Meal

1 whole chicken and 1 lb. of pulled pork.

$55.25

Sides

Coleslaw

No description available

$4.50

Basket of Cornbread

No description available

$4.50

Sweet Potato Tots

No description available

$4.50

Spiced String Beans

No description available

$5.00

Fried Brussels Sprouts

No description available

$5.75

Macaroni and Cheese

No description available

$5.75

French Fries

No description available

$4.50

Tater Tots

No description available

$4.50

Mashed Potatoes with Gravy

No description available

$5.00

BBQ Baked Beans and Pork

No description available

$5.00

Collard Greens

No description available

$5.75

Any 4 Sides

No description available

$12.00

Potato Salad

No description available

$4.50

Fried Okra

No description available

$5.75

Desserts

Apple Crumb Pie

No description available

$7.50

Fudge Brownie

No description available

$3.00

Pecan Pie

No description available

$7.00

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.