Menu With Price > Menu > Athenian Diner > CT > New Haven > 1426 Whalley Ave, New Haven, CT

Athenian Diner Prices in New Haven, CT 06515

4.2 based on 128 votes
Athenian Diner Logo
1426 Whalley Ave, New Haven, CT
(203) 397-1556
Athenian Diner Menu

Hours of Operation

Hours may fluctuate. For detailed hours of operation, please contact the store directly.

Restaurant Menu

Appetizers & Finger Foods.

Buffalo Wings (8)

hot and spicy with a blue cheese dip.

$8.29

Jalapeno Poppers (6)

with cream cheese or cheddar cheese.

$8.29

Potato Skins (5)

"our way" stuffed with bacon and cheddar cheese.

$8.29

Fried Zucchini Sticks

with cucumber garlic dip.

$6.29

Stuffed Mushrooms (3)

with crabmeat stuffing.

$8.29

Tri Sampler

combination of chicken fingers, fried mozzarella and zucchini sticks with their accompanying dips.

$9.99

Greek Sampler

for two gyro, pork, sourtaki chicken sourtaki, pita, grape leaves, olives, tzatziki, and spinach pie.

$14.99

Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail (4)

with cocktail sauce.

$10.99

Fried Mozzarella Sticks (6)

with a marinara dip.

$8.29

Chicken Fingers

served with a tangy barbecue and sweet & sour sauce.

$8.29

Grape Leaves

(appetizer size stuffed with rice and spices).

$6.29

Fried Clam Strips

with tartar sauce.

$8.29

Baked Stuffed Clams (3)

stuffed with crabmeat stuffing.

$8.29

Sweet Potato Fries

No description available

$4.99

Curly Spicy Fires

No description available

$4.99

French Fries

with melted cheese & gravy.

$3.29 - $4.99

Fried Calamari

with marinara dip.

$8.29

Soups.

Soup Of The Day

No description available

$2.49 - $3.49

French Onion Soup

au gratin in a crock

$4.29

Hot Open Sandwiches.

Sliced Turkey

with gravy and cranberry sauce.

$13.99

Roast Sirloin Of Beef

No description available

$13.99

Baked Virginia Style Ham

served with salad, potato and vegetable.

$13.99

Tasty Sandwiches.

Fried Egg

with bacon, ham or sausage.

$1.99 - $2.99

Canadian Style Bacon And Egg

No description available

$3.79

Fried Egg And Cheese

No description available

$2.79

Western Sandwich

No description available

$3.99

Tasty Sandwiches - Meat.

Corned Beef Or Roast Beef

No description available

$6.79

Roast Virginia Style Ham

No description available

$6.79

Roast Turkey

No description available

$6.79

Pastrami

No description available

$6.79

Bacon, Lettuce And Tomato

No description available

$4.49

Canadian Style Bacon

with lettuce and tomato

$5.29

Boiled Ham And Lettuce

No description available

$4.49

Chicken Salad Sandwich

No description available

$5.29

Egg Salad Sandwich

No description available

$4.29

Beef Liver

with onions or bacon

$5.29

Chicken Or Veal Parmigiana

No description available

$6.99

Eggplant Parmigiana

No description available

$6.49

Meatloaf

No description available

$4.79

Hot Dog

No description available

$3.29

Tasty Sandwiches - Fish.

Tunafish Salad

No description available

$5.79

Seafood Salad

No description available

$6.29

Individual Salmon

with lettuce, tomato and onion.

$7.29

Individual Tuna

with lettuce, tomato and onion.

$7.29

Imported Sardines

with lettuce, tomato and onion.

$6.29

Fried File Of Sole

on a bun.

$7.29

Peanut Butter And Jelly

No description available

$1.99

Tasty Sandwiches - Cheese.

Grilled Cheese

No description available

$2.99

Grilled Cheese

with tomato.

$3.29

Grilled Cheese

with bacon or ham.

$3.99

Grilled Cheese

with canadian style bacon.

$4.49

Grilled Swiss Cheese

with tomato.

$3.59

Grilled Swiss Cheese

with bacon or ham.

$4.29

Grilled Swiss Cheese

with canadian style bacon.

$4.79

Fancy Fresh Seafood - Broiled.

Broiled Fresh Deep Sea Scallops

with butter sauce.

$19.99

Broiled French Filet Of Sole

with butter sauce.

$18.99

Broiled Salmon Filet

in butter sauce.

$18.99

Broiled Fresh Boston Scrod

in butter sauce.

$16.99

Broiled Fresh Swordfish

in butter sauce.

$17.99

Broiled Rainbow Trout

in butter sauce.

$16.99

Broiled Fish Almondine

(codfish)

$17.99

Broiled Jumbo Shrimp

stuffed with crabmeat.

$19.99

Baked Homemade Stuffed Clams (4)

No description available

$15.99

Our "S Star" Specials.

London Broil

london broil on hard roll with gravy.

$7.69

Reuben Sandwich

corned beef or pastrami and tangy sauerkraut with melted swiss cheese on grilled rye bread.

$7.69

Open Steak Sandwich

on toast served with french fries, lettuce, tomato and onion rings.

$15.99

Monte Cristo

french toast with white meat turkey and ham topped with swiss cheese and grilled to perfection.

$7.69

Tuna Or Pattie Melt

tuna or hamburger with melted cheese and tomato on grilled rye.

$7.29

Grilled Chicken

on hard roll with lettuce and tomato.

$7.69

Chicken Cutlet

on hard roll with gravy or tomato sauce.

$7.69

Pastrami Melt

pastrami with melted swiss cheese, onion and tomato on grilled rye bread.

$7.69

Cheese Steak Sandwich

on toast served with lettuce and tomato or fried onions.

$7.69

Fancy Fresh Seafood - Fried.

Fish And Chips

with tartar sauce.

$16.99

Fried Fresh Jumbo Shrimp

with tartar sauce.

$18.99

Fried Fresh Scallops

with tartar sauce.

$18.99

Fried Fresh Filit Of Sole

with tartar sauce.

$17.99

Fried Clam Strips

No description available

$15.99

Fried Calamari

No description available

$15.99

Fried Combination Seafood Platter

shrimp, scallops. filet of sole and clam strips.

$19.99

Italian Specialties,

Veal Cutlet Parmigiana

topped with melted mozzarella, served with spaghetti.

$16.99

Breaded Breast Of Chicken Parmigiana

topped with mozzarella cheese and served with spaghetti.

$15.99

Homestyle Lasagna

No description available

$12.99

Eggplant Parmigiana

served with spaghetti.

$13.99

Cheese Ravioli Parmigiana

No description available

$13.99

Spaghetti Or Ziti

with tomato sauce.

$10.99

Spaghetti Or Ziti

with meatballs or sausage

$12.99

Linguine with clam sauce

white or red.

$15.99

Entrees And Roasts.

Roast Top Sirloin Of Beef

au jus.

$14.99

Roast Turkey

with dressing.

$14.99

Roast Prime Rib Of Beef

(16 oz).

$18.99

Beef Liver

with bacon or onions.

$13.99

Baked Meatloaf

with mushroom gravy.

$11.99

BBQ Spare Ribs And Chicken

No description available

$14.99

Pot Roast

with gravy.

$14.99

Broiled Half Spring Chicken

No description available

$14.99

Pot Roast

with gravy.

$14.99

Broiled Half Spring Chicken

No description available

$13.99

Chicken Croquettes

with gravy.

$11.99

Fried Chicken

No description available

$12.99

Steaks And Chops.

T-Bone Steak (16 Oz.).

No description available

$18.99

Broiled Juicy Large New York Strip Steak (16 Oz.).

with onion rings.

$18.99

Broiled Spring Lamb Chops

with mint jelly.

$15.99

Broiled Jersey Pork Chops

with applesauce.

$15.99

Broiled London Broil

with mushroom gravy.

$15.99

Broiled Chopped Steak

with fried onions.

$13.99

Grilled Ham Steak

with pineapple.

$15.99

Broiled Rib Club Steak (12 Oz)

with onion rings.

$16.99

Jewish Style Franks.

Jewish Style Franks

with baked beans and salad.

$7.99

Homestyle Cheese Blintzes

with sour cream and applesauce.

$8.59

Lox And Bagel

with cream cheese, tomato, onion and olive.

$9.29

Fresh Country Eggs.

Two Eggs

any style.

$4.29

One Egg

any style.

$3.49

The Above Egg orders

with bacon, ham or sausage.

$2.29

The Above Egg Orders

with canadian style bacon.

$3.59

The Above Egg Orders

with corned beef hash.

$3.79

The Above Egg Orders.

with pastrami.

$3.79

The Above Egg Orders

with gyro meat.

$3.99

Fresh Country Eggs - Egg Whites.

Rite Steak (12 Oz) & Two Large Eggs

served with home fries and toast.

$15.99

Ham Steak & Two Large Eggs

served with home fries and toast.

$15.99

Omelettes.

Plain Omelette

No description available

$4.99

American Cheese Omelette

No description available

$6.29

Cottage Cheese Omelette

No description available

$6.49

Swiss Cheese Omelette

No description available

$6.49

Western Or Mushroom Omelette

No description available

$6.79

Feta Cheese Omelette

No description available

$7.79

Ham Or Bacon Omelette

No description available

$6.79

Gyro Omelette

No description available

$6.79

Broccoli Or Spinach Omelette

No description available

$6.79

Onion Omelette

No description available

$5.29

Vegetarian Omelette

tomato, peppers and onions.

$6.29

Athenian Omelette

ham, bacon, sausage and cheese.

$8.29

Greek Omelette

with feta cheese and tomato.

$7.79

Smoked Salmon (Lox) And Onion

No description available

$9.99

Chef's Omelette

sauteed escarole, mushrooms, scallions and onions.

$7.29

Farmer's Omelette

sauteed onions, potatoes, ham, bacon and sausage.

$7.79

Florentine Omelette

spinach and feta cheese.

$7.79

Egg Benedict

No description available

$7.79

Eggs Benedict Florentine

No description available

$7.79

Spanish Omelette

No description available

$6.99

Griddle Cakes.

Golden Brown Griddle Cakes

No description available

$4.59

Short Stack

No description available

$3.59

Silver Dollar Pancakes

No description available

$4.99

Chocolate Chip Pancakes

No description available

$5.99

Blueberry Pancakes

No description available

$5.99

French Toast.

French Toast

dipped in rich egg batter and served with butter and syrup.

$5.29

Short Stack Of French Toast

No description available

$3.79

Belgian Waffer.

Crisp Golden Brown Waffles

any of the above griddle specialties with bacon, ham or sausage $2.29, with canadian style bacon $3.59, with one egg $0.79 extra, two eggs $1.59 extra with strawberries or blueberries and whipped cre

$5.29

Toast & Muffins.

Golden Brown Buttered Toast

with jelly.

$1.29

Cinnamon Toast (3 Slices)

No description available

$1.79

Toasted English Muffin

No description available

$1.79

Hard Roll

with butter.

$1.29

Assorted Danish

No description available

$2.59

Challah Toast (2 Slices)

No description available

$1.79

Muffin

(corn, blueberry or bran)

$1.79

Kid's Corner.

One Egg

with home fries and toast.

$3.29

Slice Of Challah Bread French Toast

with syrup or jelly

$3.29

Silver Dollar Pancakes (6)

with syrup or jelly.

$3.29

Bagel Bin.

Toasted Bagel

No description available

$1.79

Toasted Bagel

with cream cheese.

$2.79

Toasted Bagel

with nova lox & cream cheese.

$7.29

Toasted Bagel All Teh Way

with lox, cream cheese, lettuce, tomato, bormuda onion and olives.

$9.29

Menu.

Broiled Shrimp Scampi

on a bed rice with salad.

$19.99

Atherian Broiled Seafood Combination

fiot of sole, scallops, stuffed shrimp and stuffed clams served with potato, vegetable and salad.

$19.99

Sarb & Tarb

rub eye steak and two stuffed shrimp served with mushroom caps, potato, vegetable and salad.

$23.99

Stuffed Filet Of Sole Florentine

stuffed with feta cheese and spinach, served with potato, vegetable and salad.

$19.99

Broiled Stuffed Filet Of Sole

with crabmeat stuffing served with potato, vegetable and salad.

$19.99

Gyro

gyro slices on pita bread with tomato, onions and yogurt sauce.

$7.79

Chicken Souvlaki

on pita with onions, tomato and yogurt sauce.

$7.79

Pork Souvlaki

on pita onions, tomato with yogpurt sauce.

$7.79

Authentic Greek Specialties.

Moussaka

layers of food eggplant and ground beef baked with a cheese south topping, served with salad.

$13.99

Lamb Shish Ke-Bab

chunks of marinated lamb with onions, peppers and tomatoes, served on rice piaf with salad.

$15.99

Chicken Ala Greco

broiled in garlic butter sauce with herbs, smothered with fresh green peppers, onions, and tomatoes served on rice pilaf with salad.

$14.99

Pork Sourlaki Or Gyro Platter

gyro slices on pita with onions, tomato and yogurt sauce served with french fries and small greek salad.

$13.99

Dolmathes

stuffed grape leaves with potato salad, lettuce, tomato and lemon wedge.

$8.99

Sparakopita

homemade spinach pie. served with a small greek salad.

$10.99

Juices.

Orange Juice

No description available

$1.79 - $2.59

Tomato Juice

No description available

$1.79 - $2.59

Apple Juice

No description available

$1.79 - $2.59

Pineapple Juice

No description available

$1.79 - $2.59

Grapefruit Juice

No description available

$1.79 - $2.59

Ind. V-8 Juice

No description available

$1.79 - $2.59

Cranberry Juice

No description available

$1.79 - $2.59

Fresh Fruits.

Half Grapefruit

No description available

Fresh Melon

with scoop.

Cottage Cheese

No description available

$2.79

Fruit Salad

No description available

$2.99

Cereal.

Cereal

with milk.

$2.79

Hot Oatmeal

No description available

$2.79

Children's Menu.

Spaghetti

with one meatball.

$6.79

Chicken Or Tunafish Salad Sandwich

with french fries.

$6.79

Grilled Frank

with french fries.

$6.79

Roast Turkey

with french fries.

$7.59

Grilled Cheese

with french fries.

$6.79

Hamburger

with french fries.

$6.79

Fried Filet Of Sole

with french fries.

$7.59

Chicken Fingers

with french fries.

$6.79

Side Orders.

Bacon, Ham Or Sausage

No description available

$2.29

Canadian Style Bacon

No description available

$3.59

Corned Beef Hash

No description available

$3.79

Gyro (3 Slices)

No description available

$3.99

French Fries

No description available

$3.29

Home Fries

No description available

$2.99

Side Orders - 1.

French Fried Potatoes

No description available

$3.29

Home Fries

No description available

$3.29

Sweet Potato Fires

No description available

$4.99

Curly Fries

No description available

$4.99

Potato Salad

No description available

$2.69

Cole Slaw

No description available

$2.69

Onion Rings

No description available

$4.29

Vegetable Du jour

No description available

$2.69

Tossed Salad

No description available

$3.99

Spaghetti

with tomato sauce.

$4.99

Bacon Or Ham

No description available

$2.29

Sausage

No description available

$2.29

Canadian Style Bacon

No description available

$3.59

Feta Cheese

(imported)

$3.99

Corned Beef Hash

No description available

$3.79

Cottage Cheese

No description available

$3.59

Fountain Delights.

Milk Shakes

No description available

$4.29

Ice Cream Creations.

Fresh Ice Cream

vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, with strawberries $1.29 extra.

$2.79 - $3.79

Desserts.

Light Creamy Cheesecake

No description available

$3.99

Light Creamy Cheesecake

with fruit.

$4.59

Cream Pies

No description available

$3.29

Assorted Buttered Danish

No description available

$2.59

Ala Mode

No description available

$3.99

Coconut Custard Pie

No description available

$2.99

Strawberry Shortcake

No description available

$4.29

Lemon Meringue Pie

No description available

$3.29

Assorted Layer Cakes

No description available

$3.99

All Puddings

with whipped cream $0.59 extra.

$2.29

Jello

No description available

$2.29

Fruit Salad

No description available

$2.99

Melon

No description available

Beverages 1.

Coffee Or Tea

No description available

$1.69

Decaffeinated Coffee Or Tea

No description available

$1.69

Herbal Tea

No description available

$1.79

iced Tea

No description available

$1.49 - $1.79

Iced Coffee

No description available

$1.49 - $1.79

Hot Chocolate

No description available

$1.59

Hot Chocolate

No description available

$1.79

Milk

No description available

$1.49 - $1.79

Chocolate Milk

No description available

$1.59 - $1.89

Soda

No description available

$1.49 - $1.79

Bottled Water

No description available

$1.49

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading