Menu With Price > Menu > Black & Blue Steak & Crab > NY > Amherst > 5493 Sheridan Dr, Amherst, NY

Black & Blue Steak & Crab Prices in Amherst, NY 14221

4.0 based on 74 votes
Black & Blue Steak & Crab Logo
5493 Sheridan Dr, Amherst, NY
(716) 839-2525
Black & Blue Steak & Crab Menu

Hours of Operation

Hours may fluctuate. For detailed hours of operation, please contact the store directly.

Restaurant Menu

Appetizers

Oysters on the Half Shell

Each ask your server for today’s selection

$2.75

Large Oyster Sampler (8 Pieces)

No description available

$19.95

Small Oyster Sampler (4 Pieces)

No description available

$10.95

Seafood Platter

Serves $4.00 assorted fresh, chilled seafood

$79.95

Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail

Poached and chilled with a spicy citrus cocktail sauce

$13.50

B&B Shrimp

Crispy fried rock shrimp tossed with a sweet & spicy thai chili glaze

$9.95

Blue Crab Cocktail

Lump crab meat served chilled with a house dipping sauce

$12.50

Tuna Tartare

Seasoned, diced yellowfin tuna with cucumber slaw & crispy rock shrimp

$13.95

Potato Croquettes

Chorizo, piquillo peppers and pepper jack cheese with a tamarind BBQ sauce

$7.95

Crab Cake

Colossal and jumbo lump blue crab cake, pan seared with an avocado lime aioli

$16.95

Kobe Meatballs

Slow roasted kobe beef with caramelized onions and a roasted garlic cream sauce

$10.95

Fried Calamari

With watercress, cilantro, cashews, sweet & spicy ponzu and sesame tempura crisps

$9.95

Crab & Lobster Fondue

Sweet crab & maine lobster, parmigiano reggiano cheese and toasted pita chips

$12.95

Steak Tartare

Diced tenderloin with onion, garlic, capers, horseradish aioli, truffle oil and panko crusted soft boiled egg

$13.95

Soups and Salads

Maryland She-Crab Soup

No description available

$8.95

Lobster Bisque

No description available

$9.95

Caesar Salad

Hearts of romaine, garlic croutons and fresh shaved parmesan in a classic dressing

$8.50

Mixed Greens

Mesclun greens and cornbread croutons tossed in a white balsamic vinaigrette

$7.50

Beefsteak Tomato Salad

Quartered and tossed in a sweet basil vinaigrette with fresh mozzarella and red onion

$8.50

Chop Salad

Romaine, cucumbers, tomatoes, red onion, blue cheese, bacon and toasted chick peas in a sweet & sour vinaigrette

$8.50

Black & Blue Salad

Seasoned beef tenderloin tips over baby spinach with grilled onions, oven dried tomatoes and crispy bacon croutons in a bacon blue cheese viniagrette

$14.95

Fish

Black Grouper

Line caught black grouper with roasted artichokes, cipollini onions, kalamata olives, blistered tomatoes, scallion pesto and black garlic vinaigrette

$29.95

Red Snapper

Line caught red snapper, quinoa pilaf with currants, baby arugula and golden beets over a butternut squash puree, finished with crispy pickled shallots

$32.95

Ahi Tuna

Filet mignon of hawaiian yellow fin tuna seared over a gingered potato salad, soy glazed carrots and sugar snap peas

$31.95

Atlantic Salmon

Crispy pan seared over a cauliflower and potato puree with fennel & spinach confit

$28.95

Shellfish

Seared Sea Scallops

Jumbo scallops with a pomegranate glaze over grilled vegetable risotto

$32.95

Lump Maryland Blue Crab

De shelled, lump crab steamed and served with an herb infused butter and mustard aioli with your choice of side

$29.95

Alaskan King Crab Legs

Served pre cracked with your choice of side

$41.95 - $61.95

Live Maine Lobster

Comparable to a 1½ lb lobster de shelled, steamed & served with drawn butter comes with your choice of side

$39.95

Whole Live Maine Lobster

2¼ lb steamed lobster, pre cracked and served with drawn butter & lemon comes with your choice of side

$49.95

North Atlantic Lobster Tail

Broiled jumbo 18oz cold water tail served with drawn butter and your choice of side

$59.95

House Specialties

Short Ribs

Slow braised beef shortrib, onion rings and blue cheese mashed potatoes

$29.95

Roasted Chicken

Oven roasted herb encrusted half chicken with a seared potato cake, green beans & red onion

$19.95

Roasted Piquillo Peppers

Stuffed with saffron rice and a three grain saute with a balsamic glaze

$18.95

Steaks and Chops

Center Cut Sirloin (9 oz)

No description available

$26.95

N.Y. Strip (12 oz)

No description available

$32.95

N.Y. Strip (16 oz)

No description available

$39.95

Filet Mignon (8 oz)

No description available

$33.95

Filet Mignon (12 oz)

No description available

$47.95

Kansas City Strip (14 oz)

No description available

$36.95

Ribeye (14 oz)

No description available

$39.95

Porterhouse (20 oz)

No description available

$46.95

Bone-In Cowboy Ribeye (21 oz)

No description available

$48.95

Lamb Chops (12 oz)

No description available

$34.95

Addons

Jumbo Shrimp

No description available

$6.50

Lump Blue Crab (4 oz)

No description available

$10.50

Maine Lobster Tail (3 oz)

No description available

$13.95

Alaskan King Crab Legs (8 oz)

No description available

$17.95

Jumbo Lobster Tail (18 oz)

No description available

$52.95

Steakhouse Specialties

Steak Au Poivre

12 oz NY strip steak with a brandy & black peppercorn sauce, hash brown rosti cake and green beans

$36.95

Steak Arabica

Coffee & cocoa rubbed 9 oz center cut sirloin, sweet potato dumpling and sauteed spinach

$28.95

Steak Garlic

12 oz NY strip with sweet whole roasted garlic, minced garlic butter, button mushrooms and a crispy chorizo & pepper jack potato cake

$36.95

Surf & Turf

9 oz center cut sirloin & pan-seared sea scallops with a lemon butter sauce, asparagus and vegetable risotto

$34.95

Sides

Garlic Mashed Potatoes

No description available

$6.50

Shoe String Fries

No description available

$6.50

White Cheddar Fries

No description available

$6.50

Sweet Potato Dumplings

No description available

$6.50

Vidalia Onion Rings

No description available

$6.50

Roasted Button Mushrooms

No description available

$6.50

Grilled Asparagus

No description available

$6.50

Creamy Spinach

No description available

$6.50

Green Beans

No description available

$6.50

Orzo Mac & Cheese

No description available

$6.50

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading